Review 2024: Season Review

Joined
1 Feb 2016
Messages
106
Likes
807
AFL Club
Essendon
#1
SuperCoach is done for another year! :cry::D All the tears, rage, joy, happiness, successful PODs and late changes are over!

If you're rational, you'll get back to your life and use the free time to be more productive. But if you're obsessive like me, you may want a chance to review your season!

Use any format you like, as usual! If you want to get started, here are some ideas?
  • What was your overall rank?
  • What is your general recap of the year?
  • Who were your best trade(s)?
  • Who were your worst trade(s)?
  • Who's the one you wish you had?
  • Who's the one you wish you didn't have?
  • If you could go back with 20/20 hindsight, what three changes would you make to your starting team?
  • How did your C/VC streak go?
  • How did your byes go?
  • What was the impact of the 40 trades?
  • What will you change for next year?
 
Joined
15 Mar 2019
Messages
14,962
Likes
57,683
AFL Club
Hawthorn
#2
Thanks for keeping the tradition going of posting regular update threads this year. I have always liked to read through these when I get a chance, and used to always post my own updates weekly, just been too busy for most of the year. Bit of a shame their hasn't been a lot of responses to these topics this year, but thanks for continuing with them anyway.

My season started average, traded my way to an acceptable rank, then fell in a hole as soon as I ran out of trades. That about sums my year up. Sounds like most years for me.

  • What was your overall rank? 20K+
  • What is your general recap of the year? Never really liked my team, so kept trading to fix things, probably made things worse with too many sideways trades and ran out of trades to complete the team properly.
  • Who were your best trade(s)? Probably Green to Neale, avoiding the 5 from Green. Neale was a real POD at the time.
  • Who were your worst trade(s)? Dunno where to start. Mostly trading out players far too early. Getting sucked in by Oliver wasn't great either.
  • Who's the one you wish you had? Xerri
  • Who's the one you wish you didn't have? English, stuck with him all season, that money should have been used better.
  • If you could go back with 20/20 hindsight, what three changes would you make to your starting team? English to Xerri, Fyfe to D'Ambrosio and starting another premium rather than a rookie. Not sure who is my biggest miss for that final spot, there were a lot.
  • How did your C/VC streak go? Surprisingly well for me. Missed a few big scores, and had a few fails, but overall think I went 130+ for my C score which is good.
  • How did your byes go? Mixed. Two good, but got smashed iin Rd 15 in particular.
  • What was the impact of the 40 trades? As the NTL Club president this year, still nowhere near enough for me. I honestly would like to see similar to AFL - 2 per round, 3 for byes, no boosts. Maybe one day.
  • What will you change for next year? Not much. I'll still burn all my trades far sooner than I should and not get decent value from them. I'll still pick a bunch of dud starting picks. I'll still enjoy it (to an extent) anyway.
 
Joined
25 Dec 2022
Messages
3,356
Likes
16,461
AFL Club
West Coast
#3
What was your overall rank?
663rd
What is you general recap of the year?
Beat my preseason goal of top 1k. 3 consecutive top 1k finishes now which I’m proud of. Extremely disappointing finish after putting myself in an excellent position during the first 2 thirds of the year. Best starting team I’ll ever have I reckon. Over real premium failures were: Libba while Butters was the alternative annoyingly; Young who I traded in round 2 but would’ve been a fine hold in hindsight; and Jackson who I got in for the initial sugar hit, which worked to be fair, but was useless otherwise. Wish I went through with trading him when he was 600k+. Didn’t ever need his RUC status either. Then a couple rookies which is inevitable. Sharp and Dempsey the main ones I missed.
Who were your best trade(s)?
Powell (just before his first stinker) to Daicos. Bonner to Dale for just 68k.
Who were your worst trades(s)?
As weird as it sounds, Round 5 where I went: Jordon, Billings, and Howes to Steele, Graham, and Clohesy. Cashed out Howes too early. Steele was mediocre and ended up being traded at his bye. The main one is actually the Graham and Clohesy combo. Both had only played 1 game. The guy who I was going to choose instead of one of them and on the bubble was Lohmann. Was set on it all week then got cold feet on the Thursday. After Round 14 (thanks to @jel and his weekly graphs on the main thread), Lohmann had made the most cash out of any player in the game. Was a huge POD and would’ve been massive for cash generation and also points. They flow on effect was that I was forced into going early on McAuliffe next week, with me already owning Graham/Clohesy, who has on the bye and then dropped. He was stuck on the bench at 117k with no DPP for 4 weeks.

