Discussion NRL SuperCoach Discussion

Connoisseur

Leadership Group
Joined
3 Jul 2017
Messages
38,963
Likes
126,636
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
If anyone is able to find the time I would love some feedback on my team. At the moment, I've just tried to throw all my money into my onfield players so my main concern is that I don't have much to work with on my bench and playing reserves. Someone please let me know if this is a terrible idea.

Cook (Brailey)
Fifita, Lane (Napa*, Host)
Jurbo, Arrow, Murray (Capewell*, Garner, Burr*)
Morgan (Keighran)
Ponga (Brown)
Marsters, Croker, Bateman, Nikora (Garrick, Ravalawa, Allan)
Teddy (Nicoll-Klockstad*)

Another option I have is to downgrade Cook to Hodgson and Ponga to Walker which allows me to pick up Holland as my sub hooker, which gives me a decent bench player.
Is that J Brailey or B Brailey. If B Brailey an option could be
Out: D Cook, B Brailey, L Garner
In: J Friend, K Holland, J Tatola
Allowing K Holland to be the reserve instead of L Burr.

Apart from that very hard to fault the rest of your selections.
 
Joined
24 Nov 2018
Messages
444
Likes
1,078
AFL Club
GWS Giants
Is that J Brailey or B Brailey. If B Brailey an option could be
Out: D Cook, B Brailey, L Garner
In: J Friend, K Holland, J Tatola
Allowing K Holland to be the reserve instead of L Burr.

Apart from that very hard to fault the rest of your selections.
Yeah its B Brailey, only thing that concerns me is that Tatola loses his starting spot round 3 when George Burgess returns
 

Connoisseur

Leadership Group
Joined
3 Jul 2017
Messages
38,963
Likes
126,636
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
Yeah its B Brailey, only thing that concerns me is that Tatola loses his starting spot round 3 when George Burgess returns
How much do you have remaining salary as the last section of the trade was proposed if you had less than 20,000 to 30,000 to allow the 2 aforementioned trades.
 

KLo30

Leadership Group
Joined
27 Jan 2014
Messages
18,104
Likes
52,784
AFL Club
North Melb.
If anyone is able to find the time I would love some feedback on my team. At the moment, I've just tried to throw all my money into my onfield players so my main concern is that I don't have much to work with on my bench and playing reserves. Someone please let me know if this is a terrible idea.

Cook (Brailey)
Fifita, Lane (Napa*, Host)
Jurbo, Arrow, Murray (Capewell*, Garner, Burr*)
Morgan (Keighran)
Ponga (Brown)
Marsters, Croker, Bateman, Nikora (Garrick, Ravalawa, Allan)
Teddy (Nicoll-Klockstad*)

Another option I have is to downgrade Cook to Hodgson and Ponga to Walker which allows me to pick up Holland as my sub hooker, which gives me a decent bench player.
Yes, to Hodgson and Holland as hookers. Allan and Burr are concerns, so maybe Sivo and Ravalawa instead. NCK and Kahu are options at CTW opening up more dollars elsewhere.
 
Joined
24 Nov 2018
Messages
444
Likes
1,078
AFL Club
GWS Giants
How much do you have remaining salary as the last section of the trade was proposed if you had less than 20,000 to 30,000 to allow the 2 aforementioned trades.
If I go Cook to Friend and Brailey to Holland that leaves me with 336k or 226k if I go with Hodgson instead (I think thats what you're asking me)
 
Joined
24 Nov 2018
Messages
444
Likes
1,078
AFL Club
GWS Giants
Yes, to Hodgson and Holland as hookers. Allan and Burr are concerns, so maybe Sivo and Ravalawa instead. NCK and Kahu are options at CTW opening up more dollars elsewhere.
Thank you for reminding me of Sivo. Was pretty keen on him.
 

KLo30

Leadership Group
Joined
27 Jan 2014
Messages
18,104
Likes
52,784
AFL Club
North Melb.
@Melmo We are all able to fill leagues if you and others need players. Please post league codes and I'm sure there will be multiple teams jumping in.
 

