Div 2: Trades Thread - Post Official Trades here

Joined
29 Mar 2012
Messages
8,681
Likes
165
AFL Club
Geelong
#21
If you need a player from another Team, then you've only got less than 9 hours left to get the player(s) for Round 1!!!
 

Benno

50 Games Club
Joined
17 Dec 2013
Messages
534
Likes
15
AFL Club
West Coast
#22
Confirmed :)

*Note that S.Docherty will be delisted to accommodate the 3 for 4 trade*
 

RocketPip

Rising Star Nominee
Joined
11 Jul 2013
Messages
175
Likes
16
AFL Club
Melbourne
#23
Trade has been agreed upon between Moneyball FC and Heckle Rock Rowdies...

Moneyball FC Trading Out:
S Mumford
R Bastinac
A Gaff
1st round pick in 3rd (upcoming) Minidraft

Heckle Rock Rowdies Trading Out:
T Rockliff
M Pavlich
M Priddis
M Leuenberger
 

Benno

50 Games Club
Joined
17 Dec 2013
Messages
534
Likes
15
AFL Club
West Coast
#24
Don't know why my confirmation was time stamped up there??:confused: but yeah refer to post 22 for my confirmation.
 

Giblet

Rising Star Nominee
Joined
26 Nov 2013
Messages
102
Likes
14
AFL Club
Gold Coast
#26
Trade has been agreed upon between Moneyball FC and Heckle Rock Rowdies...

Moneyball FC Trading Out:
S Mumford
R Bastinac
A Gaff
1st round pick in 3rd (upcoming) Minidraft

Heckle Rock Rowdies Trading Out:
T Rockliff
M Pavlich
M Priddis
M Leuenberger
Interesting one.

S Mumford (140 ave but realistically 110)
R Bastinac 77
A Gaff 85
1st round pick in 3rd (upcoming) Minidraft
for
T Rockliff 115
M Pavlich 96 FWD
M Priddis 100
M Leuenberger 59 (but I put him at 90 due in rd 16)
 

Giblet

Rising Star Nominee
Joined
26 Nov 2013
Messages
102
Likes
14
AFL Club
Gold Coast
#27
I'm going to be controversial and put up a vote against this trade.
I have considered it heavily and I know I won't be in the good books with the 2 traders, but it isn't personal.
I believe it heavily favours Moneyball FC.
I think it is based on Mummy averaging 140, but IMO he is an injury prone ruck that may average 108-112.
It's unlikely that I will enter further debate on the topic, as the above is my firm and considered opinion.
 

vin.gill

250 Games Club
Joined
14 Jan 2014
Messages
1,338
Likes
174
AFL Club
North Melb.
#28
I'm going to be controversial and put up a vote against this trade.
I have considered it heavily and I know I won't be in the good books with the 2 traders, but it isn't personal.
I believe it heavily favours Moneyball FC.
I think it is based on Mummy averaging 140, but IMO he is an injury prone ruck that may average 108-112.
It's unlikely that I will enter further debate on the topic, as the above is my firm and considered opinion.
Kinda agreeing with this comment...
 

av1jme

Dual Best & Fairest
Joined
26 Apr 2013
Messages
3,299
Likes
56
AFL Club
Sydney
#30
Trade was agreed upon at 2:52pm Tuesday so it would have passed today at 2:52pm given that there was only 1 decline before the deadline.

Agreed that trade looked a bit one sided but it seems that both coaches involved were happy with the trade as it met their needs. :)
A bit hard this one because there are no more Premium Rucks in the draft and as it as Premium Rucks are so rare that they do command higher value when traded.

Trade has been agreed upon between Moneyball FC and Heckle Rock Rowdies...

Moneyball FC Trading Out:
S Mumford
R Bastinac
A Gaff
1st round pick in 3rd (upcoming) Minidraft

Heckle Rock Rowdies Trading Out:
T Rockliff
M Pavlich
M Priddis
M Leuenberger
 
Last edited:
Joined
18 Jun 2012
Messages
6,009
Likes
11,376
AFL Club
Melbourne
#32
PENDING TRADE:
Deeman1 Trading with Benno.
GV Vikings >>> Moneyball FC
* Nick Riewoldt, STK, FWD
* Jake Melksham, ESS, MID

Moneyball FC>>> GV Vikings
* Chris Dawes, MEL, FWD
* Dylan Shiel, GWS, MID

PENDING TRADE EXPIRES: When Benno accepts
 
Joined
18 Jun 2012
Messages
6,009
Likes
11,376
AFL Club
Melbourne
#34
PENDING TRADE:
Deeman1 Trading with Benno.
GV Vikings >>> Moneyball FC
* Nick Riewoldt, STK, FWD
* Jake Melksham, ESS, MID

