Opinion Questions For Rowsus
- Thread starter Rowsus
- Start date
- Status
Hi Mm, thanks for the good words.
Docherty $512,700 B/E 38
McVeigh $472,800 B/E 122
Enright $470,300 B/E 68
Certainly, if you want Docherty, it would seem you get him this week, or leave him to one of your last upgrades, hoping he has come down in price again. I think he is a little over priced (102) for what he might produce from here. The most likely to miss a game or two from here is Enright, then McVeigh, then Docherty. On a week to week basis, Enright might be the best value option, but you will curse the games he get managed. I think if you can comfortably reach next weeks upgrade, then grab Docherty, otherwise grab Enright.
Docherty $512,700 B/E 38
McVeigh $472,800 B/E 122
Enright $470,300 B/E 68
Certainly, if you want Docherty, it would seem you get him this week, or leave him to one of your last upgrades, hoping he has come down in price again. I think he is a little over priced (102) for what he might produce from here. The most likely to miss a game or two from here is Enright, then McVeigh, then Docherty. On a week to week basis, Enright might be the best value option, but you will curse the games he get managed. I think if you can comfortably reach next weeks upgrade, then grab Docherty, otherwise grab Enright.
Thanks Row. Current bench (Laird, Adams / Menadue, Davis, Petracca / Wyatt / Wells, Uebergang) if that helps 
Things have now gotten a little tricky (and may get worse). Will now have Laird, Adams, Wells and GAJ on the bench so not sure if I should keep Brown for one more week as cover or just trust Tippa, DBJ and Ruggles to score well enough without a looping option.
With Adams...worth holding and still trading out Brown first? Will be keeping DBJ as I agree with you there.
If Barlow is ALSO out, then trading Kerridge is a harder decision as he is sitting at F5 and also compounds onto potentially keeping Brown an extra week as cover.
I guess I'm at a little but of an impasse...this week I think I need Priddis (due to GAJ being out)...but I'm not sure what way to go about trading him in. It looks as though I'll lose my degree of freedom M/F which I really don't like...but I guess there may be a chance to move Menadue/Petracca back there next week via another trade...
Would love to hear if you can come up with some scenarios for me that may work to my advantage
Things have now gotten a little tricky (and may get worse). Will now have Laird, Adams, Wells and GAJ on the bench so not sure if I should keep Brown for one more week as cover or just trust Tippa, DBJ and Ruggles to score well enough without a looping option.
With Adams...worth holding and still trading out Brown first? Will be keeping DBJ as I agree with you there.
If Barlow is ALSO out, then trading Kerridge is a harder decision as he is sitting at F5 and also compounds onto potentially keeping Brown an extra week as cover.
I guess I'm at a little but of an impasse...this week I think I need Priddis (due to GAJ being out)...but I'm not sure what way to go about trading him in. It looks as though I'll lose my degree of freedom M/F which I really don't like...but I guess there may be a chance to move Menadue/Petracca back there next week via another trade...
Would love to hear if you can come up with some scenarios for me that may work to my advantage
Adams isn't looking like a Keeper, has made good money, and you need to take action. I'd trade him out this week.
Even if Barlow makes it back into the team, his JS has to be highly questioned, now Freo are in re-build mode. I'd trade him out this week too.
Adams/Barlow ---> Priddis/Brand or MacPherson.
The only one of those 3 I'd be happy to bring in this week is Dahl.
Mundy needs to show he can score close to 110 consistently in his new sweeping halfback role, before we trade him in. Wingard needs an injury or two to get some Mid time, or needs to start kicking 3 or 4 goals each week. Robbo is Robbo. With Beams gone, he should score ok, but he is high risk.
Mundy needs to show he can score close to 110 consistently in his new sweeping halfback role, before we trade him in. Wingard needs an injury or two to get some Mid time, or needs to start kicking 3 or 4 goals each week. Robbo is Robbo. With Beams gone, he should score ok, but he is high risk.
- Joined
- 24 Apr 2013
- Messages
- 11,173
- Likes
- 13,044
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Hi Rowsus, had an interesting discussion with Stephen over in the trades thread.
