Discussion Rookie Roulette!

[Rumbler]

Collins vs Clark
Setterfield vs Drew

I’m actually really tempted to go Setterfield over Drew with how bad he is in losses and Carlton not having a very difficult match..

Problem for me is Setterfield's highest score this season has been 69 and that was back in round 1. Drew at least has a couple of tons under his belt. Then again I dunno how well he'll do against the Pies away....can't decide!

 

[quite ironic]

Problem for me is Setterfield's highest score this season has been 69 and that was back in round 1. Drew at least has a couple of tons under his belt. Then again I dunno how well he'll do against the Pies away....can't decide!

Setterfield has all been in losses though which is important along with some bad scores due to horrible clangers which won’t happen every week.

Drew averages 48 in 2 losses this season which is very likely this weekend.


Another thing is I believe Collingwood have by far the lowest sc scores against this year due to their high possessive game style which will also affect Drew a fair bit I reckon.

 

[Juzzo]

2 to field out of Clark, Collins, Ridley?

 

[BigRuss]

Wilkie Vs Clark for D6

 

[THCLT]

Wilkie Vs Clark for D6

Wilkie has demonstrated that he posses a higher ceiling than Clark. Wilkie will have a bigger role to play with all their defensive outs and I suspect the ball will be down his end a fair bit. Clark is returning to a pretty settled back six and has shown us that he can consistently push out scores in the 50's but nothing much higher.

If they were my options and I have no way of looping their scores, then I would lean towards playing Wilkie.

 

[Tamuhawk]

Stack Vs Hayes

They're playing against each another

 

[Grundogging]

Rolling with Butters and Drew looped into Atkins (or Ross / Hayes if I decide to bring one or them in for Atkins or Scott) and Baker.

 

[BigRuss]

Wilkie has demonstrated that he posses a higher ceiling than Clark. Wilkie will have a bigger role to play with all their defensive outs and I suspect the ball will be down his end a fair bit. Clark is returning to a pretty settled back six and has shown us that he can consistently push out scores in the 50's but nothing much higher.

If they were my options and I have no way of looping their scores, then I would lean towards playing Wilkie.

Yep, thats my thinking too mate, much appreciated.

 

[THCLT]

Stack Vs Hayes

They're playing against each another

For me, Hayes scores to date are more quantifiable, that is, reproducible without much improvement on what he's given thus far.

Stacks on the other hand have been heavily favoured by those pressure acts or 1% acts which makes it more harder to quantify and predict as it relies on when and where he performs them.

I think Hayes is the 'safer' play and Stacks if you're feeling it.

 

[Tamuhawk]

For me, Hayes scores to date are more quantifiable, that is, reproducible without much improvement on what he's given thus far.

Stacks on the other hand have been heavily favoured by those pressure acts or 1% acts which makes it more harder to quantify and predict as it relies on when and where he performs them.

I think Hayes is the 'safer' play and Stacks if you're feeling it.

Gibbons it is... ?

 

[THCLT]

Gibbons it is... ?

Thought it was only X v Y...But I like Gibbons against my mob!

 

[Tamuhawk]

Thought it was only X v Y...But I like Gibbons against my mob!

I should have been clearer. Stack vs Hayes for the E and Scott to field if either I choose does well. Gibbons for back up should the one I choose from Stack/Hayes fails... so I'll prob E Stack for the higher ceiling.

 

[Goodie's Guns]

Stack Vs Hayes

They're playing against each another

Same call for me with which one to through the EMG on (we seem to have had a lot of similar conundrums this week hahaha).

At this stage I've got it on Stack as well.

 

[quite ironic]

Hmmmmmm Clark v Collins

Need some opinions please

 

[NT.Thunder]

One out of Atkins/Gibbons or Fyfe?

Stand-down - I got this one!

 

[Dustman]

For me, Hayes scores to date are more quantifiable, that is, reproducible without much improvement on what he's given thus far.

Stacks on the other hand have been heavily favoured by those pressure acts or 1% acts which makes it more harder to quantify and predict as it relies on when and where he performs them.

I think Hayes is the 'safer' play and Stacks if you're feeling it.

Great logic,if I was smart,I’d follow that advice, but I’m gonna chase the slightly higher Stack ceiling,and I’ll have the ointment ready for when that bites me on the arse !

 

[THCLT]

One out of Atkins/Gibbons or Fyfe?

Stand-down - I got this one!

Could've ran something similar for last night's game...

Which of Duursma/Drew or Rocky for the E...?

 

[Professor]

Hmmmmmm Clark v Collins

Need some opinions please

I'd say Collins against WC, should see plenty of ball.

On a side note, Marsh to debut for the Saints, l see he's listed in the forward pocket.

 

[Tamuhawk]

Same call for me with which one to through the EMG on (we seem to have had a lot of similar conundrums this week hahaha).

At this stage I've got it on Stack as well.

Very similar indeed... maybe I should go the other way and go Hayes to make it fun lol.

 

[Adrenaline]

Two of gibbons/Atkins/hayes??

Leaning towards Atkins and Hayes