Connoisseur

Leadership Group
Joined
3 Jul 2017
Messages
38,963
Likes
126,636
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
If I go Cook to Friend and Brailey to Holland that leaves me with 336k or 226k if I go with Hodgson instead (I think thats what you're asking me)
Then select Hodgson over Friend and utilise the 226,000 by upgrading one of K Capewell/D Napa/ L Garner.
 
Joined
24 Nov 2018
Messages
444
Likes
1,078
AFL Club
GWS Giants
Then select Hodgson over Friend and utilise the 226,000 by upgrading one of K Capewell/D Napa/ L Garner.
No sorry I meant I had that 226k to spend on my last player which looks like Tatola as he is the only one I can afford that is playing with Hodgson at Hooker.
 
Joined
24 Nov 2018
Messages
444
Likes
1,078
AFL Club
GWS Giants
@Melmo We are all able to fill leagues if you and others need players. Please post league codes and I'm sure there will be multiple teams jumping in.
At the moment I'm only in 4 or 5 but they're all full. Will probably jump in a bunch more tomorrow and let you all know
 

Connoisseur

Leadership Group
Joined
3 Jul 2017
Messages
38,963
Likes
126,636
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
No sorry I meant I had that 226k to spend on my last player which looks like Tatola as he is the only one I can afford that is playing with Hodgson at Hooker.
Thanks. Sounds like a good combination and a solid 17.
 

KLo30

Leadership Group
Joined
27 Jan 2014
Messages
18,104
Likes
52,784
AFL Club
North Melb.
No sorry I meant I had that 226k to spend on my last player which looks like Tatola as he is the only one I can afford that is playing with Hodgson at Hooker.
Tatola has a good opportunity for 3 weeks.
 

KLo30

Leadership Group
Joined
27 Jan 2014
Messages
18,104
Likes
52,784
AFL Club
North Melb.
The Mastermind’s ultimate POD squad revealed
The Mastermind, The Courier-Mail
Are you a little worried your team looks like everybody elses? Did your sneaky POD suddenly shoot from single digit ownership to double digits over night? Perhaps you’re just a contrarian and want to argue the merits of lesser owned and hyped players.
Pick a few of these players in your team so you can smugly say “I had them before they were cool”.
THE MASTERMIND’S 2019 TEAM REVEALED
SIGN UP TO SUPERCOACH NOW BEFORE IT’S TOO LATE!