Honourable mentions for Gawn to Nankervis instead of Xerri and for the “upgrades” to Curnow and Holmes.
Who’s the one you wish you had?
Xerri. Neale a close second.
Who’s the one you wish you didn’t have?
Curnow. Nankervis, Jackson, Holmes, Fisher honourable mentions.
If you could go back with 20/20 hindsight, what three changes would you make to your starting team?
Had an incredibly good starting team so not too many. Liberatore to Butters is the obvious one. Seth Campbell to Dempsey and Jhye Clark to Sharp.
How did your C/VC streak go?
Biggest VC streak of 3 during rounds 3-5. Had 5 VC fails from rounds 15-19. 108.6 average from the eventual C in those weeks with only 1 above 116. Overall average of 131.54. Not great but not bad either.
How did your byes go?
Extremely well. Jumped from 1221st to 128th. Top 1k round ranks in rounds 12, 14, and 15.
What was the impact of the 40 trades?
I think the main difference to me was the rounds in between correction trades and upgrade season. Traditionally you used to have your correction trades in rounds 2/3 and start upgrading round 6. This year I found myself, and almost everyone, trading heavily during this period. I think this was in part due to Round 0 with rookies being a price rise ahead and trading them early could get you an upgrade ahead of those who didn’t. Will I go ahead with that next season if it stays? Probably. I did find myself with little trades down the stretch though.
What will you change for next year?
Nothing. I think I keep improving my strategies and planning. I dominated through the byes again like last year after struggling a couple years ago. I felt I executed my plan exactly how I wanted to. Still only my 3rd year playing ‘seriously’ after 3-4 years playing ‘casually’. I had in my opinion the best bench setup you can have in terms of DPP links which helped me only have one donut (due to a late out in Heeney) despite copping a decent amount of injuries in the back end of the season, (although far better than some teams I’ve seen) and very little trades with 2 for the last 8 and 0 for the last 6 rounds. The main things that hurt me were XvY’s. The main ones being Holmes over Whitfield, Nankervis over Xerri, and LDU over Neale.

My number one rule is SuperCoach is do not overpay for premiums. The ONLY time I may overpay is if we are in the byes or past the byes, and I know my budget and trust my situation. It’s a well known and obvious rule, but the amount of times I see people just spending up for a player that’s in a hot patch always amazes me. 8 times out of 10, the play is to wait until they have a bad game/s and get them cheap or not at all. You don’t automatically gain the points they got in the previous weeks. Be realistic with expectations. Just because someone scored at 130 for 5 weeks, that doesn’t mean they will score at 130 for the remainder of the year. There is times it doesn’t pay off of course. For example, if I didn’t start Ryan this year, I wouldn’t have considered him until after his bye. But as I said, 80% of the time waiting is the best play.
 
Joined
7 Sep 2020
Messages
11,767
Likes
41,430
#4
What was your overall rank?
140th
What is your general recap of the year?
It's dangerous to completely rule out players susceptible to injury or 30+ year old players
(Neale, Whitfield, Yeo, McGovern and Treloar are examples and most of them fit in both.)
Who were your best trade(s)?
Grundy > Meek (Kept him all year)
Who were your worst trade(s)?
Jackson and McKay
Who's the one you wish you had?
Xerri, Whitfield or Caldwell
Who's the one you wish you didn't have?
Jackson
If you could go back with 20/20 hindsight, what three changes would you make to your starting team?
Avoid or cull mid pricers blocking on field spots to the better rookies.
Don't be afraid to hold onto or pay up on rookies that are inflated (Dempsey, Lohmann, Sexton)
Keep a starting player scoring low if the role is there and don't be afraid of players to come back in.
How did your C/VC streak go?
13/11 in the end
How did your byes go?
Started 562nd and came out at 630th with 8087 points.
What was the impact of the 40 trades?
Fixing mid priced players and I culled a lot of rookies for 50-100k profit due to injuries/omissions. (Bigoa, Jones and Richards were three in a row.)
What will you change for next year?
DPP favourable and make the most of the optimise button with them. Keep the right role players after a low one as those points are gone and can just as easily be made up on your alternative trade in player.

Starting side:
Daicos, Houston, Sheezel, Young, Williams, Howes // Gibcus, Hore
Bontempelli, Butters, Steele, Miller, Lyons, Berry, Roberts, McKercher // Sanders, Wilson, Clark
Gawn, Grundy // Livingstone
Heeney, Fisher, Jordon, Harmes, Reid, Sexton // Lazzaro, Campbell

Final side:
 

