Strategy Round 4: Trades

[Goodie's Guns]

Sorry if it's been asked, but anyone have Nobles BE? Cheers in advance..

39

 

[Ironhawk]

Sorry if it's been asked, but anyone have Nobles BE? Cheers in advance..

Noble 39
Doedee 11

 

[BomberArmy]

Cheers guys, might just be 'cullable' this week.. especially as an upgrade.. kicking myself for not pulling the trigger and grabbing B.Smith, he's looking like a FWD keeper..

 

[Zim^zuM]

Trades for me lookin at...

Noble/Pickett to Williamson + Wingard/Simpkin (cant afford better)

OR I can go more mid price madness with

Pickett/Sturt to Ridley/Williamson

OR

Picket/Sturt to Butler/Williamson

Not excited by any haha but dont Want to have my change sitting there a second week in a row after the crap I copped last week. Almost deleted my team.

 

[Herbie66]

Depending on final teams tomorrow night have now decided on a 50/50 fomo

Jacobs - > Petracca via D Cameron
Williams - > Hamill (hopefully can play enough to generate some $$$)

Bennell & Pickett could be a problem trying to generate $$$

 

[Mudflap]

looking to bring in a forward. Have narrowed it down to 3 players.

Gresham
Ziebell
Ceglar

Any views on which of these can end up a top 6 forward for the year?

 

[Lgndhen23]

looking to bring in a forward. Have narrowed it down to 3 players.

Gresham
Ziebell
Ceglar

Any views on which of these can end up a top 6 forward for the year?

ruckmen seem to be able to score quite highly this season, or any season for that matter

definately ceglar for me

 

[TigerTime]

The Naismith news sucks for the big fella, but makes my trade thoughts clearer.
Will abort my plan to trade out Grundy and instead trade out Long and either C Taylor or Pickett. In will come Simpkin and one of Philp or Mahony (if named).
Anyone have any thoughts regarding Philp's job security?

 

[bloke]

What are those who have Sturt and AREN'T trading him thinking of doing? Just holding him as a donut, or holding hope that in 5-6 weeks he can come back and make money?

 

[Kidult]

What are those who have Sturt and AREN'T trading him thinking of doing? Just holding him as a donut, or holding hope that in 5-6 weeks he can come back and make money?

Holding for 1 week to go to either West,Hill or Serong.

 

[Zoku Pops]

Simpkin this week or wait, play a rookie and get Bont next week?

 

[NT.Thunder]

What's the Stanley injury for Geelong?
Fort???? Up against Gawn but still should field more points then most other rookie/mid fwd options

 

[jel]

What are those who have Sturt and AREN'T trading him thinking of doing? Just holding him as a donut, or holding hope that in 5-6 weeks he can come back and make money?

Yep, holding as a donut/loophole for now.
May trade in the future if required, but I've got 7 up FWD with some swing options, so he's low on the todo list.
May even stick around long enough that he comes back, but I wont be counting on it.

 

[BomberArmy]

Did Pickett to Rivers.. might backfire, but think Rivers looks solid whereas Pickett might have to earn his spot back over at least a couple of weeks..

 

[bloke]

Anyone have Noah Andersen's BE?

 

[blue dreamer]

Anyone have Noah Andersen's BE?

From SC Gold, 11

 

[Blaze]

I just don't think I can do my Grundy/Sturt to Pittonet/Petracca trade....I will likely chicken out
I am also struggling with the J Kelly/Doedee to Simpkin/Petracca trade....this is lower risk as Jelly won't hurt me like Grundy but I don't feel I am improving my team enough... It does get another premium on field so I haven't ruled this out. Jelly being a late out which actually make me happy as then I would just do this trade in a heartbeat
At the moment I am thinking of moving on Doedee/Noble to Petracca (via Brander)/Hamill. Essentially this means Petracca/Rivers on field compared to Doedee/Noble. Jumping off Doedee with a break even of 11 seems counter productive but Petracca also won't be 470k next week and I feel like I get a better on field hit going to 14 premiums a week earlier and I don't have the $$ to do it any other way.

Anyway thanks for my therapy session I will go and change my mind again now!

 

[TigerTime]

I just don't think I can do my Grundy/Sturt to Pittonet/Petracca trade....I will likely chicken out
I am also struggling with the J Kelly/Doedee to Simpkin/Petracca trade....this is lower risk as Jelly won't hurt me like Grundy but I don't feel I am improving my team enough... It does get another premium on field so I haven't ruled this out. Jelly being a late out which actually make me happy as then I would just do this trade in a heartbeat
At the moment I am thinking of moving on Doedee/Noble to Petracca (via Brander)/Hamill. Essentially this means Petracca/Rivers on field compared to Doedee/Noble. Jumping off Doedee with a break even of 11 seems counter productive but Petracca also won't be 470k next week and I feel like I get a better on field hit going to 14 premiums a week earlier and I don't have the $$ to do it any other way.

Anyway thanks for my therapy session I will go and change my mind again now!

It's a tough week to make trade choices. I've similarly come up with 4 or 5 ideas and not sure which way to roll.
Petracca looks a must have to me so if you are confident that Hamill will keep getting games I like your Doedee/Noble to Trac/Hamill option.
The decision might be made for you (and me) if Grundy or Jelly are a late out tonight though.

 

[randomcliche]

Any tips on how to enlarge it? I've dragged it onto a spreadsheet but hard to read.

1. Simpkin: Appears to be second behind Cunnington for midfield priority.
2. Smith: 3rd in the pecking order and now 2nd with Dunkley out.
3. Greenwood: Gold Coast rotating mids a lot but he is a major part of the rotations.
4. Wingard: Bit part player of the midfield and relying on goals.
5. Ebert: Seems to be relying on some goals aswell. Might be benefiting from 3 easy wins.

Sorry if it's too late.

save a .JPG

 

[Blaze]

It's a tough week to make trade choices. I've similarly come up with 4 or 5 ideas and not sure which way to roll.
Petracca looks a must have to me so if you are confident that Hamill will keep getting games I like your Doedee/Noble to Trac/Hamill option.
The decision might be made for you (and me) if Grundy or Jelly are a late out tonight though.

yes not sure on Hamill's scoring but I think there is a spike game in him (if the crows can actually get the ball as he likely doesn't get it himself). In terms of JS he was looking good all pre-season so I will back the new crows regime to give a run of games to one of the only quick silky young talented wing/hbf types we have at the crows - particularly while milera and atkins are injured for a while.