Strategy 2023: Player X v Player Y

[zac-ster]

Op 1 - Cincotta to Hewett - Seamus to Dawson
Op 2 - Cincotta to Harrison- Seamus to Dawson
Op 3 - Cincotta to Fletcher/Lohman Seamus to Sinclair

 

[Ironhawk]

Day vs Keays

Keays

Op 1 - Cincotta to Hewett - Seamus to Dawson
Op 2 - Cincotta to Harrison- Seamus to Dawson
Op 3 - Cincotta to Fletcher/Lohman Seamus to Sinclair

Op 3.

 

[inwhiterooms]

1. Windhager M9 cover for the year and Hayden Young D6 (Cincotta cover)
2. M. Johnson M9 cover for the year and Yeo D6 (Cincotta cover)

 

[Ironhawk]

1. Windhager M9 cover for the year and Hayden Young D6 (Cincotta cover)
2. M. Johnson M9 cover for the year and Yeo D6 (Cincotta cover)

If I could trust Yeo to play out the year, option 2. Depends on your level of risk based on that - conservative go for option 1, don't mind some risk - option 2. I'd probably punt on 2 myself, but it's not for everyone.

 

[Zim^zuM]

Humphrey vs Ashcroft to keep? Will still look to trade the other for M8 possibly to Mills

 

[Old Big 'Ead]

Humphrey vs Ashcroft to keep? Will still look to trade the other for M8 possibly to Mills

At this stage, Humphrey for me, at least until Touk is back.

 

[Ironhawk]

Humphrey vs Ashcroft to keep? Will still look to trade the other for M8 possibly to Mills

I think I probably prefer keeping Humphrey too, both have been great value though.

 

[BarginHunter]

Maric vs Harvey Harrison

 

[Ironhawk]

Maric vs Harvey Harrison

Maric, JS issues with HH.

 

[dlanod]

Darcy vs Merrett? Got Briggs on the bench ready to go for next week but that $50k drop for Darcy hits hard.

 

[mike89]

Sheldrick V Windhager

Who has best JS for the rest of the year to give DDP Cover with Dury

Im Thinking Windhager.?

One of these two or Fletcher? Purely as mid cover, have Mitchell for the other two lines.

 

[Ironhawk]

Darcy vs Merrett? Got Briggs on the bench ready to go for next week but that $50k drop for Darcy hits hard.

Hard to compare across lines. I'd expect Merrett to be the higher scorer of the two from here out, but you generally do expect mids to score more than rucks.

One of these two or Fletcher? Purely as mid cover, have Mitchell for the other two lines.

I was suggesting Sheldrick and Fletcher both be traded in to the combined team this week as I like both as options. Thinking Sheldrick is slightly the better of the two (although at a higher price), so I'd say Sheldrick.

 

[dlanod]

Hard to compare across lines. I'd expect Merrett to be the higher scorer of the two from here out, but you generally do expect mids to score more than rucks

I realised that trading Darcy out instead of someone who wasn't playing left with me 17 pending Chesser so I guess I'm taking the hit.

 

[Vicwood]

One of these two or Fletcher? Purely as mid cover, have Mitchell for the other two lines.

Yes.

 

[NT.Thunder]

Humphrey vs Ashcroft to keep? Will still look to trade the other for M8 possibly to Mills

At this stage, Humphrey for me, at least until Touk is back.

Maybe, but I think I'll let Humphrey go, Flanders back in the side gives me reason for some concern. That combined with Ashcroft having a known role and CBA minutes for the remainder of the year and we know at some stage Touk comes back and will impact HBB. I need to flip and hold one so I'll move Humphrey and keep Ashcroft.

 

[meataxe]

X: English and Callum Mills: or
Y: Briggs and Dawson

 

[Ironhawk]

X: English and Callum Mills: or
Y: Briggs and Dawson

Y. No real reason, gut feeling mainly.

 

[Zimmer]

Final spot in Defence: Dawson v Ryan and 75K

 

[Ironhawk]

Final spot in Defence: Dawson v Ryan and 75K

I was looking at these two teams a few days back and think I preferred the Crows run home, so I'll back in Dawson. If you will struggle to complete your team and need the cash, Ryan's not a bad pick though.

 

[Darkie]

Final spot in Defence: Dawson v Ryan and 75K

I’ll go Dawson. Better scorer and DPP could be handy.