Opinion Player X vs. Player Y
- Thread starter Darkie
- Start date
- Joined
- 3 Jul 2017
- Messages
- 38,963
- Likes
- 126,636
- AFL Club
- Port Adelaide
Greatly appreciate some advice on the following conundrum on which is the better combination
A. L Whitfield (D2), D Roberton (D4) and T Liberatore (M6)
VS
B. L Whitfield (D2), J Darling (F3) and rookie
VS
C. H Andrews (D2), D Mundy (F3), rookie
Current premiums/mid pricers above the Roberton and Libba range are:
R Laird, Z Williams, N Fyfe, J Kelly, L Neale, Z Merrett, R Sloane, B Grundy, T Goldstein, P Dangerfield, I Heeney and T Greene.
D Roberton and T Liberatore will likely be utilised as quick avenues to K Simpson/H Andrews and C Oliver/P Cripps.
Hard to split B and C as B looks like the most upside but C should be the most consistent. I really want to give H Andrews a 2nd chance as he only survived 1/2 a quarter in my side last season but it means I would have to forego L Whitfield.
A. L Whitfield (D2), D Roberton (D4) and T Liberatore (M6)
VS
B. L Whitfield (D2), J Darling (F3) and rookie
VS
C. H Andrews (D2), D Mundy (F3), rookie
Current premiums/mid pricers above the Roberton and Libba range are:
R Laird, Z Williams, N Fyfe, J Kelly, L Neale, Z Merrett, R Sloane, B Grundy, T Goldstein, P Dangerfield, I Heeney and T Greene.
D Roberton and T Liberatore will likely be utilised as quick avenues to K Simpson/H Andrews and C Oliver/P Cripps.
Hard to split B and C as B looks like the most upside but C should be the most consistent. I really want to give H Andrews a 2nd chance as he only survived 1/2 a quarter in my side last season but it means I would have to forego L Whitfield.
B to be safe, A if you want to risk Roberton.
I'm edgy on Roberton because I think he could miss games and leave you with a D7 score (which by the rookies looks like it could be a 40-50 ie. bad).
Mundy will start ok I think (around 100 even) but will tail away as others return from injury and move back into midfield. I also think Andrews is a nearly but not quite premium, whereas I think Darling could have some spike scores that allow for some interesting trades.
I'm edgy on Roberton because I think he could miss games and leave you with a D7 score (which by the rookies looks like it could be a 40-50 ie. bad).
Mundy will start ok I think (around 100 even) but will tail away as others return from injury and move back into midfield. I also think Andrews is a nearly but not quite premium, whereas I think Darling could have some spike scores that allow for some interesting trades.