Do you think it's worthwhile to bring in Wingard this week and play him as my F6/F7 for the rest of the year?
Zorko and Dahl are my prime trade-in targets so that leaves me with 1 spot left, I'm afraid I won't have enough money for someone like Joey.
Additional bonus is that I get Menadue off the field this week lolz.
Thoughts?
Do you think it's worthwhile to bring in Wingard this week and play him as my F6/F7 for the rest of the year?
Zorko and Dahl are my prime trade-in targets so that leaves me with 1 spot left, I'm afraid I won't have enough money for someone like Joey.
Additional bonus is that I get Menadue off the field this week lolz.
Thoughts?
While Wingard is a great price, I think you shouldn't be trading in players to play F6/7 right now. It's better to be getting players you are confident can fill a higher role.
I guess the exception might be, if you are short of Cash this week, and your team is looking weakish in this week of carnage, and Wingard is the only player you can afford, that gives you a boost in an important match up, you might do it. Otherwise, trading in a player you expect to be on your bench at the end of the season is a bit wasteful.
I guess the exception might be, if you are short of Cash this week, and your team is looking weakish in this week of carnage, and Wingard is the only player you can afford, that gives you a boost in an important match up, you might do it. Otherwise, trading in a player you expect to be on your bench at the end of the season is a bit wasteful.
Hey mate, just wondering if you could have a look at my team and see what trades you can come up with. I have 280k in the bank and i'm thinking about one up (Priddis/JJK) and one down (Williams/Mathieson/Hopper) or possibly trading out Martin/Jacobs to get Goldy along with an upgrade.
If you want, come up with something out of the box.
Thanks.
If you want, come up with something out of the box.
Thanks.
Hey anfa18,
Eagling is correct, I can only see your 22 scoring players from Rnd 9.
Here is some info that might help you decide, or just confuse you even further!
I'm liking JJK to get a big score this week. Here is what KPP Fwds have done against GC in the last 4 rounds:
Lynch T - 133 - Season high. ave 89 in his other 7 games this season. Up 49% on season ave Vs GC
Walker A - 119 - Season high. ave 69 in his other 8 games this season. Up 72% on season ave Vs GC
Cameron - 143 - Season high. ave 70 in his other 4 games this season. Up 104% on season ave Vs GC
Hogan - 45 - no idea how it went this bad for him.
Hawkins - 140 - Season high. ave 73 in his other 8 games this season. Up 92% on season ave Vs GC
Kersten - 106 - Season high. ave 65 in his other 7 games this season. Up 63% on season ave Vs GC
So 5 of the last 6 KPP fwd's to play GC have recorded seasons high, and have scored at an average of 76% higher than what their season average was, excluding the GC game. JJK has a season high of 180, and is averaging 108. If the baby's been born, he could go 190 this week, if these figures are anything to go by! More realistically, I am expecting him to go at least 130+ this week! I'd love to make him VC, but they play last!
GC haven't been giving up scores to Mids that translate as high as the KPP Fwds, in relative terms. Recent scores are: Sloane 95, Scully 121, Shiel 120, Coniglio 118, Jones 137, Viney 92, Selwood 138, Dangerfield 132. We can expect a good score from Priddis, but it would seem if someone is going to go nuts, it's more likely to be JJK this week.
Upgrading one of Martin/Jacobs to Goldy is nearly a this week, or last upgrade you make proposition.
Goldy $574,800 B/E 66
Martin $458,300 B/E 143
Jacobs $465,400 B/E 100
Given Brisbane are "experimenting" with West, and Martin just isn't gathering 20 possessions like he was last season, I'd use Martin. The changeover is currently $109,400. Let's assume Goldy scores 110 against Sydney this week, and Martin scores 75 against Hawthorn. That will blow the changeover out to $158,700 next week. It's starting to get out to a full Rookie upgrade price. Unless you are prepared to wait for either Goldy to have an injury score, and come down in price again, or until you've nearly completed your team, it's now or much later.
