Opinion Player X vs. Player Y

[Ironhawk]

Fyfe v TKelly v Gaff?

On recent scoring Kelly. On past history and proven scoring potential, Fyfe.

...I'll say Gaff. Not sure why, just think he can get back his early season form and be the best of these 3 from here on.

 

[Connoisseur]

Fyfe v TKelly v Gaff?

In that order.

Prefer T Kelly over A Gaff but if you already possess Yeo then select Fyfe. Also only 2/9 above 105 for T Kelly this season but I would think it’s unlikely he dishes up multiple scores under 75 again for the remainder of the season.

 

[jel]

Woodcock or Wicks

Looking at maybe one, possibly both, depending on selection etc.
Woodcock was iffy with js, but has his game against the tigers given him a few weeks?

 

[Ironhawk]

Woodcock or Wicks

Looking at maybe one, possibly both, depending on selection etc.
Woodcock was iffy with js, but has his game against the tigers given him a few weeks?

Splinter did look good against Richmond, didn't look out of place. Woodcock would be stiff to miss the next match after that performance (pun noted).

Wicks also looked good, but not sure that his JS is much better.

I guess it comes down to position and price at this point. Wouldn't be fielding either except to cover byes, both look equally promising. Maybe Wicks, as he hasn't had a price rise yet and has had his bye if you were only targeting one, but both look like consistent 50-60ish scorers to me.

 

[Tamuhawk]

Fyfe v TKelly v Gaff?

In the order you listed. Fyfe!

 

[Deeman1]

In the order you listed. Fyfe!

Cheers, Tam, thats the directiion I went, I can blame you now too, when it all goes pear shaped !

 

[Monya Meow Meow]

Probably needs a crystal ball for this one but...

Trey Ruscoe v Lachlan Sholl as my D7 for the remainder of the season, thanks

 

[Ironhawk]

Probably needs a crystal ball for this one but...

Trey Ruscoe v Lachlan Sholl as my D7 for the remainder of the season, thanks

If they are on the bench rather than on field and you are keeping them all season rather than selling later, go for Ruscoe as he is a few thousand cheaper.

 

[Monya Meow Meow]

If they are on the bench rather than on field and you are keeping them all season rather than selling later, go for Ruscoe as he is a few thousand cheaper.

Thanks mate

 

[nath_99]

Fyfe v Merrett v Coniglio v Taranto ... last midfield spot.

Currently have Neale, Macrae, Mitchell, Danger, Cripps, Miller, McGrath and whichever rookie can find his way from the hub to the ground and get on the field! (currently simpson)

Thanks

 

[Ironhawk]

Fyfe v Merrett v Coniglio v Taranto ... last midfield spot.

Currently have Neale, Macrae, Mitchell, Danger, Cripps, Miller, McGrath and whichever rookie can find his way from the hub to the ground and get on the field! (currently simpson)

Thanks

Leaning to Fyfe after seeing him last night. Even spending a lot of time forward he got 130. Seems good value.

 

[nath_99]

Leaning to Fyfe after seeing him last night. Even spending a lot of time forward he got 130. Seems good value.

Thanks mate

 

[Crabby Skills]

Fyfe v Merrett v Coniglio v Taranto ... last midfield spot.

Currently have Neale, Macrae, Mitchell, Danger, Cripps, Miller, McGrath and whichever rookie can find his way from the hub to the ground and get on the field! (currently simpson)

Thanks

oooo Touk in there nice.

I'm getting Fyfe fwiw cause I <3 him. Second pref is Taranto from them - doubt he'll get a rest.

 

[Tamuhawk]

Boak vs Shiel

 

[Eagling]

Another upgrade, and sadly time for a premature goodbye to Simpson and Serong.

But sort've at a crossroads for my 7th mid: Fyfe v Titch?

 

[Tamuhawk]

Another upgrade, and sadly time for a premature goodbye to Simpson and Serong.

But sort've at a crossroads for my 7th mid: Fyfe v Titch?

Fyfe!

 

[Goodie's Guns]

Another upgrade, and sadly time for a premature goodbye to Simpson and Serong.

But sort've at a crossroads for my 7th mid: Fyfe v Titch?

I think Titch will be fine to see out the season (traded him in myself last round).
But Fyfe for sure, even with time spent forward he's a gun and an SC machine.

 

[Ironhawk]

Boak vs Shiel

Tough. Boak has been frustrating to own for the last month or so prior to this round, but apart from that, he has been good. Half Shiel's scores this season have been 81 or less which you don't want (but he has had his bye, Boak hasn't).

I would say Boak seems a bit less frustrating of the two, but would rather look elsewhere if possible.

Another upgrade, and sadly time for a premature goodbye to Simpson and Serong.

But sort've at a crossroads for my 7th mid: Fyfe v Titch?

The one that doesn't play for Hawthorn. Fyfe easy.

 

[Tamuhawk]

Tough. Boak has been frustrating to own for the last month or so prior to this round, but apart from that, he has been good. Half Shiel's scores this season have been 81 or less which you don't want (but he has had his bye, Boak hasn't).

I would say Boak seems a bit less frustrating of the two, but would rather look elsewhere if possible.


The one that doesn't play for Hawthorn. Fyfe easy.

Only got 475k to get a mid so those 2 are my best options at that price so not possible to look elsewhere unless I dig even lower. Will lean towards Boak. Cheers @Ironhawk.

 

[Ironhawk]

Only got 475k to get a mid so those 2 are my best options at that price so not possible to look elsewhere unless I dig even lower. Will lean towards Boak. Cheers @Ironhawk.

Fair enough. Not a lot at that price range, true, unless you go for say a Ladhams via DPP or possibly Billings (1K over your price range at 476K). Boak looks the best bet to me.