Attachments

Last edited:
Joined
6 Dec 2022
Messages
359
Likes
1,718
AFL Club
Gold Coast
#5
  • What was your overall rank? 2153 (peaked about 1100)
  • What is your general recap of the year? Very slow to start the season which put me in the position where I exclusively needed to trade in PODs to make up any ground whatsoever. Tried to play it too smart by fading Reid for Dempsey, fading Flanders due to fixture and other silly decisions like that.
  • Who were your best trade(s)? Whitfield, Ryan (Round 3), Dunkley, Moyle, LDU, Gulden and 400k Green. Trading Steele out at peak price due to knee concern when most were trading in.
  • Who were your worst trade(s)? LDU to Dunkley when I ended up getting LDU back in two weeks later, 600k Petracca, Merry-Go-Ruck with Grundy, Marshall and English, Hore -> Donut for DPP swing instead of holding the trade for an injury, Curnow and Jackson.
  • Who's the one you wish you had? Xerri and Neale
  • Who's the one you wish you didn't have? Jackson, Curnow and English.
  • If you could go back with 20/20 hindsight, what three changes would you make to your starting team? Grundy -> Xerri, Wines -> Flanders, Clark -> Reid.
  • How did your C/VC streak go? 135 avg, including a Marshall 60 when he did his knee which was the same week Gawn went 160 against Richmond. Overall I think It was a 60/40 split in taking VC's which is a bit lower than I'd have liked.
  • How did your byes go? This was my shining point of the year where my PODs in Whitfield, LDU and Dunkley all went on a heater and I was able to make up some good ground.
  • What was the impact of the 40 trades? For me personally it caused me to sideways too many premiums early such as Martin, Young, Steele, Marshall and LDU all before the byes. I would be surprised if I gained any substantial amount of points from these trades except for maybe Young and Martin -> Ryan.
  • What will you change for next year? Paid up for bench rookies for 'good' job security when instead that cash should've been used on field, paid up for too many premiums that eventually came down in price, didn't look for enough value to start the year, used way too many trades for rucks when I could've just started Gawn and Xerri and held them all year. This was one of the things I wrote down before the year started only for it to happen anyway. Screenshot 2024-08-28 at 3.49.44 pm.png
 
Joined
28 Sep 2020
Messages
715
Likes
3,300
AFL Club
Essendon
#6
  • What was your overall rank? 300, peaked at 79 in round 14. Was in the top 800 from round 4 onwards.
  • What is your general recap of the year? Nailing some value starting picks in Yeo, Heeney, Gawn, Crouch, Sheezel, Martin and Steele set me off on the right foot. Some poor trading during and post the byes definitely cost me a top 100 ranking and potentially could've been right up there if I nailed some of my later moves. Went into the season wanting to finish top 1k and to be aggressive so I can say I nailed both of that at least.
  • Who were your best trade(s)? Xerri at $605k in round 20 for a 148.8 average, Sinclair at $540k in round 12 for a 118.8 average
  • Who were your worst trade(s)? Ryan at $667k in round 14 for a 102.1 average, Rowell at $542k in round 15 for a 86.9 average, Curnow at $448k in round 15 for a 71.1 average. The sliding doors on those 3 trades...
  • Who's the one you wish you had? Treloar
  • Who's the one you wish you didn't have? Getting Macrae and Oliver for short periods.
  • If you could go back with 20/20 hindsight, what three changes would you make to your starting team? Grundy to Xerri, Lyons to McKercher, Fisher to Flanders
  • How did your C/VC streak go? 133 average for the year mainly thanks to my 11 VC's at an average of 149.5. Made some poor last minute decisions which cost me, taking the C off Gawn when he had the fitness test before the game and then went 180 and recently last minute switch off both Bont and Naicos when they went 180s on a Friday night against the Dees.
  • How did your byes go? Scored 8,287 points and improved my rank from 341 to 153. It was the moves I made during the byes which would cost me in the second half of the season.
  • What was the impact of the 40 trades? Think it meant you could be more aggressive but looking back on my trades with hindsight there was plenty wasted. I believe you need to deal with the hand dealt to you and think with 40 or even more trades next year that the best way to go about finishing with a high rank is to stay aggressive.
  • What will you change for next year? Don't go chasing points or high averages or paying top dollar for players. When I look back on all my trades and starting picks the only "winning" (this is judging what they were priced at versus their average while in my team) player above $600k is Xerri who I had for the last 5 rounds. So a 14% strike rate on players above $600k. Understand you need the top scoring players for captaincy purposes as well as a well rounded team but there is always value to be had. When I use this metric for players between $400k and $600k my strike rate on winning picks increases to 72%. This is all easier said than done.
 
Joined
8 Jan 2020
Messages
6,248
Likes
26,086
AFL Club
Geelong
#7
  • What was your overall rank? 2472
  • What is your general recap of the year? Just frustrated really, got to such a good position again early in the season and it went to water through alot of bad luck and poor decision making.
  • Who were your best trade(s)? Lloyd Meek at 350K, Luke Ryan at 610K
  • Who were your worst trade(s)? Zac Fisher, Charlie Curnow, Luke Jackson, Tim English
  • Who's the one you wish you had? Sinclair, was so obvious of a pick bottomed out aswell with a Marvel back end.. Xerri when everyone jumped on also hurt my soul every week watching him dominate while Tim English pretended to be a league footballer.
  • Who's the one you wish you didn't have? Zac Fisher, Luke Jackson, Charlie Curnow, all rubbish picks, Tom Stewart averaged basically nothing for me when plenty had a better defender in the spot, Phillipou and McKercher also basically ruined my season but that was more bad luck than actually being rubbish selections when selected so will give them a pass. Pea Heart Tim English isn't even worth wasting my breath on.
  • If you could go back with 20/20 hindsight, what three changes would you make to your starting team? Xerri was free, always pick the solo ruck with no competition, terrible miss both as a starter and in season.
  • How did your C/VC streak go? 130 average, pretty poor really for the standards I set myself, was alot higher last year.
  • How did your byes go? 7916, terrible and was the start of my season concluding.
  • What was the impact of the 40 trades? Honestly not much, I've always played aggressively, 40 trades maybe makes you go too far with it and we could use trades more wisely despite the increased amount.
  • What will you change for next year? Be more patient and dont burn sideways trades on guys in early rounds if the role is there. Also don't pick absolute spuds that you've never rated like Zac Fisher and somehow be surprised when they are useless 😂.
 
