Strategy 2023: Player X v Player Y

[Ironhawk]

X: Butters and Jake Lloyd
Y: Sicily and Andrew Brayshaw

Thanks all.

Can you still get Lloyd?

Prefer that combo based on what he scored.

 

[Monya Meow Meow]

Luke Ryan v Jack Sinclair as a trade in?

 

[Ironhawk]

Luke Ryan v Jack Sinclair as a trade in?

Sinclair.

 

[donnybuang]

Luke Ryan v Jack Sinclair as a trade in?

Sinclair

 

[Leroy]

For the coming week... Laird vs Macrae?

Ideally I want both eventually, but does Macrae become 'more' important if he gets DPP?

 

[Ironhawk]

For the coming week... Laird vs Macrae?

Ideally I want both eventually, but does Macrae become 'more' important if he gets DPP?

I'd have to see BE's to decide this one, but think Macrae will be better value. Seems to have improved his scoring in the last 2 rounds too.

 

[Montyjnr]

Fyfe vs Briggs

 

[Zim^zuM]

Wines vs ridley

 

[Ironhawk]

Fyfe vs Briggs

Briggs

Wines vs ridley

Ridley. Looks good value, but not sure I can go there myself.

 

[BarginHunter]

1. Wilmot to Ford
2. Day and Buckley to Ford and Briggs
3. Day and Buckley to Ford and Wardlaw
4. Day and Buckley to Ford and Premo

The only reason Day and Buckley are showing up so often is that they are losing cash by the day, whilst Wilmot, Ashcroft etc all have a bye and wont lose cash YET

Also have to keep Mitchell in mind as im hoping he hasn't been managed due to his ankle

 

[GrainFedBeef]

1. Wilmot to Ford
2. Day and Buckley to Ford and Briggs
3. Day and Buckley to Ford and Wardlaw
4. Day and Buckley to Ford and Premo

The only reason Day and Buckley are showing up so often is that they are losing cash by the day, whilst Wilmot, Ashcroft etc all have a bye and wont lose cash YET

Also have to keep Mitchell in mind as im hoping he hasn't been managed due to his ankle

Wilmot to Ford and Buckley to a Premium

 

[Russty_]

1. Wilmot to Ford
2. Day and Buckley to Ford and Briggs
3. Day and Buckley to Ford and Wardlaw
4. Day and Buckley to Ford and Premo

The only reason Day and Buckley are showing up so often is that they are losing cash by the day, whilst Wilmot, Ashcroft etc all have a bye and wont lose cash YET

Also have to keep Mitchell in mind as im hoping he hasn't been managed due to his ankle

Buckley's already lost most of the cash he's gonna lose, should maintain that price thereabouts from here, or maybe improve a bit if he can manage to stop acting like a spud.

 

[Ironhawk]

1. Wilmot to Ford
2. Day and Buckley to Ford and Briggs
3. Day and Buckley to Ford and Wardlaw
4. Day and Buckley to Ford and Premo

The only reason Day and Buckley are showing up so often is that they are losing cash by the day, whilst Wilmot, Ashcroft etc all have a bye and wont lose cash YET

Also have to keep Mitchell in mind as im hoping he hasn't been managed due to his ankle

Wilmot to Ford and Buckley to a Premium

This sounds a good option to me if you can. I seem to remember you having quite a few trades, so I'm sure you can make it work (3 trades available this round, 4 if you use a boost).

Of your 4 options, I'd definitely be trying to get a premo in. Briggs is a good trade in if you can afford a second to trade him out again at a profit (I can't really).

 

[Zimmer]

Wardlaw v Oisin

One is an expensive, injury risk with otherwise good JS and looks like he below at this level. (Bad bye)
The other a cheap, fit guy who looked pretty good, but JS is probably shaky. (Good bye.)

How much do we see Wardlaw making?

 

[Ironhawk]

Wardlaw v Oisin

One is an expensive, injury risk with otherwise good JS and looks like he below at this level. (Bad bye)
The other a cheap, fit guy who looked pretty good, but JS is probably shaky. (Good bye.)

How much do we see Wardlaw making?

Not sure Oisin survives past his bye, so Wardlaw by default.

Slow burn 70K or so is what I see him making.

 

[Scaries6.0]

Macrae v Stewart

 

[GrainFedBeef]

Macrae v Stewart

Stewart

Stewart - role certainty, history this year you can rely on and better bye. top end of his line.

Macrae - do you base decision on recent 140's or prior scoring, Treloar back and Bevo magnets.

round 15 when the donuts are coming people will panic trade sideways players due to Macrae type picks is my guess.

 

[Ironhawk]

Macrae v Stewart

Agree with Stewart here. Macrae seems value but I know I have massive Rd 15 issues which is my main negative with him, as he seems a bit underpriced still (but not out of range).

 

[Zim^zuM]

Ridley + the change vs Stewart?

A bit of context. Will end this round with 10 trades and 3 "upgrades" to make. 2 mids and a fwd. That would be counting day as a M8

 

[Ironhawk]

Ridley + the change vs Stewart?

A bit of context. Will end this round with 10 trades and 3 "upgrades" to make. 2 mids and a fwd. That would be counting day as a M8

Think you need to find a bit of value somewhere, and without seeing what other options you have for cash, Ridley is not the worst pick.