Discussion 2023 NFL DREAM TEAM Discussion- RD3: Friday 22nd Sep @ 9:15am AEST- San Francisco VS New York Giants

RD3: Who will be your VC/C? (Pick 2)

  • C McCaffrey

    Votes: 15 78.9%
  • L Jackson

    Votes: 1 5.3%
  • B Robinson (ATL)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • T Hill

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • A Ekeler

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • J Allen

    Votes: 2 10.5%
  • T Pollard

    Votes: 1 5.3%
  • P Mahomes

    Votes: 9 47.4%
  • J Hurts

    Votes: 5 26.3%
  • Other

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    19
Joined
9 Feb 2015
Messages
7,223
Likes
43,608
AFL Club
West Coast
490 (Mahomes) with just Chubb to come.

Trades next week :- Chase > Nacua to load the bank up looks almost certain. Especially if Burrow misses time after hurting his calf again. Not sure on any other moves yet.

Shame Richardson got concussed as he was on track for a huge score, think I will just bench him next week & play Love on the field next week who has started the season well.
 
Last edited:
Joined
20 Mar 2016
Messages
1,991
Likes
7,468
AFL Club
St Kilda
A prime example of why a RB is not just a RB - interchangeable:
Ekeler was out injured and Kelley took over the RB1 duties against Tennessee.
Kelley had 13 carries for 39 yds = 3.0 yds per carry.
Ekeler and Kelley against Tennessee last year:
Ekeler: 12 carries for 58 yds and a TD = 4.8 yds per carry.
Kelley: 10 carries for 24 yds and a TD = 2.4 yds per carry.

Some people might think that if Kelley got the chances that Ekeler did he could do as well.
I doubt it.
 
Joined
6 Dec 2021
Messages
132
Likes
616
A prime example of why a RB is not just a RB - interchangeable:
Ekeler was out injured and Kelley took over the RB1 duties against Tennessee.
Kelley had 13 carries for 39 yds = 3.0 yds per carry.
Ekeler and Kelley against Tennessee last year:
Ekeler: 12 carries for 58 yds and a TD = 4.8 yds per carry.
Kelley: 10 carries for 24 yds and a TD = 2.4 yds per carry.

Some people might think that if Kelley got the chances that Ekeler did he could do as well.
I doubt it.
Thoughts on Kyren Williams as Rams RB1 post Akers for the remainder or will they trade for an established RB like JT?
 
Joined
20 Mar 2016
Messages
1,991
Likes
7,468
AFL Club
St Kilda
Thoughts on Kyren Williams as Rams RB1 post Akers for the remainder or will they trade for an established RB like JT?
Who knoes?
For whatever reason Akers isn't favoured by the LAR coaches so it is post-Akers time and there is a RB1 spot open.
Kyren had a reasonable college career but not outstanding: about 17 carries per game at 5 yds per with 1 x TD per and 3 receipts but almost no TDs
In the NFL it's hard to judge. He had limited involvement last year but his two games this year are reasonably promisiing.
His 15 and 14 carries were good volume but inefficient at only 3.5 and 3.7 yds per carry. By contRast, Montgomery averaged 4.2 yds per carry and Harris 5.2 against the same opponents.
His 2 and then 10 targets are promising. If the Rams think he can be a regular in the passing game you'd think they see him as their RB1.
Also promising is the Rams use of Nacua.
I think it probably indicates a look to the future approach.

They traded away their immediate future to win the SB: to get Stafford they gave away a ton of future picks: 1st rnd - 2022/2023; 2nd rd - 2022/2023; 3rd rd - 2021/2023.
So they don't have the picks to trade and it would have to be players.
But which players?
Akers - he's out of favour and if they tried to trade him pre-season they weren't successful
Kupp - maybe but he's 30 yrs old and injury is starting to hit
linemen and defence - I don;t know enough about them to comment

My best guess is that they'll give Kyren a decent shot at proving himself.
 

KLo30

Leadership Group
Joined
27 Jan 2014
Messages
16,797
Likes
46,018
AFL Club
North Melb.
Who knoes?
For whatever reason Akers isn't favoured by the LAR coaches so it is post-Akers time and there is a RB1 spot open.
Kyren had a reasonable college career but not outstanding: about 17 carries per game at 5 yds per with 1 x TD per and 3 receipts but almost no TDs
In the NFL it's hard to judge. He had limited involvement last year but his two games this year are reasonably promisiing.
His 15 and 14 carries were good volume but inefficient at only 3.5 and 3.7 yds per carry. By contRast, Montgomery averaged 4.2 yds per carry and Harris 5.2 against the same opponents.
His 2 and then 10 targets are promising. If the Rams think he can be a regular in the passing game you'd think they see him as their RB1.
Also promising is the Rams use of Nacua.
I think it probably indicates a look to the future approach.