Last edited:
Joined
9 Feb 2015
Messages
9,386
Likes
57,602
AFL Club
West Coast
#8
What was your overall rank? 82nd

What is your general recap of the year?
Great overall year for me, solid starting team & most of my trading decisions. There was much talk about players with the early byes/2 byes overall so avoid but guys like Heeney & Flanders were standout picks in the forward line which was such a weak line that they were must haves really with their roles

Who were your best trade(s)?
Clohesy > Whitfield, Wilson > Gulden straight after Whitfield & Gulden (535K when I bought him) had their 2nd bye.Gulden punched out 2 x 150+ scores in the first 3 weeks of me owning him, love your work Errrol :love:, McKercher > Sexton round 10 (roughy back in) when desperate for downgrade options that week - scored 118 that week, averaged over 80 next month

Who were your worst trade(s)?
Williams > Nyuon round 7, I knew he was a spud but took him anyway with the lack of options. Really should of taken Sweet via Livingstone DP- took Sweet the following week but it was a wasted trade

Who's the one you wish you had?
Xerri

Who's the one you wish you didn't have?
Oliver

If you could go back with 20/20 hindsight, what three changes would you make to your starting team?

Xerri, Dempsey & Steele instead of Grundy, Wines & Seth Campbell


How did your C/VC streak go?
130 overall, had a bad patch for a month


How did your byes go?
Started 469th & finished 271st so good result

What was the impact of the 40 trades?
Fixing mistakes/poor trades immediately, being aggressive with my trading

What will you change for next year?
Not much, follow my gut instinct even more. If a mid price ruck option appears that is the clear main ruck at his team/ no ruck share then jump on. Xerri was on my radar but he received a head/ face knock a few weeks before the start of the season which scared me off & went with Grundy like many.
 
Joined
3 May 2017
Messages
2,684
Likes
8,886
AFL Club
Hawthorn
#12
  • What was your overall rank?
19k
  • What is your general recap of the year?
Started really badly. Just never got going. You name a player that people were rage trading in R2/3 I owned them. You name an injured dud rookie defender, I owned them (Ried, Gibcus, Hore, Pink, Coffield). This meant I missed the better scoring M/F rookies. I also went too midpriced, compounding me to miss way too many good cash gen and scoring rookies. The rarer low end midpricers I went with like Lyons failed compared to rookies on cash gen and points. I only wore one forced rookie score post R16. So I think I traded okay. Even covered Heeney with Georgiades last round!
1724943333986.png
  • Who were your best trade(s)?
This is hard. Perhaps R12 In Salem ($345,000), R17 Out Salem ($443,400) 90k over a few weeks, averaged 90 odd with onfield scores of 91 and 111. After round 17 he was injurred for a bit a regularly spudded it up before a couple of tonnes to finish the season. One I'll look at closely next year.

Kidding. actually its easy, Salem trade not even close to Rozee R16 $430k - 6 tonnes in 7 matches including a 168. Great M8. About 10% of teams picked him that week, so I'm no Nostradamus!
  • Who were your worst trade(s)?
Start crying. This is season ending stuff. I started Xerri at R3, I wanted to make cash. I wanted English. A few weeks later he goes from Grundy avg to Gawn avg. Game over.
OUT Xerri ($570,300) - IN English ($612,700)
OUT Roberts ($416,000) - IN Oliver ($476,700)
  • Who's the one you wish you had?
Neale. Serong. And Flanders sooner, was like 2nd last upgrade. Just too late.
  • Who's the one you wish you didn't have?
I wish I didn't start Newcombe. I was sooo set on him. Traded R2. Who
  • If you could go back with 20/20 hindsight, what three changes would you make to your starting team?
I still like starting Xerri at R3. Many didn't agree. Starting Flanders. I would also sell Tom Green at his first bye when everyone else who didn't have him were breaking their teams to get him!
  • How did your C/VC streak go? Once the wheels fell off my season my selections followed suit.
  • How did your byes go? No real gains, despite being well set up I thought.
  • What was the impact of the 40 trades? I didn't eat a donut. More early trading.
  • What will you change for next year? Less early trading. Back the roles. Looking to avoid the Young start/out/in shenanigans.
 
