Discussion 2024 Round 1: Teams & In Game Discussion

[Miller is a Steele]

@Ben’s Beasts @Deeman1 and other Dees supporters… I notice Tomlinson has been omitted. Who do you expect to play that third tall role, Howes or Hore?

 

[jobeywatto]

Martin named on a wing, anyone else jumping off

He was named wing in the practice game I believe, but I'd be more concerned about Heppell, Kelly and Cox all being named.

 

[Feerits Elf]

Martin named on a wing, anyone else jumping off

Yep

I'm also jumping off Zac Fisher because he was named at right HBF

It's left HBF or nothing, baby!

 

[Under The Dome]

Hore comes in for Reid and takes over onfield duties for Howes.

 

[XabiFernando]

If it is Bowey that he's replacing its very tempting to bank the Gibcus cash

Edit: on Hore

 

[Vicwood]

My goodness my head is spining with all the Rookies named, think i will get through tonights match and have a good look. lots of last minute options to consider.

Reid to Lyons is the first change i will consider.

 

[Herbie66]

Reidy named on extended bench for Freo/ Sunday game ...not ideal for Jackson owners

Is that a surprise that a club would name a back up ruckman on a extended bench for a game on Sunday ?

 

[sethlad]

Is it too early in the year to ask why people still care where players are named on paper?

 

[GrainFedBeef]

Is that a surprise that a club would name a back up ruckman on a extended bench for a game on Sunday ?

Except there has been speculation this week that Freo will play him. Expect he is just as you say, an emg.

 

[Shannon]

Is that a surprise that a club would name a back up ruckman on a extended bench for a game on Sunday ?

No but not ideal as I stated

 

[Vicwood]

So do we start Hore over Zach Reid now?

If Hore has the Bowey role, one to consider. Any Melbourne supporters with any advice on other options on who has the bowey role.? Brayshaw and now Bowey out leaves lots of points down back for the Demons. Anyone else now considering looping Gibcus.?

 

[OnTopBar]

Hore comes in for Reid and takes over onfield duties for Howes.

Bit of a decision here, had Phillips a D8, not named, so need to find $20k, reckon Gibcus > Hore and Phillips > Coffield. I'd like to keep Gibcus because of his low BE and JS. Other choice is Windsor down, might go that way instead

 

[Vicwood]

Hore in for Coffield. The dogs have lots of options down back who can play the role , the Demons not so many.?

 

[Bombers2win]

If Hore has the Bowey role, one to consider. Any Melbourne supporters with any advice on other options on who has the bowey role.? Brayshaw and now Bowey out leaves lots of points down back for the Demons. Anyone else now considering looping Gibcus.?

Nah, I’m going to have plenty of loops next week and so on, I’m just enjoying 29 green dots ATM!

 

[Herbie66]

Except there has been speculation this week that Freo will play him. Expect he is just as you say, an emg.

Playing Sunday , they might not even had their final training session yet.

Might wait until they finalise their 23 tomorrow afternoon and see what they do.

I own Jackson but if they want to keep their system/structure surprised they don't pick Reidy , obviously wouldn't ruck as much as Darcy would.

 

[Vicwood]

my goodness imaging all the coaches who had 4 keeper in DEF with Williams at D5, with all these DEF rookies named. Hore is of real interest to me, coffield might make way.

 

[Under The Dome]

Bit of a decision here, had Phillips a D8, not named, so need to find $20k, reckon Gibcus > Hore and Phillips > Coffield. I'd like to keep Gibcus because of his low BE and JS. Other choice is Windsor down, might go that way instead

Yeh keep Gibcus and go Windsor down

 

[Herbie66]

No but not ideal as I stated

Might wait until the 23 is finalised before panicking

 

[Uncle Drew]

He was named wing in the practice game I believe, but I'd be more concerned about Heppell, Kelly and Cox all being named.

Forget Martin owners, that's a dumpster fire of a team selection for us Bombers supporters. If those 3 are in our best 22 it's going to be a long year.

 

[freowho]

Hore being selected is good for Salem.