They traded away their immediate future to win the SB: to get Stafford they gave away a ton of future picks: 1st rnd - 2022/2023; 2nd rd - 2022/2023; 3rd rd - 2021/2023.
So they don't have the picks to trade and it would have to be players.
But which players?
Akers - he's out of favour and if they tried to trade him pre-season they weren't successful
Kupp - maybe but he's 30 yrs old and injury is starting to hit
linemen and defence - I don;t know enough about them to comment

My best guess is that they'll give Kyren a decent shot at proving himself.
View: https://twitter.com/AdamSchefter/status/1703369579248935351
 
Joined
6 Sep 2023
Messages
72
Likes
160
AFL Club
Brisbane
Who knoes?
For whatever reason Akers isn't favoured by the LAR coaches so it is post-Akers time and there is a RB1 spot open.
Kyren had a reasonable college career but not outstanding: about 17 carries per game at 5 yds per with 1 x TD per and 3 receipts but almost no TDs
In the NFL it's hard to judge. He had limited involvement last year but his two games this year are reasonably promisiing.
His 15 and 14 carries were good volume but inefficient at only 3.5 and 3.7 yds per carry. By contRast, Montgomery averaged 4.2 yds per carry and Harris 5.2 against the same opponents.
His 2 and then 10 targets are promising. If the Rams think he can be a regular in the passing game you'd think they see him as their RB1.
Also promising is the Rams use of Nacua.
I think it probably indicates a look to the future approach.

They traded away their immediate future to win the SB: to get Stafford they gave away a ton of future picks: 1st rnd - 2022/2023; 2nd rd - 2022/2023; 3rd rd - 2021/2023.
So they don't have the picks to trade and it would have to be players.
But which players?
Akers - he's out of favour and if they tried to trade him pre-season they weren't successful
Kupp - maybe but he's 30 yrs old and injury is starting to hit
linemen and defence - I don;t know enough about them to comment

My best guess is that they'll give Kyren a decent shot at proving himself.
I am very impressed with your knowledge Rupert as I am only new and I got no idea on where to look to find team list for the NFL...
Frustrating to say the least... I do have a source that tells me about injuries, but as we all know that's a bit like smoke and mirrors....
Questionable Doubtful and what have you... also the games kick off at 3am.... makes it very difficult to make late changes for late outs.

I do like the info I get from this forum best, Truth be told and everybody seems to not tell tales which is even better.

So Thanks to Everyone in here and best of luck to You all. (y)(y)(y)(y)(y)(y):):):):)
 

KLo30

Leadership Group
Joined
27 Jan 2014
Messages
16,797
Likes
46,018
AFL Club
North Melb.
I am very impressed with your knowledge Rupert as I am only new and I got no idea on where to look to find team list for the NFL...
Frustrating to say the least... I do have a source that tells me about injuries, but as we all know that's a bit like smoke and mirrors....
Questionable Doubtful and what have you... also the games kick off at 3am.... makes it very difficult to make late changes for late outs.

I do like the info I get from this forum best, Truth be told and everybody seems to not tell tales which is even better.

So Thanks to Everyone in here and best of luck to You all. (y)(y)(y)(y)(y)(y):):):):)
The first page of this thread has a list of useful links to all things NFL.
 
Joined
20 Mar 2016
Messages
1,991
Likes
7,468
AFL Club
St Kilda
I am very impressed with your knowledge Rupert as I am only new and I got no idea on where to look to find team list for the NFL...
Frustrating to say the least... I do have a source that tells me about injuries, but as we all know that's a bit like smoke and mirrors....
Questionable Doubtful and what have you... also the games kick off at 3am.... makes it very difficult to make late changes for late outs.

I do like the info I get from this forum best, Truth be told and everybody seems to not tell tales which is even better.

