Discussion 2024 Round 9: Teams & In Game Discussion

Raaraab

Raaraab

#301
Joined
3 Jun 2014
Messages
425
Likes
1,907
AFL Club
St Kilda
#301
4/390, Gawn, Walsh, Oliver and Windsor
Big night tonight with Houston, Heeney, Grundy, Ryan, Serong, Fyfe, Jackson plus Roberts to play.
NWM, DWilson, Bont, DJones, Green, Sheezel, SDarcy, TBrown, Crouch and HReid over the weekend.

Regret getting caught up in the hype on how cheap Clarry was, hindsight’s easy and should have waited and watched another week. Strongly considering using one of my 3 remaining Boosts to trade Yeo for Sinclair but will likely wait a week. Reversed my trade on Roberts after Graham was omitted.
 
GrainFedBeef

GrainFedBeef

#307
Joined
6 Jul 2012
Messages
4,917
Likes
11,248
AFL Club
West Coast
#307
MagpiePotato said:
Haha, i was actually expecting them to find his free against and take him down to 96. It is pure sorcery. As said before you simply cannot convince me some players don't get treated differently to others.... It's almost making me prefer the AFL fantasy format as it isn't ambiguous and no stats rely on someones opinion... and this is from someone who has finished top 500 the last 2 years in SC. (doing terrible this year though).
Click to expand...
don’t beat yourself up brother. It is the same scorers. The umpire decides the free kick, the recorder note its, same raw data feeding into fantasy and SC systems. Maybe you are watching on Kayo which lags actual game and site had updated already. I am sure we all have seen times when we saw an event and they didnt seem to include it.
 
jel

jel

#309
Joined
25 Feb 2019
Messages
2,640
Likes
11,930
AFL Club
Adelaide
#309
GrainFedBeef said:
don’t beat yourself up brother. It is the same scorers. The umpire decides the free kick, the recorder note its, same raw data feeding into fantasy and SC systems. Maybe you are watching on Kayo which lags actual game and site had updated already. I am sure we all have seen times when we saw an event and they didnt seem to include it.
Click to expand...
Doesn't SC only get updated every ~30sec or so?
Multiple things can be counted in that time so it's hard to know the exact +/- for any act.
 
Chumpion

Chumpion

#310
Joined
9 Dec 2020
Messages
2,634
Likes
13,488
AFL Club
Essendon
#310
jel said:
Doesn't SC only get updated every ~30sec or so?
Multiple things can be counted in that time so it's hard to know the exact +/- for any act.
Click to expand...
Yep, plus previous actions are constantly being rescaled as the game unfolds and more information/stats/impact factors are known. So a player may seem to be not getting enough points or not being penalised, but it could instead be that some earlier actions are being rescaled that o***ets the expectations.
 
Maso

Maso

#312
Joined
18 Mar 2012
Messages
2,908
Likes
2,565
AFL Club
Essendon
#312
2/206
Hate to say it but im glad Dees did not pinch the win last night, as a non Gawn owner it would have hurt again big time :ROFLMAO:.
Went with the flock and got Oliver in this week for Graham, holding Yeo for now will continue to upgrade around him.
VC English into Daicos all things going well 2400-2500 is the target this week and hopefully closer to top 1000 (1618 currently)

Need to Find 1 more Mid and 1 FWD to ''complete'' my team, This will be with Dale D6, Oliver M8 and Reid F6 .
Obviously Reid will need to be replaced but nobody jumping out at me just yet.
 
GrainFedBeef

GrainFedBeef

#316
Joined
6 Jul 2012
Messages
4,917
Likes
11,248
AFL Club
West Coast
#316
jel said:
Doesn't SC only get updated every ~30sec or so?
Multiple things can be counted in that time so it's hard to know the exact +/- for any act.
Click to expand...
Chumpion said:
Yep, plus previous actions are constantly being rescaled as the game unfolds and more information/stats/impact factors are known. So a player may seem to be not getting enough points or not being penalised, but it could instead be that some earlier actions are being rescaled that o***ets the expectations.
Click to expand...
We need to ensure we don't get pulled into some vortex, the point was whether fantasy was more accurate for free kicks etc over SC. My comment was around its the same data set.

Having watched videos and size of team and looking and some going over it and video footage overlayed with data points, you do gain there is a lot of rigour to the system.

However expect there can still be subjective interpretation and they do review it, hence we notice it at game end changes made. what we dont appreciate is it probably happens in game and then a player does some else, and the net score doesn't equal what we just saw. That last comment fits into your comment Jel we are seeing in groups of 30 secs for SC where fantasy is more live as there is no scaling algo programs overlaying it.
 
Spifflicator

Spifflicator

#317
Joined
6 Feb 2013
Messages
399
Likes
1,625
AFL Club
GWS Giants
#317
Raaraab said:
4/390, Gawn, Walsh, Oliver and Windsor
Big night tonight with Houston, Heeney, Grundy, Ryan, Serong, Fyfe, Jackson plus Roberts to play.
NWM, DWilson, Bont, DJones, Green, Sheezel, SDarcy, TBrown, Crouch and HReid over the weekend.

Regret getting caught up in the hype on how cheap Clarry was, hindsight’s easy and should have waited and watched another week. Strongly considering using one of my 3 remaining Boosts to trade Yeo for Sinclair but will likely wait a week. Reversed my trade on Roberts after Graham was omitted.
Click to expand...
Oliver had a mountain of it but didn't convert it to SC pts. Nothing to worry about IMO
 
blue dreamer

blue dreamer

#320
Joined
21 Mar 2012
Messages
4,277
Likes
6,648
AFL Club
Carlton
#320
Vicwood said:
Yes the one in the 3rd quarter, Steve May got fingers on the ball, but goal allowed. I am sure you remember it.???

The moon landings supplied clearer video footage.
Click to expand...
Sorry Vic, I thought your original post implied this happened in Q1.

Was at the ground and there was no controversy or feeling that I was aware of that May had definitely touched the ball.

Your opinion is valid though, was just commenting regarding Q3 for both goals .
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top