Discussion 2023 Finals Week 3: Teams & In Game Discussion

Joined
15 Mar 2019
Messages
13,294
Likes
50,498
AFL Club
Hawthorn
#83
Umps seem to be favouring the Blues early on. Doubtful free paid for running too far against the Lions (my opinion), then not at the other end which scored a goal (running about 40m and bouncing it once). Hopefully it doesn't continue and we get a fairly umpired match.
 
Joined
20 Dec 2016
Messages
9,490
Likes
45,990
AFL Club
Carlton
#85
Umps seem to be favouring the Blues early on. Doubtful free paid for running too far against the Lions (my opinion), then not at the other end which scored a goal (running about 40m and bouncing it once). Hopefully it doesn't continue and we get a fairly umpired match.
They rule it by steps rather than by metres. I admittedly didn't check the Cottrell one but Berry took 17 steps.

(I haven't read the Laws in a while and I suspect they do say metres, but steps are easier for an umpire to judge.)
 
Joined
15 Mar 2019
Messages
13,294
Likes
50,498
AFL Club
Hawthorn
#87
They rule it by steps rather than by metres. I admittedly didn't check the Cottrell one but Berry took 17 steps.

(I haven't read the Laws in a while and I suspect they do say metres, but steps are easier for an umpire to judge.)
Would have to rewatch it to check, but if he did take that many steps, fair enough.

Not going to matter the way the Blues are playing. Smashing the Lions.
 

Ben's Beasts

Leadership Group
Joined
6 Jan 2013
Messages
16,683
Likes
62,468
AFL Club
Melbourne
Kiddy Coleman BOG.

The two best teams this season are playing off in the GF.

Fitting that the two best teams in the back half of the season made prelims too. Both Blues and Giants fans should be very proud.

Gonna be a ripper of a Grand Final. Go the Lions.
 
Top