Player X vs. Player Y

[manyproblems]

Hogan vs Gunston

 

[manyproblems]

Upgrade in a few weeks time..

M.Crouch vs Pendlebury for last MID spot?

Whoever is cheaper at the time. Can't go wrong with either.

 

[Herbie66]

anyone looking/considering Gunston or Robinson as a Top 10 forward ?

maybe even Boak ?

Feels like I am.paying way much for Heeney and/or Gray at the moment.

 

[Ben's Beasts]

With Higgins named despite the return of Caddy and Graham what do we all think of Higgins v Guelfi?

Tough one I reckon!

 

[minidee]

Gray v Cripps

 

[XabiFernando]

Gray v Cripps

Gray a definite top 6 forward, cripps may or may not be a top 8 mid

 

[Maccas marvels]

Guelfi vs ZGL vs Higgins ( selecting 2)

Would love some advice on why....... big dilemma with so many rookies to choose from this week

 

[Crabby Skills]

Guelfi vs ZGL vs Higgins ( selecting 2)

Would love some advice on why....... big dilemma with so many rookies to choose from this week

Guelfi and ZGL for me.

 

[Maccas marvels]

Guelfi and ZGL for me.

I am worried about job security for Higgins even though he has the highest scoring potential. Thanks for feedback, why do you think those two?

 

[DoggyODFL]

Guelfi vs ZGL vs Higgins ( selecting 2)

Would love some advice on why....... big dilemma with so many rookies to choose from this week

Guelfi and ZGL for me

I suspect Higgins will average more than these 2 but given he was dropped after his first game (which was pretty good) the other 2 have the better JS

 

[Maccas marvels]

Guelfi and ZGL for me

I suspect Higgins will average more than these 2 but given he was dropped after his first game (which was pretty good) the other 2 have the better JS

Thanks for the response, gives me something to consider

 

[Crabby Skills]

I am worried about job security for Higgins even though he has the highest scoring potential. Thanks for feedback, why do you think those two?

Guelfi and ZGL for me

I suspect Higgins will average more than these 2 but given he was dropped after his first game (which was pretty good) the other 2 have the better JS

Guelfi has best JS of the bunch in my opinion and GWS really like ZGL. Obviously everyone at the Tigers love Higgins too and he'll be a great player in the future, but he's a very confident (and driven tbf to him) kid, and I reckon Hardwick will just want to play tough with him to get the best out of him... sometime meaning he'll get dropped if a spot is 50/50.

 

[GrainFedBeef]

Guelfi and ZGL for me

I suspect Higgins will average more than these 2 but given he was dropped after his first game (which was pretty good) the other 2 have the better JS

Thanks for the response, gives me something to consider

Guelfi has best JS of the bunch in my opinion and GWS really like ZGL. Obviously everyone at the Tigers love Higgins too and he'll be a great player in the future, but he's a very confident (and driven tbf to him) kid, and I reckon Hardwick will just want to play tough with him to get the best out of him... sometime meaning he'll get dropped if a spot is 50/50.

Good discussion. I have now swung to Guelfi. After looking at his heatmap it is clear he is playing wing/mid rather than fwd. Looks a consistent scorer, maybe not high ceiling, mature rookie at 20 years old helps.

I have ZGL, has super high JS (based on coaches comments) although not as solid scorer.

 

[Maccas marvels]

Think I’m sold, thanks everyone for your thoughts.

 

[BigRuss]

Mirra v ZGL v Higgins

Guelfi Locked in as my first trade but having a real tough time splitting these three.

Normally would only be Mirra v ZGL but Higgins DPP will let me open the m/f link over the next couple of weeks which could end up being very handy.

 

[Steuby]

Looking for discounted premo mid that can slot nicely into M6-M8 (already have most of the big boys)

Neale v Zerrett v JPK v Bontempelli

 

[Imcjb]

Oliver v Macrae

 

[Maccas marvels]

Oliver v Macrae

McRae for me as he has higher ceiling and in less teams

 

[Steuby]

Oliver v Macrae

+1 Macrae

He's looked a class above whenever i've watched him play, that being said i dont think Oliver is a bad shout either

 

[Zoku Pops]

Savage v Howe

Ferrett v Selwood