I like the looks of Redman, just dont know much about him
Vs
Dale i know a little about as he's been himself all season
Vs
Brayshaw who is in the same boat as Redman which is a POD but dont know why hes going off lately. Frok what ive heard its a similar Dawson/Laird situation (defender turned midfielder and it worked so far)
I feel Brayshaw and Redman have the higher ceilings but also the lower floors
Whereas Dale is the safe option
Redman: Ignoring the game where he got subbed out, his last 7 scores have been 99+, 3 of them 7 140+. On that form, I'd accept a floor of 99, but yes, he could revert, and might chuck in a 60, who knows.
Brayshaw: Not scoring quite as high, but a good chance of 100-125, floor a bit lower as mentioned, not a terrible pick.
Dale: Definitely more consistent as you mentioned, probably closer to a 90-115 scorer.
I still prefer Redman, but I'm biased as I chose him as a POD 2 weeks back and I'm ignoring his sub game, based on coming back with a 176 the next game.