Here’s the MasterMind’s ultimate POD squad: 13 players that have single digit ownership before the season kicks-off.
HOOKER:
JAKE FRIEND: $481,500, 7% owned
He’s in my team as a back-up to Damien Cook. Friend has hovered around the 60PPG average most of his career. Last year he averaged 51.5PPG after playing reduced minutes until Origin was over. Once he strung 80 minute performances together he averaged 68.5PPG in seven games. If you think Cook is too expensive, Cameron Smith is too old and Josh Hodgson can’t possibly replicate the attacking points from last year, Friend could be your friend.
PROPS:
JOSH PAPALII: $595,900, 9% owned
Papalii averaged 63.7 last year, 66 in 2017, 62.8 in 2016. He’s set for a permanent move into the middle where he’ll have a feast of base points. He’s one of the few players in this position who consistently finds the tryline. He’s scored 17 tries in 64 games over the past three years, bettered by just one player, the next on our list. Is also a dual 2RF.
RYAN JAMES: $585,800, 7% owned
Hasn’t quite reached the heights of his incredible breakout season in 2016 where he scored 11 tries and averaged 72.9PPG as the third best player in the game. He averaged 62.6PPG in 2018 and 59.7PPG in 2017. He’s been moved to the left edge and that seems to be turning people off. Knows how to find the line with 20 tries in his last three seasons. Is also a dual 2RF.
SECOND ROWERS
JOSEPH TAPINE: $590,100, 3% owned
Had the 8th best average for backrowers in 2018. He averaged 63PPG in his first season as an 80min player and had two-try efforts of 112 and 138 against the Tigers. Just for the record the Raiders play the Tigers in Round 13 and 18 this year.
NATHAN BROWN: $582,000, 7% owned
It’s a tale of two Browns at the Eels, Dylan Brown has 60% ownership and rising, poor Nathan Brown is sitting at just 7%. Since he joined the Eels in 2017 he’s had 64.6PPG and last year 62.2PPG. He’s only scored one try in each of those seasons. He’s a pure base stats machine.
FELISE KAUFUSI: $565,100, 3% owned
The Storm backrower missed Cooper Cronk more than any player to start last season with a pre-Origin average of 53. Once he settled into those new combinations he came home with an average of 67.7PPG after Origin. If he carries that sort of form into this season he’ll be among the top backrowers.
HALFBACK
DALY CHERRY-EVANS: $577,400, 7% owned
I’m still scratching my head how he’s so low. He was last year’s top scoring halfback with 1481 points, 300 clear of the next best. He had an average equal to Nathan Cleary, with only Shaun Johnson ahead of him on 64.4PPG. He’s backed up the same average from 2017. His durability is also worth factoring in. Cherry Evans has played every game of the past two seasons. SJ who has only played 36 games out of 48 the past two seasons.
FIVE-EIGHTH
ANTHONY MILFORD: $511,900, 6% owned
Coming off his worst SuperCoach season ever 54.7PPG. Will he bounce back to a mid 60s average? Milford had to take on the bulk of the organisational duties for the Broncos last year with Ben Hunt gone. You could see the weight of that burden on his game. The Rabbitohs left edge was lethal last year. If Anthony Seibold gets the Broncos firing in the same way, Milford will be in the thick of the points again.
CENTRE/WINGERS
WILL HOPOATE: $556,000, 2% owned
The Bulldog’s little brother Albert had all the pre-season hype as a potential cash cow at Manly, but if you want the proven article here’s the Hopper for you. Will had 1426 points in 2018, the third highest scoring in the position and 5th best average. That was with just 5 tries in 24 games. He managed 58.9PPG in 2017 with 3 tries in 18 games.
JOSEPH MANU: $410,500, 7% owned
A rocky start to 2018 means he’s well undervalued with a price based on 43.9PPG. He found confidence mid-season and finished last year with an 8-game average of 62.2PPG. Developed a great combination with Blake Ferguson last year, who’s moved to the Eels, but with Cronk, James Tedesco and Angus Crichton playing inside him those attacking points should keep flowing.
JOSH DUGAN: $497,400, 1% owned
Just look what David Fusitua did playing outside of Shaun Johnson last year, before that Bodene Thompson. When you’ve got the best attacking half in the game inside you the points will flow. Dugan had 6 tries in 13 games last year for an average of 53.2PPG. 3 tries in 17 games in 2017 at 58.8PPG. There’s big room for improvement here and he’ll have the service. The downside? He’s only played 30 of a possible 48 games the past two seasons.
DANE GAGAI: $497,400, 4% owned
The move to the wing means a lot more runs (especially from kick returns) and tackle busts. You’ve seen what he does on the wing for Queensland in Origin — eight tries in nine games. He’s playing outside Greg Inglis and Sam Burgess. There should be plenty of space for him out wide with those two keeping defenders busy.
FULLBACK:
CONNOR WATSON: $537,100, 2% owned
There’s so much talk about Kalyn Ponga that everyone’s forgetting the other dual position fullback/five-eighth at the Knights. Remove two injury affected scores of 5 and 15 from last year’s stats and you’re looking at 65PPG player Connor Watson.
 
Joined
1 Mar 2013
Messages
126
Likes
180
AFL Club
Brisbane
Can someone please post an article (If there is one) similar to what they have in AFL Supercoach... "Pick three of these, pick one of these, pick him" etc.

Don't really know my NRL SC too well... but have been sucked in to joining the office comp.
 

Connoisseur

Leadership Group
Joined
3 Jul 2017
Messages
38,963
Likes
126,636
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
Can someone please post an article (If there is one) similar to what they have in AFL Supercoach... "Pick three of these, pick one of these, pick him" etc.

Don't really know my NRL SC too well... but have been sucked in to joining the office comp.
On the first page on the forum there are articles pertaining to rookie and premium selections from early in the preseason and there are a wealth of articles from NRL Supercoach Talk (https://www.nrlsupercoachtalk.com/) regarding selections.
 
Top