Opinion Player X vs Player Y
- Thread starter yakka
- Start date
- Joined
- 22 Jan 2013
- Messages
- 3,858
- Likes
- 1,652
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
Simpson is proven but unknowns with new coach
Laird has just broken out and also has a new coach.
I'd go laird for the potential but it's a real tough line ball call.
Martin + Barlow will be prob 2+3 fwds behind lids I'm guessing but make sure you have cover coz he will be managed. This is also where I'm struggling but going lids,dusty,barlow fwd prems
Laird has just broken out and also has a new coach.
I'd go laird for the potential but it's a real tough line ball call.
Martin + Barlow will be prob 2+3 fwds behind lids I'm guessing but make sure you have cover coz he will be managed. This is also where I'm struggling but going lids,dusty,barlow fwd prems
?Made a significant change after thinking in an x vs y format.
T Mitchell, Lobbe, J Anderson, Barrett, Kommer, King and S Collins
vs
Mills, Goldstein, Hopper, Gresham, Cockatoo, Currie and Marcon (DPP swap)
Turned an overly strong midfield to a slightly more normal midfield setup (still way over most mid budgets though) and upgraded weak rookies.
Thoughts?
T Mitchell, Lobbe, J Anderson, Barrett, Kommer, King and S Collins
vs
Mills, Goldstein, Hopper, Gresham, Cockatoo, Currie and Marcon (DPP swap)
Turned an overly strong midfield to a slightly more normal midfield setup (still way over most mid budgets though) and upgraded weak rookies.
Thoughts?
Want to create a little more cash as I think a couple of the high end rookies (eg Callum Mills) may become must haves. Have come down to changing my midfield from Titchell to Wines OR forward line Dollhouse to Mitch Robinson.
Don't mind Robinson. I think he took a while to fit into the Brisbane team but he finished the season hard. Not convinced the big scores at the end were connected to Beams not being on the field as Rocky or Beams were in and out for much of the season and Robinsons scores were up and down until that streak at the end. Taking more of a leadership role as well so thinking he could push up to 100ppg. Preference is to boot Dollhouse atm. Thoughts?
Don't mind Robinson. I think he took a while to fit into the Brisbane team but he finished the season hard. Not convinced the big scores at the end were connected to Beams not being on the field as Rocky or Beams were in and out for much of the season and Robinsons scores were up and down until that streak at the end. Taking more of a leadership role as well so thinking he could push up to 100ppg. Preference is to boot Dollhouse atm. Thoughts?
- Joined
- 8 Jan 2014
- Messages
- 6,968
- Likes
- 11,084
- AFL Club
- Melbourne
I like the look of Wines and he is about $40k cheaper then TMitch
Dahl was great lest year, but I'm worried about his starting price and the impact of the return of Libba. I'm not starting him, but will monitor as a potential upgrade target.
Robinson is interesting. I don't have the guts to pick him, but if you have a good feeling then I think he could be a reasonable selection at about $500k
Dahl was great lest year, but I'm worried about his starting price and the impact of the return of Libba. I'm not starting him, but will monitor as a potential upgrade target.
Robinson is interesting. I don't have the guts to pick him, but if you have a good feeling then I think he could be a reasonable selection at about $500k
