Discussion BBL|12: Planning Thread

Which of the more expensive players on a double do you have for round 1?

  • M Short

    Votes: 38 55.1%
  • R Khan

    Votes: 68 98.6%
  • Boult

    Votes: 23 33.3%
  • Sams

    Votes: 66 95.7%
  • J Sangha

    Votes: 16 23.2%
  • Thornton

    Votes: 1 1.4%
  • Clarke

    Votes: 24 34.8%
  • Siddle

    Votes: 36 52.2%
  • Sandhu

    Votes: 5 7.2%
  • Doggett

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    69
Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
9 Feb 2015
Messages
9,440
Likes
57,908
AFL Club
West Coast
Don't think I can look anymore , just hurry up and start so I can lock it in

MS - Boult , Stoinis , Webster , Zampa
ST - Gilkes , Green , Hales , Rossouw , Sams

Pending Final XI's
Wasn't there an issue with his bowling action/getting investigated again or was that just an unfounded rumour in the end?
 
Joined
20 Dec 2016
Messages
10,769
Likes
52,333
AFL Club
Carlton
Think this is my seventh time doing this and I've never been so uncertain about a starting side 24 hours out. Got several spots where I just have no idea what I'm doing, and my bench doesn't look like anything I've ever played before... Anyone else in the same boat?
 
Joined
11 Dec 2019
Messages
226
Likes
843

Think this is the happiest I'm going to be with. Normally my benches are much cheaper as I wanna get my value on the field but with this season being so undecided and so much value for cheap I have shifted to more value on the bench as a security measure. Agar and Tye are my two certains for the scorchers so I feel most safe with them and am happy to sacrifice value for R1 to avoid issues in R2 and 3. Hosein is my pick to potentially gain an extra for round 5 where i think he will be more expensive whilst having no byes and can sit as extra protection against the random weather/injury if need be.
- I'm not happy with Gilkes but think he for price and 4 goes at it for R1+2 is worthwhile and given my bench cover can be benched or moved on next round with relative ease if required.
- Would prefer to move Wood at to Bat and have Farooqi over Rossouw but there are issues with this; 1. Stu*** up my loop where Hosein can cover with CDG swithcing with connolly, 2. Rossouw has better JS 3. Rossouw, Hales, Gilkes are my only true batters which are less consistent but missing rossouw if he gets a big score in any of the 4 innings will be fairly devastating for R1+2
- I have really tried to target as many overs as possible as probably indicated by my preference of bowlers.
- Wood is my key POD for R1 where he is a worse bowler than Boult HOWEVER has been indicated to bowl at better times, should have a better chance of swinging the bat and is 75K cheaper with DPP.
- 55K is spare but there isnt any change I like where I could use the money to upgrade, Stoinis and Zampa have been in my team through the 4000 variations, Wood I like, green is the only guaratee for ST, CDG should have an excellent role and I cant upgrade rossouw to M short or Sangha and Gilkes/inglis cant become Billings or Phillipe so.
Any thoughts are appreciated, especially any holes or disagreements the more perspectives the better.
 

Attachments

Joined
2 Dec 2017
Messages
32
Likes
40
Boyce injury news is a bit subjective but if he is doing low intensity running I would say he is expected back in probably 2-3 weeks. As a spin bowler he probably can come back earlier than a quick.
 
Joined
3 Oct 2022
Messages
639
Likes
1,905
AFL Club
Collingwood
Toby Gray in the squad gives me some confidence, looks a reasonable chance they just pick him if they want 2 spinners.
The question still remains for me of what they go with for their bowling attack? You'd think Sams, Green, Sandhu are in with Farooq as variety of the left arm bowler which leaves a choice between Doggett and McAndrew as the 5th bowler (Cutting/Sangha to make up 6th if needed). McAndrew was one of their better bowlers last season but I have no confidence in what Thunder will go with in 1st 4 games? Good luck🤞🤞🤞
 
Joined
8 Jan 2020
Messages
6,265
Likes
26,158
AFL Club
Geelong
The question still remains for me of what they go with for their bowling attack? You'd think Sams, Green, Sandhu are in with Farooq as variety of the left arm bowler which leaves a choice between Doggett and McAndrew as the 5th bowler (Cutting/Sangha to make up 6th if needed). McAndrew was one of their better bowlers last season but I have no confidence in what Thunder will go with in 1st 4 games? Good luck🤞🤞🤞
I rate Doggett pretty highly think if he misses out Game 1 it wont be long before he gets a game.
 
Joined
25 Jul 2012
Messages
47,729
Likes
107,811
AFL Club
Collingwood
Why XV ?

That's a damn hard team to select , you would only pick Farooqi , Green , Hales , Rossouw , Sams & Sangha as certain starters.

That's 6 , add a keeper and any of the remaining (less the other keeper) you could make a case for playing.
 
Joined
25 Jul 2012
Messages
47,729
Likes
107,811
AFL Club
Collingwood

Think this is the happiest I'm going to be with. Normally my benches are much cheaper as I wanna get my value on the field but with this season being so undecided and so much value for cheap I have shifted to more value on the bench as a security measure. Agar and Tye are my two certains for the scorchers so I feel most safe with them and am happy to sacrifice value for R1 to avoid issues in R2 and 3. Hosein is my pick to potentially gain an extra for round 5 where i think he will be more expensive whilst having no byes and can sit as extra protection against the random weather/injury if need be.
- I'm not happy with Gilkes but think he for price and 4 goes at it for R1+2 is worthwhile and given my bench cover can be benched or moved on next round with relative ease if required.
- Would prefer to move Wood at to Bat and have Farooqi over Rossouw but there are issues with this; 1. Stu*** up my loop where Hosein can cover with CDG swithcing with connolly, 2. Rossouw has better JS 3. Rossouw, Hales, Gilkes are my only true batters which are less consistent but missing rossouw if he gets a big score in any of the 4 innings will be fairly devastating for R1+2
- I have really tried to target as many overs as possible as probably indicated by my preference of bowlers.
- Wood is my key POD for R1 where he is a worse bowler than Boult HOWEVER has been indicated to bowl at better times, should have a better chance of swinging the bat and is 75K cheaper with DPP.
- 55K is spare but there isnt any change I like where I could use the money to upgrade, Stoinis and Zampa have been in my team through the 4000 variations, Wood I like, green is the only guaratee for ST, CDG should have an excellent role and I cant upgrade rossouw to M short or Sangha and Gilkes/inglis cant become Billings or Phillipe so.
Any thoughts are appreciated, especially any holes or disagreements the more perspectives the better.
Really enjoyed reading your comments around why you selected each player , very well thought out.

Might just be best to sit on the $ 55k and use it for Round 2 or 3 trades (CDG + Bank gets you du Plessis easy enough)

Good luck with it
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top