So Thanks to Everyone in here and best of luck to You all. (y)(y)(y)(y)(y)(y):):):):)
I've been following the NFL on and off for a long time so I'd like to think I know something about it.
As @KLo30 says, see the first page but to help get you started on the basics.
A good starting point for NFL in general is the ESPN NFL site:
https://www.espn.com/nfl/
This site contains team line-ups, depth charts, schedules, injuries, fantasy advice etc
A good starting point for NFL fantasy is the FantasyPros site:
https://www.fantasypros.com/nfl/
This site provides advice on all things fantasy. When looking up rankings remember that the RDT scoring is mostly 2 x half PPR.
It is not PPR. Half PPR and PPR scoring is identical except that a reception is given 0.5 points in half PPR, 1.0 points in PPR. RDT gives 1.0 p;oints for a reception and doubles everything else as well.
The only difference is that place kickers aren't deducted points for misses.

The NFL treats the reporting of injuries much better than the AFL.
DNP and LP
Each team issues practice reports and if a player does not practice, for whatever reason, they are listed as DNP. If they do only a light practice they are listed as LP.
DNPs early in the week can be relatively meaningless as players are often enough just given the day off. DNPs late in the week, Thursdays and Fridays are more significant,

Probable, questionable and doubtful.
Each team has to list the injury status of any player with a chance of missing the next game, no matter how slim the chance of missing might be.
Probable: the player has some sort of injury but is very likely to play. It is rare that a player listed as probable does not play.
Questionable: the player is a roughly 50-50 chance of playing. This is often used for players with things like bruising, sprains, concussions etc
Dountful: the player is very unlikely to play and it is very rare that they do.
To the best of my knowledge the NFL polices the use of these designations: have too many "unlikely" play and they notice.

Out and IR/PUP
Out: a team might announce a player is out earlier but at the latest they do so roughly 90 min before a game when they release team sheets.
The designation only applies to that game. The player is automatically assumed to be available for the nrxt game.
IR/PUP: if a player is injured and unable to play he is designated Physically Unable to Perform (PUP) and is uitomatically eligible to be placed on Injured Reserve (IR). But as a player on IR has to miss the next 4 games a team might decide to keep the player listed as PUP off IR.
When a player is placed on IR their team can add a replacement player to their 53-man roster for the duration.
 
Last edited:
Joined
6 Sep 2023
Messages
72
Likes
160
AFL Club
Brisbane
woof - it's been a rough start, gang.

419, with Chubb to play, and a really underwhelming WR line, featuring Chase (11), AJ Brown (9), Brandon Aiyuk (11) and Calvin Ridley (8). All while a cool 28 from Jordan Addison is sitting on my Bench.

Not quite sure what my trades will be yet.
I think You will do alright if Chubb gets you around 35 or more hopefully ;););););)
I got him too and Olave to come
Most scores seem to hover around 420-460... with obviously some nice 500+ scores too as posted by some already
If You are looking for a TE... HH or Hockenson come to mind... lots of choices in RB and WR but TE is more difficult to get right I feel.... Kelce is an obvious Keeper... but I feel I wait on him for now , anyway
BoL
 
Joined
6 Sep 2023
Messages
72
Likes
160
AFL Club
Brisbane
Trading out
Kittle / TE ( underperformed and will have a big BE )
Tank Bigsby / RB ( low score rd1 and DNP this week... want to make $$$ and get somebody that provides points )
Quentin Johnson / WR ( was a punt but badly mis-fired )

I feel the reasons for trading them out are valued unless somebody can tell me otherwise
 
Joined
14 Feb 2021
Messages
105
Likes
313
AFL Club
Bulldogs
Trading out
Kittle / TE ( underperformed and will have a big BE )
Tank Bigsby / RB ( low score rd1 and DNP this week... want to make $$$ and get somebody that provides points )
Quentin Johnson / WR ( was a punt but badly mis-fired )

I feel the reasons for trading them out are valued unless somebody can tell me otherwise
I think I'm also going to trade out Bigsby, probably for Williams if I have the money to do so.

Trading out QJ isn't the worst move, I don't think. A lot of the draft game podcasts I was listening to over the o***eason were saying that despite the hype, they're not sold on him. LAC really doesn't support more than 2 WRs in their offense anyway, and with both Allen and Williams healthy, he's just not going to get enough play I don't think
 
Joined
6 Sep 2023
Messages
72
Likes
160
AFL Club
Brisbane
I think I'm also going to trade out Bigsby, probably for Williams if I have the money to do so.

Trading out QJ isn't the worst move, I don't think. A lot of the draft game podcasts I was listening to over the o***eason were saying that despite the hype, they're not sold on him. LAC really doesn't support more than 2 WRs in their offense anyway, and with both Allen and Williams healthy, he's just not going to get enough play I don't think
Bigsby to Williams is like $100,000 variation... assuming you refer to Kyren Williams surely you can afford that ;););)
 
Top