Joined
19 Jan 2016
Messages
1,925
Likes
6,552
#13
  • What was your overall rank? 9769
  • What is your general recap of the year? A few unlucky staring picks (Rozee types) set me back, but plugged away
  • Who were your best trade(s)? Clark, Neale, Zorko
  • Who were your worst trade(s)? McGovern (twice), Sicily, Oliver, Walsh, Rankine, Petracca, Green, Yeo, Macrae & Parish
  • Who's the one you wish you had? Ryan
  • Who's the one you wish you didn't have? Rozee
  • If you could go back with 20/20 hindsight, what three changes would you make to your starting team? Switch Rozee out for Serong, Switch Young for Ryan, switch Fisher out for Mass
  • How did your C/VC streak go? Awesome, normally it's a disaster zone, but great this year
  • What will you change for next year? Ima get me a 4 leaf clover
 
Joined
9 Jan 2022
Messages
64
Likes
262
AFL Club
GWS Giants
#14
  • What was your overall rank?
207
  • What is your general recap of the year?
    * Enjoyed the year as I was on a prolonged upward trajectory after a nightmare first round. I maintained great (potentially) cover across the lines until going with Schoenmaker as my only cover for non DPP defenders - ie Houston/Sheezel.
    * Started Xerri, Yeo and Heeney.

  • Who were your best trade(s)?
    Jordan to Darcy RD4
    Sweet to Marshall RD 12
    Williams to Daicos RD7

  • Who were your worst trade(s)?

    So many looking back - any 'must have' 650k player, and:
    Fisher to Berry (GC) RD2
    Comden to McKay RD15

  • Who's the one you wish you had?

    Opening 12 rounds of Gawn and Ryan

  • Who's the one you wish you didn't have?

    Started Newcombe and Berry (AC)

  • If you could go back with 20/20 hindsight, what three changes would you make to your starting team?

    Newcombe to Steel
    Grundy to Gawn
    Berry to Dempsey

  • How did your C/VC streak go?
    Average 133.7

  • How did your byes go?

    Happy with - 8,000th to 3,570th

  • What was the impact of the 40 trades?

    I made too many fomo trades. My trades look poor/average in hindsight my season was made in some great opening picks and a small number of successful early swings against the grain

  • What will you change for next year?
I was going to be expansive here, until I compiled the attached table which logs my rankings across the years, which i think is suggesting that I have under appreciated the value of luck whenever I am relatively successful at SC AFL.
 

Attachments

Connoisseur

Leadership Group
Joined
3 Jul 2017
Messages
38,668
Likes
125,808
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
#15
What will you change for next year?
I was going to be expansive here, until I compiled the attached table which logs my rankings across the years, which i think is suggesting that I have under appreciated the value of luck whenever I am relatively successful at SC AFL.
Best not to adapt this mindset or for it to be the main takeaway given it diminishes all that was achieved throughout the season and that it was unearned. Too often this is a simplistic and lazy takeaway as those accustomed to strong finishes cannot take responsibility for a poor finish relative to their unrealistic expectations and use ”luck” as their downfall or on the flip side those that have a high ranking season owe it to “luck”. Hard to maintain a high consistent rank over the years so expect peaks and troughs throughout.
 
Joined
8 Aug 2012
Messages
418
Likes
2,699
AFL Club
Bulldogs
#16
I was extremely disappointed with my coaching effort this year. I made too many trade calls that failed and I also made quite a few flat-out mistakes - missed looping, not getting my captain picks set up before cut-o*** etc. My excuse on the latter is that I had knee replacment surgery in April & boy did the recovery throw out my concentration...


What was your overall rank?
35K
What is you general recap of the year?
My first round was a disaster - I was over 500 points off the pace and about 80,000th. That probably panicked me into making a few rash early trades. Nevertheless I quickly recovered my ranking to the 20,000s but couldnt improve from there and gradually slipped backwards again.
I think most of what I did was fine, but you cant afford too many slip-ups. Compared to other years I think I actually had less bad luck with injuries.
Who were your best trade(s)?
Bringing in Daicos at R6 - I think this was a win over those who started him
Flanders in R6 was great although not as good as starting him.
Bringing in Will Day at R11 for $500K - ave 111 over the next 9 games (but he bombed after that)
Ed Richards ave 103 after I traded him in for 475K at R10
Zorko in R16 - but I was probably a few weeks too slow to move
Caldwell in R15 - before most and scored well as a fwd - ave 100
Who were your worst trades(s)?
There were a lot of these..
Max King in R4 and out in R6
Callaghan in R9 disappointed me - maybe next year
Just to rub it in, my last trade in R22 was Darcy to Rayner. Rayner was playing mids and had scored 100, 122, 111 & 99 in the previous 4 weeks. He then went 72, 58, 72 while Darcy went 78. 146 & 80
But starting errors were probably the worst.. see below
Who’s the one you wish you had?
Would have liked to have started these keeper-types Gawn, Ryan & Serong.
And started these rookie types McKercher, Dempsey who I got as correction trades
Who’s the one you wish you didn’t have?
Oliver, Rayner, Newcombe, Owens
If you could go back with 20/20 hindsight, what three changes would you make to your starting team?
I have done a bit of analysis on my starting team
Screenshot 9.JPG
In the first panel I've highlighted the players in yellow who I held through the entire season - Blue for a couple I traded out but brought back and retained.

