Player A v Player B (and General Player) Discussions
- Thread starter Impromptu
- Start date
- Status
Re: Player A v Player B
It would not only seem madness to do upgrades to get Zorko sitting on the bench, it would also seem impossible. There aren't 7 FWD's doing better than him! His vest-corrected average of 104 has him holding F6 status right now. As Porps showed on the weekend, he is a great back up on the bench. I'd upgrade elsewhere if it meant Zorko to the bench.
What is your team name, Zim^zuM?
It would not only seem madness to do upgrades to get Zorko sitting on the bench, it would also seem impossible. There aren't 7 FWD's doing better than him! His vest-corrected average of 104 has him holding F6 status right now. As Porps showed on the weekend, he is a great back up on the bench. I'd upgrade elsewhere if it meant Zorko to the bench.
What is your team name, Zim^zuM?
Re: Player A v Player B
With 4 trades left I would hold fire a few weeks. Unless your fighting to get into the 8 of your league (or stay in it) or you are a chance of 50k.
If you did trade and were left with 3 trades. Then I suggest the 3rd option. Except I would upgrade Porps. He doesn't average much and he isn't DPP. Upgrading to a premo DPP like Dangerfield would be best. Then if your injuries hold out in R22 do a downgrade for cash e.g. zorko. And for GF week trade in 2 guns to seal the deal.
With 4 trades left I would hold fire a few weeks. Unless your fighting to get into the 8 of your league (or stay in it) or you are a chance of 50k.
If you did trade and were left with 3 trades. Then I suggest the 3rd option. Except I would upgrade Porps. He doesn't average much and he isn't DPP. Upgrading to a premo DPP like Dangerfield would be best. Then if your injuries hold out in R22 do a downgrade for cash e.g. zorko. And for GF week trade in 2 guns to seal the deal.
- Joined
- 21 May 2012
- Messages
- 22,330
- Likes
- 31,231
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
Re: General Discussions
Is Brian Lake a definate keeper in a Defence that looks like:
Deledio, Goddard, M. Johnson, Enright, Suckling, Carrazzo (trading in this week), Lake (S. Shaw, Spurr)
By the way I will have 3 trades and a bit of coin left when I am looking to do the trade, possibly round 16/17.
Is Brian Lake a definate keeper in a Defence that looks like:
Deledio, Goddard, M. Johnson, Enright, Suckling, Carrazzo (trading in this week), Lake (S. Shaw, Spurr)
By the way I will have 3 trades and a bit of coin left when I am looking to do the trade, possibly round 16/17.
- Joined
- 21 May 2012
- Messages
- 22,330
- Likes
- 31,231
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
Hey Guys,
Needing two or three upgrades to have a team full of players that I will take to the end. I currently have 6 trades and $65,400 in funds. I am wanting to bring in Carrazzo and Dangerfield and ready to get rid of Giles and McDonald who are dropping off. Dangerfield has a breakeven of 138 whilst Carrazzo only 41. Most likely Dangerfield will drop a little more in price this week and Carrazzo is bound to go up. I am leaning towards bringing in Carrazzo this week and waiting on Dangerfield but also doing a downgrade for extra funds to get to get him the following week.
Trades:
McDonald out for Carrazzo (Swaping Goddard to midfield bench for a couple of weeks and then doing a downgrade to move him back. This will create more funds for one or two more defence or forward upgrades and trades complete.)
Giles out for Cheap forward (By swaping Roughead into ruck. Currently looking for any decent forwards that are cheap but my decision will be made after teams.)
Then can bring in Dangerfield the following week.
Please fell free to comment.
Needing two or three upgrades to have a team full of players that I will take to the end. I currently have 6 trades and $65,400 in funds. I am wanting to bring in Carrazzo and Dangerfield and ready to get rid of Giles and McDonald who are dropping off. Dangerfield has a breakeven of 138 whilst Carrazzo only 41. Most likely Dangerfield will drop a little more in price this week and Carrazzo is bound to go up. I am leaning towards bringing in Carrazzo this week and waiting on Dangerfield but also doing a downgrade for extra funds to get to get him the following week.
Trades:
McDonald out for Carrazzo (Swaping Goddard to midfield bench for a couple of weeks and then doing a downgrade to move him back. This will create more funds for one or two more defence or forward upgrades and trades complete.)
Giles out for Cheap forward (By swaping Roughead into ruck. Currently looking for any decent forwards that are cheap but my decision will be made after teams.)
Then can bring in Dangerfield the following week.
Please fell free to comment.
- Joined
- 4 Apr 2012
- Messages
- 672
- Likes
- 97
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
I was thinking about going Shiel -> Sylvia, since Shiel will miss the next four weeks with an injury. This will open up DPP between mid and forward giving me some flexibility (for bench cover. Other mid bench is S.Gibson). However the only problem is, after I make this trade I will have 2 trades left to run out the year. Do you think I should make this trade and hope I get lucky or no because its too risky?
Def: deledio goddard suckling marty clarke lake drummond morris mohr ellis
Mid: pendles thompson watson selwood ablett priddas horsley gibson
Ruc: ryder mumford redden stephenson
Fwd: dangerfield franklin walker cloke martin zorko smedts deven smith hall
got 317k in bank should i trade walker got 5 trades remaing want to upgrade mohr to heppell or newman and trade hall to goodes or lewis but dont know whether to keep walker could get a donut if buddy doesnt play
Mid: pendles thompson watson selwood ablett priddas horsley gibson
Ruc: ryder mumford redden stephenson
Fwd: dangerfield franklin walker cloke martin zorko smedts deven smith hall
got 317k in bank should i trade walker got 5 trades remaing want to upgrade mohr to heppell or newman and trade hall to goodes or lewis but dont know whether to keep walker could get a donut if buddy doesnt play
It would seem a bit of a "luxury" trade to me. If Croz was playing this week, and you avoided the FWD donut, would you get Sylvia?
If the answer is "no", then you are trading in Sylvia to cover a 40-60 point donut.
With your DEF having: Broughton, Lake, Ellis, S Shaw and Darley, long term you might be better upgrading there. Sylvia will give you flexibility, but will probably spend most weeks on the bench for you. A DEF upgrade will play every week (hopefully)
Good luck
If the answer is "no", then you are trading in Sylvia to cover a 40-60 point donut.
With your DEF having: Broughton, Lake, Ellis, S Shaw and Darley, long term you might be better upgrading there. Sylvia will give you flexibility, but will probably spend most weeks on the bench for you. A DEF upgrade will play every week (hopefully)
Good luck
- Joined
- 9 Apr 2012
- Messages
- 56
- Likes
- 0
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
haha fair call, i reckon i could use a bit of psychiatric counseling after some of the events that have unfolded this year
i've actually reversed my trade. Just can't decide between them, I like Thompson, but Ablett is Ablett! So I might hold off for a week and then see how things are next week. I will have a donut this week, but I should be right to win my league games, which is my primary goal.
i've actually reversed my trade. Just can't decide between them, I like Thompson, but Ablett is Ablett! So I might hold off for a week and then see how things are next week. I will have a donut this week, but I should be right to win my league games, which is my primary goal.
- Status