Position Midfielder Discussion
- Thread starter IDIG
- Start date
Worpel and Dunkley had role changes, so is McGrath going to have a role change.
RE:...…..does he have the tank to sustain it in that role...….
I can't see why not, he's played 62 games in 3 seasons and had a good preseason, but I don't know what his tank is like? I wouldn't be surprised if @THCLT has the answer
RE:...…..does he have the tank to sustain it in that role...….
I can't see why not, he's played 62 games in 3 seasons and had a good preseason, but I don't know what his tank is like? I wouldn't be surprised if @THCLT has the answer
I can't see why not, he's played 62 games in 3 seasons and had a good preseason, but I don't know what his tank is like? I wouldn't be surprised if @THCLT has the answer
He looks to be clearly part of the their core midfield group through Marsh, whether that's by design or through missing personnel is another question. Got plenty of the ball but not quite the CP style of a Dunkley or Worpel. He's more outside than inside so less tackles as well.
He has every chance to improve on this output if the role sticks for this season, however, being MID only pretty much makes him irrelevant for SC purposes.
The thing is, I'm not 100% confident on most of my non-gun players
I would be surprised if he didn't avg, at least, in the mid 90s.
I haven't locked McGrath in my team, just undecided for now.
I would be surprised if he didn't avg, at least, in the mid 90s.
I haven't locked McGrath in my team, just undecided for now.
I guess it ultimately comes down to how many and in what positions the rookies are selected in Round 1.
can't leave out the Bont , think with the captaincy he will rise to a new level
Libba might be back so he can sort out the taggers
I think if we worry too much about taggers , we would be trading mid premiums in and out all season
part of the game , so hopefully the scores even themselves out over the season
Libba might be back so he can sort out the taggers
I think if we worry too much about taggers , we would be trading mid premiums in and out all season
part of the game , so hopefully the scores even themselves out over the season
- Joined
- 31 Mar 2012
- Messages
- 1,124
- Likes
- 4,780
- AFL Club
- West Coast
Assuming they will all end up on your final side, i would leave out bont. In my view he is the most likely to have a down game meaning he could be picked up at some point cheaper than the others (equally he could have a spike score seeing a big price rise just when you want to upgrade to him). Plus having all 3 doggies seems.... unnecessary? Not sure that's the right word tho
Ps haven't checked this is backed up by data, just going off what i recall from 2019.
Pps why no neale, danger, mitchell, fyfe...
Ps haven't checked this is backed up by data, just going off what i recall from 2019.
Pps why no neale, danger, mitchell, fyfe...
Neale too expensive
Danger after his Bye
Mitchell wait and see
Fyfe , starting Kelly instead , so that would be just asking too much
Oliver stats suggest he will be better after his Bye
I guess you could have a case for starting any of the top 8-10 , with Grundy , Gawn & Whitfield I can fit 5 in , but looking at the rookie mids 4-0-7 might be the way to go
Danger after his Bye
Mitchell wait and see
Fyfe , starting Kelly instead , so that would be just asking too much
Oliver stats suggest he will be better after his Bye
I guess you could have a case for starting any of the top 8-10 , with Grundy , Gawn & Whitfield I can fit 5 in , but looking at the rookie mids 4-0-7 might be the way to go
Afraid not...
He looks to be clearly part of the their core midfield group through Marsh, whether that's by design or through missing personnel is another question. Got plenty of the ball but not quite the CP style of a Dunkley or Worpel. He's more outside than inside so less tackles as well.
He has every chance to improve on this output if the role sticks for this season, however, being MID only pretty much makes him irrelevant for SC purposes.
He looks to be clearly part of the their core midfield group through Marsh, whether that's by design or through missing personnel is another question. Got plenty of the ball but not quite the CP style of a Dunkley or Worpel. He's more outside than inside so less tackles as well.
He has every chance to improve on this output if the role sticks for this season, however, being MID only pretty much makes him irrelevant for SC purposes.
By the way, a BIG
for your summary of relevant Rookies who took part in the Marsh Series Community matches.
- Joined
- 11 Mar 2019
- Messages
- 566
- Likes
- 1,996
- AFL Club
- Essendon
- Joined
- 11 Mar 2019
- Messages
- 566
- Likes
- 1,996
- AFL Club
- Essendon
Anyone else go Oliver > Cogs after the weekend?
I know we shouldn't go off preseason as a clear guide, however nor should we ignore it either. The roles of Tomilson etc. worry me for Oliver.
Oliver to Cogs also frees up some handy cash to be spent to nab those more expensive defence rookies with JS.
I know we shouldn't go off preseason as a clear guide, however nor should we ignore it either. The roles of Tomilson etc. worry me for Oliver.
Oliver to Cogs also frees up some handy cash to be spent to nab those more expensive defence rookies with JS.