In the second panel I've highted the 19 players I started that were also in the starting line-up of the SC winner - Caleb Windsor Knot.
You'd think with 19/30 picks in common I'd being doing OK - I did try to analyse this in an early post in another thread...
https://supercoachscores.com/thread...am-post-242-onwards.4408/page-14#post-1134247

In the third panel, I've highlighted the players I wish I hadnt started.. The worst thing about this is that Newcombe and Owens were players I had picked out from way back as definites in my starting team
How did your C/VC streak go?
Mucked this up at least twice - averaged about 129
How did your byes go?
Held my middling ranking
What was the impact of the 40 trades?
As mentioned by others, the weird approach to R0 skewed a few things.
I think I made more cash-grab type trades early on that I regretted.
What will you change for next year?
Try to resist cash-grab trades.. mayvbe start 1-2 more rookies rather than Lyon, Berry Budarick types,
 
Joined
9 Feb 2015
Messages
9,386
Likes
57,602
AFL Club
West Coast
#17
SuperCoach AFL 2024 champion reveals the tactics than won him $50,000
The 20-year-old winner of SuperCoach AFL 2024 reveals the tactics that led him to the game’s top prize, beating out more than 200,000 players across the country.

Al Paton

Follow

@al_superfooty


4 min read
September 3, 2024 - 1:13PM

Chasing the title of 2024 SuperCoach champion came with an added level of stress for university student Joven May.
May lined up at half-back for the Yass Roos in a qualifying final knowing he was a chance to land the $50,000 prize in Australia’s biggest fantasy sports game.

And every score in Round 24 was crucial to his fortunes after starting the weekend 144 points behind the overall leader.

“It was another layer of stress. I played OK in that game but I was thinking a lot about SuperCoach as well,” he said after storming home to claim the top prize – and helping the Roos through to this Saturday’s premiership decider.

“I was checking the scores when I came off and during the quarter-time and halftime breaks. “Luckily there are no rules (about looking at phones during matches) in AFL Canberra Div 3.”

May’s SuperCoach team - Caleb Windsor Knot - finished the season on 55,927 points at an average of 2330 per round.

His squad finished 80 points clear of Cadee’s Crew, the team that had gone into the final round at the top of the leaderboard.

A mad Geelong fan, May is an exercise physiology student at the University of Canberra. Despite his young age, the 20-year-old is a seasoned SuperCoach veteran.

“My dad made me a team when I was about seven. I don’t think I made too many of the decisions back then but I’ve been playing really for as long as I can remember. He really taught me the basics of the game.

“He actually took a break this year but I think me might come out of retirement and try to replicate what I did.”


Joven May (middle) celebrates with mates.

Trading in Lachie Neale helped May charge home. Picture: Getty

May’s Tip 1: Get your timing right on trades

The 2024 champ attributes his success to smart trades, and a healthy slice of luck.
“Timing is everything in this game,” he said.

When Max Gawn was injured in round 18, May “zigged when everyone else zagged” by replacing him with Rowan Marshall, who finished the year like a steam train, averaging 126 points a game over the final seven rounds.

The same week saw the arrival of Hawk Dylan Moore – who averaged 106.3 from round 19 onwards as forwards around him crumbled – while bringing in Lachie Neale after Brisbane’s bye and Josh Dunkley and Errol Gulden the next week set up his charge to the finish line.

May’s Tip 2: Chase value

When looking for SuperCoach recruits, value was everything for May.

“I didn’t own Luke Ryan, Zak Butters or Caleb Serong for the whole season.” he said.

“I was pretty adamant about chasing value. You don’t get the points they scored when they’re not in your team.”

But he didn’t get every call right.

“I always thought you had to have a perfect season to win, but I had a lot of things go wrong.

“I brought in Clayton Oliver and he was awful. I brought in Izak Rankine in round 10 and he did his hammy that week.”

He rated Touk Miller as another failed trade and while Zac Fisher delivered some good scores, “he was very annoying”.

May’s Tip 3: Avoid top-tier players at the start

May largely avoided top-priced players in his starting team – with the exception of Marcus Bontempelli, Max Gawn and Harry Sheezel – and instead banked on mid-pricers including Docker Jordan Clark, who went on to average 104.6 points a game for the season.

“I started him and checked his ownership and I thought a lot more people had him, he was an accidental POD,” May said.

