Div 2: Trades Thread - Post Official Trades here
- Thread starter Damoz
- Start date
I'm going to be controversial and put up a vote against this trade.
I have considered it heavily and I know I won't be in the good books with the 2 traders, but it isn't personal.
I believe it heavily favours Moneyball FC.
I think it is based on Mummy averaging 140, but IMO he is an injury prone ruck that may average 108-112.
It's unlikely that I will enter further debate on the topic, as the above is my firm and considered opinion.
I have considered it heavily and I know I won't be in the good books with the 2 traders, but it isn't personal.
I believe it heavily favours Moneyball FC.
I think it is based on Mummy averaging 140, but IMO he is an injury prone ruck that may average 108-112.
It's unlikely that I will enter further debate on the topic, as the above is my firm and considered opinion.
Trade was agreed upon at 2:52pm Tuesday so it would have passed today at 2:52pm given that there was only 1 decline before the deadline.
Agreed that trade looked a bit one sided but it seems that both coaches involved were happy with the trade as it met their needs.
A bit hard this one because there are no more Premium Rucks in the draft and as it as Premium Rucks are so rare that they do command higher value when traded.
Agreed that trade looked a bit one sided but it seems that both coaches involved were happy with the trade as it met their needs.
A bit hard this one because there are no more Premium Rucks in the draft and as it as Premium Rucks are so rare that they do command higher value when traded.
Last edited:
PENDING TRADE:
vin.gil Trading with Benno.
The Vindicators >>> Moneyball FC
* Cyril Rioli, HAW, FWD
* Jack Redden, BRI, MID
* Luke Hodge, HAW, MID/DEF
Moneyball FC>>> The Vindicators
* Eric McKenzie, WCE, DEF
* Mathew Leuenberger, BRI, RUC
* Luke Shuey, WCE, MID
PENDING TRADE EXPIRES: Thursday, July 3rd 2014 at 6.20 PM
vin.gil Trading with Benno.
The Vindicators >>> Moneyball FC
* Cyril Rioli, HAW, FWD
* Jack Redden, BRI, MID
* Luke Hodge, HAW, MID/DEF
Moneyball FC>>> The Vindicators
* Eric McKenzie, WCE, DEF
* Mathew Leuenberger, BRI, RUC
* Luke Shuey, WCE, MID
PENDING TRADE EXPIRES: Thursday, July 3rd 2014 at 6.20 PM
Sorry guys, but I'm going to officially decline this trade. I'm declining on the basis that I don't believe it is a fair trade for both parties.
Rioli is out injured for 8-10 weeks
Redden is also expected to be out injured for 6-8 weeks.
So both players will be unavailable for basically the remainder of the SCDL season
Basically, MBFC is getting Hodge plus 2 players that are unlikely to play for an extended period, but loosing 3 players, Shuey and McKenzie are un injured and Leunberger whom is expected to resume in 1-3 weeks.
Rioli is out injured for 8-10 weeks
Redden is also expected to be out injured for 6-8 weeks.
So both players will be unavailable for basically the remainder of the SCDL season
Basically, MBFC is getting Hodge plus 2 players that are unlikely to play for an extended period, but loosing 3 players, Shuey and McKenzie are un injured and Leunberger whom is expected to resume in 1-3 weeks.