Moneyball FC>>> GV Vikings
* Chris Dawes, MEL, FWD
* Dylan Shiel, GWS, MID

PENDING TRADE EXPIRES: Thursday, June 19, 2014 at 12.39 PM
 
Joined
29 Mar 2012
Messages
8,681
Likes
165
AFL Club
Geelong
#35
PENDING TRADE:
Deeman1 Trading with Benno.
GV Vikings >>> Moneyball FC
* Nick Riewoldt, STK, FWD
* Jake Melksham, ESS, MID

Moneyball FC>>> GV Vikings
* Chris Dawes, MEL, FWD
* Dylan Shiel, GWS, MID

PENDING TRADE EXPIRES: Thursday, June 19, 2014 at 12.39 PM
Trade has been updated in Team Sheets. :)

The Trades Table will be updated later.
 

Benno

50 Games Club
Joined
17 Dec 2013
Messages
534
Likes
15
AFL Club
West Coast
#36
A trade has been agreed upon between The Vindicators and Moneyball FC

VIN
Out: C.Rioli, J.Redden, L.Hodge
In: E.MacKenzie, M.Leuenberger, L.Shuey

MFC
Out: E.MacKenzie, M.Leuenberger, L.Shuey
In: C.Rioli, J.Redden, L.Hodge
 

vin.gill

250 Games Club
Joined
14 Jan 2014
Messages
1,338
Likes
174
AFL Club
North Melb.
#37
A trade has been agreed upon between The Vindicators and Moneyball FC

VIN
Out: C.Rioli, J.Redden, L.Hodge
In: E.MacKenzie, M.Leuenberger, L.Shuey

MFC
Out: E.MacKenzie, M.Leuenberger, L.Shuey
In: C.Rioli, J.Redden, L.Hodge
confirmed
 
Joined
18 Jun 2012
Messages
6,009
Likes
11,376
AFL Club
Melbourne
#38
PENDING TRADE:
vin.gil Trading with Benno.
The Vindicators >>> Moneyball FC
* Cyril Rioli, HAW, FWD
* Jack Redden, BRI, MID
* Luke Hodge, HAW, MID/DEF

Moneyball FC>>> The Vindicators
* Eric McKenzie, WCE, DEF
* Mathew Leuenberger, BRI, RUC
* Luke Shuey, WCE, MID

PENDING TRADE EXPIRES: Thursday, July 3rd 2014 at 6.20 PM
 
Joined
18 Jun 2012
Messages
6,009
Likes
11,376
AFL Club
Melbourne
#39
PENDING TRADE:
vin.gil Trading with Benno.
The Vindicators >>> Moneyball FC
* Cyril Rioli, HAW, FWD
* Jack Redden, BRI, MID
* Luke Hodge, HAW, MID/DEF

Moneyball FC>>> The Vindicators
* Eric McKenzie, WCE, DEF
* Mathew Leuenberger, BRI, RUC
* Luke Shuey, WCE, MID

PENDING TRADE EXPIRES: Thursday, July 3rd 2014 at 6.20 PM
Sorry guys, but I'm going to officially decline this trade. I'm declining on the basis that I don't believe it is a fair trade for both parties.

Rioli is out injured for 8-10 weeks
Redden is also expected to be out injured for 6-8 weeks.

So both players will be unavailable for basically the remainder of the SCDL season

Basically, MBFC is getting Hodge plus 2 players that are unlikely to play for an extended period, but loosing 3 players, Shuey and McKenzie are un injured and Leunberger whom is expected to resume in 1-3 weeks.
 

vin.gill

250 Games Club
Joined
14 Jan 2014
Messages
1,338
Likes
174
AFL Club
North Melb.
#40
Sorry guys, but I'm going to officially decline this trade. I'm declining on the basis that I don't believe it is a fair trade for both parties.

Rioli is out injured for 8-10 weeks
Redden is also expected to be out injured for 6-8 weeks.

So both players will be unavailable for basically the remainder of the SCDL season

Basically, MBFC is getting Hodge plus 2 players that are unlikely to play for an extended period, but loosing 3 players, Shuey and McKenzie are un injured and Leunberger whom is expected to resume in 1-3 weeks.
that's fair enough, I'd just like to point out that the potentially disadvantaged party (MoneyBall FC) are the ones who proposed the trade

and I believe Jack Redden 4-6 weeks is speculation at this stage, he will miss this week though

happy to change Rioli to someone else if that works
 
Top