Not all his mid-pricers succeeded, but even players like Ollie Wines and Nat Fyfe played a role in his overall success.

“A lot of mid-pricers I started ended up flopping but having them in your team gives you the flexibility to jump on the ones that do pop off – I got on guys like Riley Bonner, (Massimo) D’Ambrosio and Tom Powell pretty early.”

May’s Tip 4: Back your gut

Another smart early move was grabbing North Melbourne ruckman Tristan Xerri, the breakout SuperCoach star of 2024.

“I had him all pre-season but got fooled by Brodie Grundy in round zero, as a lot of us did,” May said.

He was quick to make a correction after just two rounds which meant he missed out on some of Grundy’s best scores, but Xerri “was better than I ever thought he would be”.

May’s Tip 5: Save your trades

May made aggressive moves early, but saving trades for a hectic finish proved pivotal.

“I knew I wanted to have trades left at the end in case of an emergency. You don’t ever want to leave yourself with a doughnut, and I was lucky I had enough left heading into the final few rounds.”

He already has some undervalued players in mind for his 2025 squad, but one challenge will be devising a new name for his champion team.

“I always try to come up with a name that’s a pun on an AFL player. Caleb Windsor Knot is probably one of my better ones, to be honest, so I’m glad I won it with a good team name.”

Joven says much of his winnings will go towards his HECS debt, but he does have a cruise planned with some school mates before next footy season.

“I might have to shout a few rounds on the cruise,” he said.

He might also want to buy one for his dad.
 
Joined
1 Feb 2016
Messages
106
Likes
807
AFL Club
Essendon
#18
What was your overall rank?
2228.

What is your general recap of the year?
Would say I'm a bit disappointed at my overall rank given my hot start (2186 by Rd 3), endings are usually my specialty. But I went from 945 in Rd 14 and drifted backwards ever since then.

Felt real bad looking at my team at the last few rounds; had Rowell, Curnow and Bolton who I couldn't trade out after earmarking my last few trades for injuries. (Ended up needing those injury trades too :confused: so I wasn't even over-cautious).

I was about 2000 points off the winner. If I do a quick thought experiment and swap those 3 for Neale, Moore and Caldwell without thinking of cash, I'd be roughly better off by:
  • Rowell (traded in Rd 12, avg 88.5 :sick:) to Neale (avg 121.9 from Rd 12 on): +401 pts
  • Curnow (traded in Rd 16, avg 64.4 :cry:) to Moore (avg 105.3 from Rd 16 on): +497 pts
  • Bolton (traded in Rd 13, avg 69.6 :mad:) to Caldwell (avg 99.3 from Rd 13 on): +327 pts
Obviously these are quite cherry picked, and I was reasonably confident in all 3 of my picks so it's just bad coaching. But still - overall those 3 fake premos cost me 1225 points alone o_O, which is more than half the gap.

Who were your best trade(s)?
Getting Heeney in Rd 2 was a great trade but that almost counts as a starting pick. Getting Flanders in might've saved my season early but he was also very popular so not much there. The main trade for positive PODs were:
  • LDU in Rd 14 for a 113.4 average to power home
  • Sinclair in Rd 9 for a 114.5 average after that, felt like he was nearly D1
  • Whitfield in Rd 17 for a 124.75 average
Who were your worst trade(s)?
There's the common AFL quote that your bottom 6 players decide who wins the premiership. I have a funny feeling it's similar in SuperCoach - the 8 players on your bench are extremely useful. I had a D7-D8 weakness all year which I didn't address and which caused me to overcompensate and worry about it a lot. Sometimes it just meant I had less mental effort to put into the other parts of my team.

So my worst trade was definitely Josh Draper. I got him in Rd 4 and complained about him all year after that. If he was D8 then it's fine, but I was always worried about a late out and Draper getting a 10 on field for me :eek:.

Other bad trades included the Unholy Trinity mentioned above, as well as trading out Tom Stewart just before his hot run.

Who's the one you wish you had?
Finally got Xerri in Rd 23 but will still put him here. Lachie Neale is also someone I had been eyeing for a long time but missed out on all year :cry:.

Who's the one you wish you didn't have?
Think I answered this above with the Rowell / Curnow / Bolton horror stories :geek:.

If you could go back with 20/20 hindsight, what three changes would you make to your starting team?
My starting team was quite good and I never got better :LOL:. With absolute 20/20 hindsight, Tom Green was a bad pick because he got injured on 5, I'd probably swap him out for Neale. I'd also find some way to fit Luke Ryan and Flanders into the starting squad instead.

How did your C/VC streak go?
Pretty poor, I think my VC/C selections are consistently worse than contending coaches. Will probably post in the VC/C chat to investigate this further. But case in point, 19/22 of my main final premos were all fine -- so something had to make up the difference :ROFLMAO:.

How did your byes go?
Rather disappointing due to my own mistakes. I was set up very well with planning but then ran into trade pressure. Decided to save trades rather than go aggressive in Rd 14/15, which cost me points. See next question for the explanation :p.

