Opinion BBL|12: Player X vs Player Y & Trade Discussions

[Woosie]

Aside from the cash difference

A Agar v Hardie ?

Agar always seems to be there in the mix. I'm uncertain Hardie gets that Marsh role.

Does Agar get 3-4 overs?

 

[Ben's Beasts]

Aside from the cash difference

A Agar v Hardie ?

Agar always seems to be there in the mix. I'm uncertain Hardie gets that Marsh role.

Does Agar get 3-4 overs?

Agar quite comfortably.

 

[The Myth]

Aside from the cash difference

A Agar v Hardie ?

Agar always seems to be there in the mix. I'm uncertain Hardie gets that Marsh role.

Does Agar get 3-4 overs?

Easily Agar. They are likely to bat one spot different and Agar will bowl 4 whilst Hardie might not even bowl.

 

[Tamuhawk]

Rashid & Lyth
Vs
Jhye & CDG

 

[toxic]

Rashid & Lyth
Vs
Jhye & CDG

Rash and Lyth

Can see Jye playing 1 game only

 

[Woosie]

Rashid & Lyth
Vs
Jhye & CDG

Jhye + CDG

Khan leaves in a few rounds.
The other two probably won't.

Lyth here is unknown.

Khans BE 89
CDGs BE 68

CDGs role looks to be quite good.

Although
JRs injury is clouded
CDG is a slogger

Tough call

 

[MaxsMaggies]

Rash and Lyth

Can see Jye playing 1 game only

Its 4 over only, if Jhye is fit tonight does he really need resting when its only 4 overs. Trying to predict/guess injuries is tricky.

 

[Ironhawk]

Maddinson v Shadab?

Hoping someone can suggest better trade options in our combined team, but I have these two fighting out a position with the trades I am proposing.

Rashid & Lyth
Vs
Jhye & CDG

I probably prefer the first option. The lack of cricket recently for Jhye due to injury, plus the potential of missing the second game, which many are mentioning could happen leans me to the other two.

 

[Ironhawk]

Aside from the cash difference

A Agar v Hardie ?

Agar always seems to be there in the mix. I'm uncertain Hardie gets that Marsh role.

Does Agar get 3-4 overs?

Missed this one, Agar for me. I'm pretty sure he will get 4 based on their likely line up.

 

[Tamuhawk]

Maddinson v Shadab?

I'd go Shadab as he's guaranteed 4 overs and batting at 4.

 

[Young gun]

Jhye + CDG

Khan leaves in a few rounds.
The other two probably won't.

Lyth here is unknown.

Khans BE 89
CDGs BE 68

CDGs role looks to be quite good.

Although
JRs injury is clouded
CDG is a slogger

Tough call

Is CDG a hold for as long as Rashid is here? I actually don’t see that being the dealbreaker in the comparison since Rashid will outscore him easily in that time period before he leaves

 

[Woosie]

Is CDG a hold for as long as Rashid is here? I actually don’t see that being the dealbreaker in the comparison since Rashid will outscore him easily in that time period before he leaves

I agree Khan will outscore CDG

I was comparing

Khan v Jhye

and

Lyth v CDG

where CDG's role looks ok, and Lyth is uncertain

as with Rashid v Jhye, I'd put Khan ahead

it's a tough one.

 

[jaca]

Jhye vs Faf vs Farooqi?

 

[The Myth]

Jhye vs Faf vs Farooqi?

Farooqi for me. Price and break even.

 

[jel]

Looking at options for a 3rd trade, maybe bring in a 4th Scorcher, have got Agar, Inglis & Morris with $156k to spend.

1. Jhye - has a bit of an injury cloud
2. Lyth - unknown quantity and Bat only
3. Just grab a SGR player like Hosein

 

[Herbie66]

Looking at options for a 3rd trade, maybe bring in a 4th Scorcher, have got Agar, Inglis & Morris with $156k to spend.

1. Jhye - has a bit of an injury cloud
2. Lyth - unknown quantity and Bat only
3. Just grab a SGR player like Hosein

Morris is with the Test Squad

 

[jel]

Morris is with the Test Squad

Of course he is, how did I miss that.

 

[Darkie]

Jhye vs Faf vs Farooqi?

Jhye if you are confident he'll play two. Otherwise Farooqi.

 

[Woosie]

R Khan vs Zampa?

 

[mike89]

It begins.