If you want a POD, take JJK. If you want consistency, and to close a negative POD, take Goldy. I'd take Goldy.
Eagling is correct, I can only see your 22 scoring players from Rnd 9.
Here is some info that might help you decide, or just confuse you even further!
I'm liking JJK to get a big score this week. Here is what KPP Fwds have done against GC in the last 4 rounds:
Lynch T - 133 - Season high. ave 89 in his other 7 games this season. Up 49% on season ave Vs GC
Walker A - 119 - Season high. ave 69 in his other 8 games this season. Up 72% on season ave Vs GC
Cameron - 143 - Season high. ave 70 in his other 4 games this season. Up 104% on season ave Vs GC
Hogan - 45 - no idea how it went this bad for him.
Hawkins - 140 - Season high. ave 73 in his other 8 games this season. Up 92% on season ave Vs GC
Kersten - 106 - Season high. ave 65 in his other 7 games this season. Up 63% on season ave Vs GC
So 5 of the last 6 KPP fwd's to play GC have recorded seasons high, and have scored at an average of 76% higher than what their season average was, excluding the GC game. JJK has a season high of 180, and is averaging 108. If the baby's been born, he could go 190 this week, if these figures are anything to go by! More realistically, I am expecting him to go at least 130+ this week! I'd love to make him VC, but they play last!
GC haven't been giving up scores to Mids that translate as high as the KPP Fwds, in relative terms. Recent scores are: Sloane 95, Scully 121, Shiel 120, Coniglio 118, Jones 137, Viney 92, Selwood 138, Dangerfield 132. We can expect a good score from Priddis, but it would seem if someone is going to go nuts, it's more likely to be JJK this week.
Upgrading one of Martin/Jacobs to Goldy is nearly a this week, or last upgrade you make proposition.
Goldy $574,800 B/E 66
Martin $458,300 B/E 143
Jacobs $465,400 B/E 100
Given Brisbane are "experimenting" with West, and Martin just isn't gathering 20 possessions like he was last season, I'd use Martin. The changeover is currently $109,400. Let's assume Goldy scores 110 against Sydney this week, and Martin scores 75 against Hawthorn. That will blow the changeover out to $158,700 next week. It's starting to get out to a full Rookie upgrade price. Unless you are prepared to wait for either Goldy to have an injury score, and come down in price again, or until you've nearly completed your team, it's now or much later.
If you want a POD, take JJK. If you want consistency, and to close a negative POD, take Goldy. I'd take Goldy.
Hi freowho,
I'd love to help you, but no I haven't done that this season. I agree Martin doesn't look right, so I'm going to go Martin to Goldy this week, like I should have last week! He's not handling the ball like a tall Midfielder this season. He seemed to do that last season. His Ruckwork seems below his level of last season too. He could bounce back, but his price and B/E ($458,300 B/E 143) nearly make it move him this week, or ride him out.
I'd love to help you, but no I haven't done that this season. I agree Martin doesn't look right, so I'm going to go Martin to Goldy this week, like I should have last week!
He's not handling the ball like a tall Midfielder this season. He seemed to do that last season. His Ruckwork seems below his level of last season too. He could bounce back, but his price and B/E ($458,300 B/E 143) nearly make it move him this week, or ride him out.
- Joined
- 13 Nov 2014
- Messages
- 369
- Likes
- 529
- AFL Club
- Port Adelaide
Hey Rowsus,
Wondering what your take is on Tom Mitchell?
Like many, I brought him in early and have since been either crying or screaming into my pillow at night.
Bar dealing with other injury issues, is it time to cut and run on him?
I know there is tagging and there is running with, not sure if he has been doing one or the other but none of it looks pretty.
Appreciate your insight.
Wondering what your take is on Tom Mitchell?
Like many, I brought him in early and have since been either crying or screaming into my pillow at night.
Bar dealing with other injury issues, is it time to cut and run on him?
I know there is tagging and there is running with, not sure if he has been doing one or the other but none of it looks pretty.
Appreciate your insight.
- Status