Discussion 2023 Round 11: Teams & In Game Discussion

Darkie

Leadership Group
Joined
12 Apr 2014
Messages
25,412
Likes
65,505
AFL Club
Collingwood
Couldn't decide between Sicily or Stewart for the Vc, went with Stewart in the end, good result.

Now with XON a late in, i was split between bringing in Merrett or Macrae for Oli, with XON in and most likely tagging Merrett, thinking of trading out Merrett for Macrae. Was a line-ball decision, really not sure what to do.
I wouldn’t trade Merrett back out for one potential tag score. Macrae’s role is pretty suboptimal (unless he gets forward status).
 

Connoisseur

Leadership Group
Joined
3 Jul 2017
Messages
38,964
Likes
126,637
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
I've traded him in and made him captain
Depends on your confidence in your remaining options in regards to captaincy. There is still 3300 points to distribute in the match tonight and unless you expect the Bombers to losem then Merrett should still feature enough for a 110+. Is O’Neil an effective tagger (comparative to his counterparts) and has he significantly limited his direct opposition previously?

In regards to a trade in, did this match have any bearing in placing him above the alternative options? If it did significantly or was the sole reasoning, then I would consider a change.
 
Joined
13 Jan 2019
Messages
9,422
Likes
42,029
AFL Club
Sydney
late changes ….x o Neill brought into the 22 just as I mentioned earlier today….

will go straight to Zerrett I have no doubt…. Decisions decisions…
Given how atrocious Day was today without a tag, can we really credit O’Neill with the tagging effort?

I’m a little annoyed as I would’ve brought Stewart in over Merrett for Jelly, but I’ll stick with it now as I don’t really want to grab Libba.
 
Joined
29 Mar 2023
Messages
97
Likes
272
AFL Club
Richmond
I wouldn’t trade Merrett back out for one potential tag score. Macrae’s role is pretty suboptimal (unless he gets forward status).
If i did swap Macrae for Merrett, it's not just for this round and the tag, i was line-ball between the two before trading out Oli. I think i'll just stick with Merrett though. Thanks for your input. (y)
 
Top