What was the impact of the 40 trades?
I severely miscalculated them. I eyeballed 40 trades over 20 rounds and guessed I could trade hard all year and still have enough :LOL:. Turns out 5 boosts and 4 bye rounds eat up your trades real quick. I think I did the maths in one of my weekly recaps but can't work it out anymore -- I just know however many trades is not enough for me ;).

What will you change for next year?
Hard to say other than avoiding 3 awful non-premos in my ending team. I thought my rookie selections were bad but after analysing them they were okay, definitely not a strength but not terrible. I should do more C/VC research and calculate byes / trades better as well.

This year feels a bit disappointing because all these mistakes are my own coaching errors, I'd say my team was quite good. But that means if I correct them then I have a real shot next year :cool:. Always look on the bright side!
 

Connoisseur

Leadership Group
Joined
3 Jul 2017
Messages
38,668
Likes
125,808
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
#19
What was your overall rank?
3982 and my best performance in quite some time.

Who were your best trade(s)?
I Rankine at $454,700 in RD6 and then traded in RD10 for close to a $100k gain to then watch others chase lost points at his peak on his return from injury.

N Martin in RD5 prior to def status. Was cautious to start a def in mid due to ceiling concerns but fixed that before his price went over $550.

Finishing off the forward premium selections with Zorko in RD13, Moore in RD14, Flanders in Rd15 and Caldwell in RD17.

Who were your worst trade(s)?
By far going overboard on quick cash gen attempts which limited my ability later on for injury/premium trades.
T Berry in RD2 and out RD3
J Billings in RD2 and out RD4
M Windhager in RD2 and out RD3
T Stewart over L Ryan to replace M Windhager in RD4
C Daniel in for RD12 without a low breakeven and then out post byes and Z Fisher that same round
H Thomas and J Rogers at elevated price tags either before or post bubble
Comben to Oliver in RD8

Who's the one you wish you had?
Xerri over Grundy as a starter and Ryan over Stewart as a trade in for RD4. Sinclair/Whitfield around the byes/post byes rather than Oliver/a midfielder.

Who's the one you wish you didn't have?
In terms of starters very tough as most of my premiums started well which would leave Grundy (see previous answer). In terms of trades (bar rookies/mid pricers) would have to be Oliver given the points leaked at M8 and the opportunity missed to capitalise on those that picked him.

If you could go back with 20/20 hindsight, what three changes would you make to your starting team?
Starting team was:
IMG_3408.jpeg
Out: H Himmelberg, J Lyons and C Lazzaro
In: M D’Ambrosio, S Flanders and O Dempsey

Saves three trades I would eventually make, moves McKercher onfield and Flanders up forward rather than waiting for him until the byes. Overkill down back with Himmelberg and the early bye and Massimo was one I identified in the preseason. Also may have helped from silly attempts at cash gen up forward in the early rounds (Billings, Berry, etc). Kept Grundy all season and content with his production but Xerri over him would have been another.

How did your C/VC streak go?
Lowest return recorded since 2021 onwards of 127.67. Only two below 100 (95 and 99) but missed the 160-180 scores from Daicos, Gawn and Bont.

What was the impact of the 40 trades?
Personally did not have much of an impact as I am accustomed to the other formats with 2-3 most rounds, navigating schedules, byes, etc. I will still use them early and will allow some riskier starting selections if you time it right for jumping off and especially early then you can limit the damage of some poor decisions. Did not try to chase too many players at their peak (eg $600k+) chasing lost points expecting them to magically sustain it for the remainder of the season, as the suckers that got Rowell close to $650,000 or Ryan at $670,000+ helped me tread water for most of the season without sliding down the ranks and with the added trades I‘d expect the same situations to recur with other players. Held onto the likes of Young early whereas others traded and still expect plenty of reactionary trades to continue to eat up at the 40.

What will you change for next year?
Not much. Cheap up forward once again with only one or two starters over $300k as has been the case for the past few seasons. Try and identify those discounted due to subs, injuries, role changes (eg younger player now transitioning into a midfield role) to allow the cash to be better utilised in the ruck, midfield and backline.

Aggressive with trades once again to exploit those playing too conservatively but hopefully limit the wasted trades on rookies which is usually my downfall as most do not have lucrative or clearly defined roles comparative to other sports, lack of a depth chart does not help and most squads still seem to default to a LIFO approach making it trickier to avoid those that make sub $100k. This should allow more premium trades later in the season or for injured players. Also may help to avoid those situations where I have to go for the likes of an Oliver due to funds.

Pay little attention to the early byes with opening round and thus little influence on starting selections as I felt this was a contributing factor for my success this season given most were unfamiliar with how to handle it if they have not participated in other fantasy sports. They opted to avoid good selections for the perceived security of a later bye and potentially overexpose themselves to one or a few teams in the process.
 
Top