Discussion Round 4: Teams & In Game Discussion

[Zimmer]

8/1003 (grundy)

Oliver, dunkley and Moore are on thin ice.

Really hoping Josh Kelly repays the faith today for holding him rounds 1 and 2

Yeah, think Dunkley might have to go.

 

[Zim^zuM]

Hope Bailet Scott doesn't get a late call-up lol. Grundy VC, stuffed up not having Bines on field yesterday for Gawn. Please stay rested, Scott

Same. Forgot to have gawn as emg.

Tyson also emergency which is pleasing. If he needs a rest hopefully it stays like that.

 

[FirstTimer]

Is Rowan Marshall a good trade for Smith or Smith worth holding ??? , put Rozee into Defence

 

[FirstTimer]

301/3 for me.

Looks pretty underwhelming given some of the other scores being posted, but given it’s one premium and two mid-pricers (Heeney, Libba and Moore), that actually feels okay. Heeney and Libba somewhat ahead of expectations too.

Whether I can jag a good C score to match Grundy owners, and how Hoff, Goldy and Andrews go, will probably be key again.

Do you have Lachie Neale he could be your answer your looking for ?

 

[IDIG]

The trap is set.

https://twitter.com/i/web/status/1116847878033432576

 

[Misky]

6/843 - Grundy C, still heaps of rookies to come, so far another good week in the making *touch wood*

 

[Professor]

Is Rowan Marshall a good trade for Smith or Smith worth holding ??? , put Rozee into Defence

Depends how he plays I think, might not be completely safe from Longer. Needs at least a 2 week stretch of form to fully establish himself in the team, currently doing that. Risk vs Reward, decisions decisions! !

 

[Yasi]

The trap is set.

https://twitter.com/i/web/status/1116847878033432576

And I think I’m a curious mouse - he does look elite

 

[IDIG]

And I think I’m a curious mouse - he does look elite

Undoubtedly elite but the big concern for me is when/if he spends more time forward.

 

[Darkie]

The trap is set.

https://twitter.com/i/web/status/1116847878033432576

Do you mean in terms of his role?

I think most of us have viewed him as an obvious SC gun if he could get a bit more ball ... just need that to continue?

 

[Darkie]

Do you have Lachie Neale he could be your answer your looking for ?

Thanks mate - I'm looking at Danger into Cripps or Neale. Not sure which way to go on the latter, although I'm hoping Danger eliminates the need to make that call!

 

[Darkie]

Is Rowan Marshall a good trade for Smith or Smith worth holding ??? , put Rozee into Defence

I don't have a strong view on Marshall, but personally I'm wondering if Brodie scores better with Seedsman out. I suspect he may, given that Laird, Seedsman, Smith and Milera all seem to be doing okay without shooting the lights out. Not a Crows expert though and I haven't seen much of their play this year.

 

[Yasi]

Undoubtedly elite but the big concern for me is when/if he spends more time forward.

They certainly seem to have the problem of not enough Bonts ...

 

[Herbie66]

Undoubtedly elite but the big concern for me is when/if he spends more time forward.

As long as they keep playing Naughton & Schache forward + Dickson , Bont will be staying put.

Listening to Bevo after the game they will take their time with Boyd , if Trengrove gets his act together suspect he will come in to support the golf course , Cordy & Crozier down back plus help English.

Bont looked like he was playing against kids last night , class above , just needs to fix up his goalkicking.

 

[Lost In The Sky]

7/910 Grundy VC

Nice to get a decent start to a week for once.

 

[Herbie66]

word is Gibbs was (finally) dropped for a lack of defensive effort/pressure , been a concern since late last season

 

[FirstTimer]

I don't have a strong view on Marshall, but personally I'm wondering if Brodie scores better with Seedsman out. I suspect he may, given that Laird, Seedsman, Smith and Milera all seem to be doing okay without shooting the lights out. Not a Crows expert though and I haven't seen much of their play this year.

Food for thought thanks Darkie , may wait a week but my only concern is if Marshal backs up another ton and Smith dogs it again (low score) the loss of potential cash is a bitter pill to swallow and the points ......decisions decisions i guess but you make some good points

 

[Drew]

word is Gibbs was (finally) dropped for a lack of defensive effort/pressure , been a concern since late last season

Thought he was good last year when we really needed him, seems to be stuffing it up this year when he has the ball, hopefully a couple of weeks in the SANFL does him some good.

 

[Jobi-Wan Kenobi]

I don’t have anyone not playing to loophole Grundy! How did I get in this spot?!?
Thoughts on me cashing out Scott or Gibbons to a base rookie to loophole this week and in to the future?
I also haven’t (clearly) done the research regarding who has lots of Sunday games.

 

[Herbie66]

Thought he was good last year when we really needed him, seems to be stuffing it up this year when he has the ball, hopefully a couple of weeks in the SANFL does him some good.

I think it is trying to fit them all in the midfield , wings and HBF that is the problem.

Sloane , Crouch * 2 , Milera , Atkins (or Knight) get confused who is who

then Laird , Smith , Gibbs

still think Greenwood needs more mid time as well

there is a certain small forward who needs a massive lift in output or he could be joining Gibbs