Strategy 2023: Player X v Player Y

[Manikato1]

Baker, Johnson

Tough choice, but I'd pick Zerrett. Not much to split the two.

Yes I found it tough hence my question. If Walsh had a quiet one this week it would tempt me to wait but at the moment I think Zerrett is in front.

 

[FlatTrackBully]

Trade 1: In - Miller, Johnson and Roberts
Out - Ginbey, Baker, Comben
+164k in the bank, 13 premiums

Or

Trade 2: In - Sinclair/Parish, Coniglio, Roberts
Out - Ginbey, Ashcroft, Baker
+13k in the bank, 14 premiums

 

[Miller is a Steele]

Trade 1: In - Miller, Johnson and Roberts
Out - Ginbey, Baker, Comben
+164k in the bank, 13 premiums

Or

Trade 2: In - Sinclair/Parish, Coniglio, Roberts
Out - Ginbey, Ashcroft, Baker
+13k in the bank, 14 premiums

1

 

[Ironhawk]

Trade 1: In - Miller, Johnson and Roberts
Out - Ginbey, Baker, Comben
+164k in the bank, 13 premiums

Or

Trade 2: In - Sinclair/Parish, Coniglio, Roberts
Out - Ginbey, Ashcroft, Baker
+13k in the bank, 14 premiums

Prefer the first too.

 

[Trickee]

JZ vs C.jones at d4 and spare coin for better upgrades mext week.

 

[Ironhawk]

JZ vs C.jones at d4 and spare coin for better upgrades mext week.

I trust Ziebell a lot more than Jones to score consistently. Doubt either is a keeper though. Ziebell for me.

 

[Amazing Bombers]

JZ vs C.jones at d4 and spare coin for better upgrades mext week.

Ziebell comfortably, think he should be able to hold a 95+ average whereas can't say the same about Jones.

 

[lappinitup]

Here is one for Rd 7. Both Walsh and Zerrett will stay same price after this round but who I trade this week may impact on who I upgrade to in Rd 7 so which one is a better long term upgrade. Walsh might drop in price but maybe by not much and waiting a week may cramp other planned trades. Will be upgrading from a rookie. So

Walsh v Zerret

Pains me to say this, but Zerret. Walsh could go silly, however want to see how he scores with acres and hollands in team. Previously he was really the only midfielder who worked hard, got plenty of those chipped kicks to him as he was only option. Now the other two will take a few.

Ginbey V McKenna to hold and field?

 

[jaca]

Since Williams is not in… Johnson vs going early on Seamus?

 

[jaca]

Ginbey V McKenna to hold and field?

I’d keep Ginbey if could afford to.

 

[Manikato1]

Pains me to say this, but Zerret. Walsh could go silly, however want to see how he scores with acres and hollands in team. Previously he was really the only midfielder who worked hard, got plenty of those chipped kicks to him as he was only option. Now the other two will take a few.

Ginbey V McKenna to hold and field?

Yes the front runner for me at the moment is Zerrett.

Ginbey has flatlined for cash gen currently and has a few niggles. IMO if they had a full squad he might have been managed by now but the Eagles cannot even field a WAFL team this week because of injuries so they have no one else to play. I am not sure that is good for his scoring.

I have both and am leaning towards fielding McKenna. It will also be easier for him to make cash.

 

[lappinitup]

I’d keep Ginbey if could afford to.

That is what I plan on doing, interesting to se if others do.

 

[Manikato1]

That is what I plan on doing, interesting to se if others do.

Ginbey the better player no doubt but perhaps circumstances not in his favour right now.

 

[Ironhawk]

Pains me to say this, but Zerret. Walsh could go silly, however want to see how he scores with acres and hollands in team. Previously he was really the only midfielder who worked hard, got plenty of those chipped kicks to him as he was only option. Now the other two will take a few.

Ginbey V McKenna to hold and field?

Probably McKenna, Eagles are a basket case I'd be trying to avoid until they get some players back.

Since Williams is not in… Johnson vs going early on Seamus?

Not sure Mitchell has a guaranteed spot longer term, Johnson seems the safer pick.

 

[BarginHunter]

Roberts vs Johnson for JS mainly
I know nothing about eithers role or brand of footy
Can we expect 50-60 from both?

 

[Monya Meow Meow]

Who to trade in?

Ziebell v Cogs

Already have 2 other Giants if it makes a diff

 

[Ironhawk]

Roberts vs Johnson for JS mainly
I know nothing about eithers role or brand of footy
Can we expect 50-60 from both?

Not sure about the JS of either to be honest. Possibly Johnson is slightly more secure, but don't know. Not Victorian teams, so may as well not exist in terms of media coverage.

Who to trade in?

Ziebell v Cogs

Already have 2 other Giants if it makes a diff

I prefer the DPP flexibility of Ziebell, but Coniglio seems the better value to me. Cogs.

 

[BigRuss]

Trade Baker and grab Cogs/Butters Vs Trade Ashcroft and grab Neale

 

[THCLT]

Trade Baker and grab Cogs/Butters Vs Trade Ashcroft and grab Neale

First one feels more right at this point of a season.

On Butters, I read that he put his hands up for more midfield time last couple of games which I can see has reflected in his scoring. Should I trust Hinkley on this move or is it another false dawn...?

 

[BigRuss]

First one feels more right at this point of a season.

On Butters, I read that he put his hands up for more midfield time last couple of games which I can see has reflected in his scoring. Should I trust Hinkley on this move or is it another false dawn...?

Jump on mate. CBA’s up at around that 65 mark he needs to score well. Reckon he does cogs on average and aggregate the rest of the year. Both likely to miss a game or 2 though probably.