2023: SC Planning Thread

Goodie's Guns

Leadership Group
Joined
21 May 2012
Messages
22,312
Likes
31,158
AFL Club
Hawthorn
Macrae spent a hell of alot of their match sim on a flank while they ran McLean and Daniel through the middle, think hes still going to have periods of games where hes out of their starting mids.
Could be true, will need to monitor the pre-season games. Apparently spent an entire quarter up in the forwards.
They also played the game with no rucks, so who knows how much you can read into what took place...
 
Joined
24 Feb 2020
Messages
4,897
Likes
13,335
AFL Club
Collingwood
Macrae spent a hell of alot of their match sim on a flank while they ran McLean and Daniel through the middle, think hes still going to have periods of games where hes out of their starting mids.
Yes thats my concern with Macrae, with Hunter gone. Too many varibles. The DOGS are stacked with depth. My opinion, Bont is a safer bet.
 
Joined
8 Jan 2020
Messages
6,264
Likes
26,157
AFL Club
Geelong
Yes thats my concern with Macrae, with Hunter gone. Too many varibles. The DOGS are stacked with depth. My opinion, Bont is a safer bet.
Hunter gone doesnt really concern me as such, he only played half the year anyway and they've recruited a genuine mature aged replacement, running other names through the midfield is the main concern, Macrae has never shown any actual ability to play anywhere else, significant time forward could be some serious pain while Bont can do it and still dominate, just alot less things to go wrong for mine.
 
Joined
6 Mar 2013
Messages
10,190
Likes
31,121
AFL Club
Carlton
He was hopeless on the wing... Bevo playing him there and him actually being any good at it are two very different things.
I wouldnt say he was hopeless, remember his second season he was a winger and averaged over 100. Lacks the leg speed for it now as the game is changing to a more fast ball movement style across the board.
 
Joined
27 Feb 2014
Messages
598
Likes
2,061
AFL Club
Essendon
Tooserious is back, so I thought i'd look at the year to date (YTD) prices rises from last year at Round 10.

Now, there is the obvious plays that everyone had in Brodie, Nic Martin, McCartin, Daicos.

What stands out to me is the $200 k - $300 k range, like Curnow, Newcombe, Richards, Frampton, Stengle, Chapman.
Now good luck if you even selected 2 of them but shows that it can be done.... it's just very very difficult.

SC2022 YTD R10.PNG
 
Joined
8 Jan 2020
Messages
6,264
Likes
26,157
AFL Club
Geelong
I wouldnt say he was hopeless, remember his second season he was a winger and averaged over 100. Lacks the leg speed for it now as the game is changing to a more fast ball movement style across the board.
Its not even his pace as such he just doesnt have any accountability at all and when the direct opponent is quick and dangerous he really got exposed the other way, whether its just laziness or something that can be worked on can probably be debated but I just dont think you put an inside mid that isnt really a two way player on the wing and expect it to work.
 
Joined
6 Mar 2013
Messages
10,190
Likes
31,121
AFL Club
Carlton
Its not even his pace as such he just doesnt have any accountability at all and when the direct opponent is quick and dangerous he really got exposed the other way, whether its just laziness or something that can be worked on can probably be debated but I just dont think you put a slow mid that isnt really a two way player on the wing and expect it to work.
His coach has though, that's the issue.
 
Joined
9 Feb 2015
Messages
9,440
Likes
57,908
AFL Club
West Coast
https://www.perthnow.com.au/sport/w...ing-tightness-in-pre-season-setback-c-9804875

A year on from the horror fortnight of injuries that ruined their 2022, West Coast’s tall forward stocks are teetering.

Spearheads Jack Darling (ankle), Jack Williams (ruptured spleen) and Oscar Allen (hamstring tightness) sat out Friday night’s intraclub with injuries, just four weeks out from round one.

While Darling and Allen are likely to be fit for the season opener against North Melbourne at Marvel Stadium on March 18, their preparation has been compromised by injuries.

Allen’s injury is believed to only be minor, but all eyes will be on the 23-year-old when the Eagles train on Monday morning ahead of a practice match against Port Adelaide at Mineral Resources Park on Friday.

But it was about this time last year when a sore foot sidelined Allen before he was eventually ruled out for the season.

WEST COAST’S “BEST TEAM” LINE-UP IN FRIDAY’S INTRACLUB
F: N Long B Williams J Waterman

HF: J Cripps L Ryan S Petrevski-Seton

C: C Chesser J Culley J Hunt

HB: L Duggan T Barrass E Yeo

B: S Hurn J McGovern A Witherden

RUCK: N Naitanui T Kelly R Ginbey

I/C: J Jones A Gaff T Cole X O’Neill

ABSENT: L Shuey D Sheed O Allen J Williams J Darling R Bazzo Z Trew J Petruccelle L Edwards
 
Joined
5 Jan 2019
Messages
490
Likes
1,132
AFL Club
Melbourne
Sounds like it'd be fun and a great idea but then I remember I can barely crack the Top 5k with the uncomplicated version of the game.[/QU
Been looking at this and currently am rolling with both as I simply can't decide between the two.

Both of their CBA's dropped last season compared to prior years and logic suggests with Dunkley gone that they will both increase their CBA loads but will be a close watch how it is split during the practice game (of course they will only have one for us to have a look at).

Here are some stats from the last three years to highlight the importance of CBAs to their scoring;

View attachment 52827

View attachment 52828

Bont showed more versatility in being able to score with the role last year so think he comes with less risk but think both if it all plays out as we suspect with Dunkley may have some upside.
What is count ?
 
Joined
12 Jan 2014
Messages
3,763
Likes
11,761
AFL Club
West Coast
Steele is a nice price and one of the few who could push 120+ for the season. Locked for my team.
I agree. That is why I picked him. What I do not like is the lack of positive comment on him at training (other than something generic like "he looks okay") and the comments like "he looks proppy" "has the hat on" and "has lost weight, not sure if it is a health issue". At his price any chance of a problem and he is out. Hence I want him to turn it on in the pre season game.
 
Joined
8 Jan 2020
Messages
6,264
Likes
26,157
AFL Club
Geelong
I agree. That is why I picked him. What I do not like is the lack of positive comment on him at training (other than something generic like "he looks okay") and the comments like "he looks proppy" "has the hat on" and "has lost weight, not sure if it is a health issue". At his price any chance of a problem and he is out. Hence I want him to turn it on in the pre season game.
Hes always been a guy that doesnt particularly give a about the pre season games, dont be surprised if he coasts through in second gear, only had 20 touches in the game last year from 82% TOG.
 
Top