Discussion 2022 Round 9: Teams & In Game Discussion

Joined
23 Mar 2014
Messages
6,389
Likes
17,516
AFL Club
Hawthorn
Ok yes I'm having a whine, but that was a bizarre decision to say the least against Gov. Trac moved into the protected zone after the mark, probably should have been 50, umpire then calls play on for no reason, gov handbalks out deliberately (which is fair enough but shouldn't have gotten to that stage) then the ump tells gov to get out of the protected zone even tho he's on the mark so the Eagles have no one on the mark

I'll take the points as traccs in my side. Feel free to provide a nuetral viewpoint but still didn't understand any of those calls o_O
Your correct…should have been 50 against Trac…..surely you are allowed to step forward one step like Gov did?
And then the second error was the mark set…10 metres in from the boundary….
if it’s a deliberate OOB call the mark should be set on the boundary not ten metres inside….
 
Joined
18 Feb 2019
Messages
1,370
Likes
5,768
AFL Club
Carlton
Ok yes I'm having a whine, but that was a bizarre decision to say the least against Gov. Trac moved into the protected zone after the mark, probably should have been 50, umpire then calls play on for no reason, gov handbalks out deliberately (which is fair enough but shouldn't have gotten to that stage) then the ump tells gov to get out of the protected zone even tho he's on the mark so the Eagles have no one on the mark

I'll take the points as traccs in my side. Feel free to provide a nuetral viewpoint but still didn't understand any of those calls o_O
Yes it was a wrong call (and will take the points too), just like many other stupid wrong calls this year. Umpiring and AFL directives have made the game hard to watch.

Except if you follow Carlton and all good😎👍
 
Joined
10 Feb 2014
Messages
11,375
Likes
21,228
AFL Club
Essendon
Hail Mary Captain Jackson going well

(except I didn't switch over in time and Oliver is my C)

Would have been a nice few extra points, but it could well have ended badly too. I won't win that H2H after Whitfeild vs Sicily. That was the difference.

Him and Oliver look like they'll end up on around the same.

Hopefully the beat Macrae's 117
 
Top