Strategy 2023: Player X v Player Y

[Crabby Skills]

2k off Mackenzie to Stewart

So it's:

Mackenzie -> Pickett ( banking 200k )
vs
Ginbey -> Stewart

 

[NT.Thunder]

2k off Mackenzie to Stewart

So it's:

Mackenzie -> Pickett ( banking 200k )
vs
Ginbey -> Stewart

I don't mind the Pickett move, I was looking at something similar wher next week I could move one or both of Ziebell and Sheezel to defence and have Pickett forward at F5/F6. Depends on yr structure I guess

 

[Ironhawk]

2k off Mackenzie to Stewart

So it's:

Mackenzie -> Pickett ( banking 200k )
vs
Ginbey -> Stewart

I'd be holding Ginbey for now if possible, so option 1.

 

[teatai]

Keep JVR score 52 or
Play Greene or Rats (have no ruck cover)

 

[Ironhawk]

Keep JVR score 52 or
Play Greene or Rats (have no ruck cover)

I'd keep the 52.

 

[Monya Meow Meow]

Keep JVR score 52 or
Play Greene or Rats (have no ruck cover)

Wanted to ask the same thing, guess the smart play would be to keep the 52 as Greene only went above that once, Rat twice.

 

[Masterofnone]

Barrass + 92k v Stewart?

 

[Ironhawk]

Barrass + 92k v Stewart?

Barrass has been a regular option in MPM, looking at his career, it seems it has been for his whole career. His current average around 90 seems about right - I don't see him as a keeper. Save the trade and get Stewart at what will likely be his cheapest.

 

[Darkie]

Barrass + 92k v Stewart?

I would normally say Stewart easily, but it would be worth looking at 2022-23 scores for Barrass without McGovern in the side. I’m also a bit wary of Stewart’s possession count since he returned from suspension.

 

[Masterofnone]

I would normally say Stewart easily, but it would be worth looking at 2022-23 scores for Barrass without McGovern in the side. I’m also a bit wary of Stewart’s possession count since he returned from suspension.

Somebody posted that his average last year without McGovern was something like 104.

 

[Masterofnone]

Barrass has been a regular option in MPM, looking at his career, it seems it has been for his whole career. His current average around 90 seems about right - I don't see him as a keeper. Save the trade and get Stewart at what will likely be his cheapest.

Thanks for the good advice!

 

[Crabby Skills]

2k off Mackenzie to Stewart

So it's:

Mackenzie -> Pickett ( banking 200k )
vs
Ginbey -> Stewart

Whelp

 

[Ironhawk]

Whelp

Yeah, got that one wrong, sorry.

 

[Munkea]

Lots to ponder this week. Can boost for an upgrade, or simply double downgrade. If boosting, I'm currently torn between two options of Ziebell or Cogs. Ziebell gives flexibility with the DEF swing and is cheaper, but Cogs probably has a higher ceiling and is well priced after a couple of bad weeks.

Cogs Vs Ziebell + 40k

Any opinions?

 

[BarginHunter]

Serong vs Touk?

 

[dlanod]

Serong vs Touk?

Touk. I always back in the existing premium to keep it up.

 

[Ironhawk]

Lots to ponder this week. Can boost for an upgrade, or simply double downgrade. If boosting, I'm currently torn between two options of Ziebell or Cogs. Ziebell gives flexibility with the DEF swing and is cheaper, but Cogs probably has a higher ceiling and is well priced after a couple of bad weeks.

Cogs Vs Ziebell + 40k

Any opinions?

If boosting I'd be trying for a more certain keeper personally. Ziebell for me due to the flexibility and cash.

Serong vs Touk?

Serong is in good form, but probably going to end up just short of keeper standard. Touk.

 

[Game of Sloanes]

Out Chandler v Baker
In Roberts v Johnson

 

[Manikato1]

Here is one for Rd 7. Both Walsh and Zerrett will stay same price after this round but who I trade this week may impact on who I upgrade to in Rd 7 so which one is a better long term upgrade. Walsh might drop in price but maybe by not much and waiting a week may cramp other planned trades. Will be upgrading from a rookie. So

Walsh v Zerret

 

[Ironhawk]

Out Chandler v Baker
In Roberts v Johnson

Baker, Johnson

Here is one for Rd 7. Both Walsh and Zerrett will stay same price after this round but who I trade this week may impact on who I upgrade to in Rd 7 so which one is a better long term upgrade. Walsh might drop in price but maybe by not much and waiting a week may cramp other planned trades. Will be upgrading from a rookie. So

Walsh v Zerret

Tough choice, but I'd pick Zerrett. Not much to split the two.