Discussion 2023: Rate My Team

[BigRuss]

What structure is everyone looking at in terms of keepers out of interest? Keepers not to include the likes of Bruhn/Setters/Hopper/Ziebell/Fyfe etc - $450k and up. I'm not seeing much from the defender rookies and can see some pain down back with limited bail out options being available if some are dropped/injured. Might be being a little cautious but what's people gut feel a couple of days out?

I keep flip-flopping between (D/M/R/F)

3/3/2/4 and 2/4/2/4

2/4/2/4 for me, though as you said the def rookies will dictate it.

3/3/2/4 feels like a lot of high priced upgrades to me, perhaps too many.

 

[Professor]

2/5/2/4

 

[inwhiterooms]

2/5/2/4

13 premium setup is intriguing, guessing you've got 2 x 500k defenders? I was playing around with that structure over the weekend and didn't mind it.

2/4/2/4 for me.

 

[Professor]

13 premium setup is intriguing, guessing you've got 2 x 500k defenders? I was playing around with that structure over the weekend and didn't mind it.

2/4/2/4 for me.

As per NT THUNDER I've included premiums >450k.

Doc, Dawson
Laird, Bont, Cripps, Green, Gulden
Gawn, Marshall
Dunkley, Rozee, Taranto and Jackson

 

[inwhiterooms]

As per NT THUNDER I've included premiums >450k.

Doc, Dawson
Laird, Bont, Cripps, Green, Gulden
Gawn, Marshall
Dunkley, Rozee, Taranto and Jackson

Spicy.

 

[Connoisseur]

What structure is everyone looking at in terms of keepers out of interest? Keepers not to include the likes of Bruhn/Setters/Hopper/Ziebell/Fyfe etc - $450k and up. I'm not seeing much from the defender rookies and can see some pain down back with limited bail out options being available if some are dropped/injured. Might be being a little cautious but what's people gut feel a couple of days out?

I keep flip-flopping between (D/M/R/F)

3/3/2/4 and 2/4/2/4

2/5/2/1

 

[donnybuang]

As per NT THUNDER I've included premiums >450k.

Doc, Dawson
Laird, Bont, Cripps, Green, Gulden
Gawn, Marshall
Dunkley, Rozee, Taranto and Jackson

If Green, Gulden and Jackson all become premos, you'll be very well placed for the overall.


I'm at 2/4/2/4

 

[donnybuang]

2/5/2/1

That seems like a squad with all genuine premos.

 

[Russty_]

What structure is everyone looking at in terms of keepers out of interest? Keepers not to include the likes of Bruhn/Setters/Hopper/Ziebell/Fyfe etc - $450k and up. I'm not seeing much from the defender rookies and can see some pain down back with limited bail out options being available if some are dropped/injured. Might be being a little cautious but what's people gut feel a couple of days out?

I keep flip-flopping between (D/M/R/F)

3/3/2/4 and 2/4/2/4

2-4-2-3

 

[Professor]

If Green, Gulden and Jackson all become premos, you'll be very well placed for the overall.


I'm at 2/4/2/4

Not even contemplating that atm, just trying to get the right balance, hopefully the rookies can stand up.

 

[neeld]

3-4-2-3

 

[jaca]

2/4/2/3 for me..

 

[Herbie66]

What structure is everyone looking at in terms of keepers out of interest? Keepers not to include the likes of Bruhn/Setters/Hopper/Ziebell/Fyfe etc - $450k and up. I'm not seeing much from the defender rookies and can see some pain down back with limited bail out options being available if some are dropped/injured. Might be being a little cautious but what's people gut feel a couple of days out?

I keep flip-flopping between (D/M/R/F)

3/3/2/4 and 2/4/2/4

Nearly time to lock in a structure , rookies everywhere in D & F might not need any midpricers at all 🤔

Aiming for 2-4 (Green M4)-2-3

+ Fyfe , Hopper , Yeo

8 onfield rookies might be too many to start though (not sure)

 

[froffershanners]

1/4/2/5 here but the more I read the less likely the defender rookies are.

Friday will be a fun day of tinkering.

 

[Shaunpro1]

2/3/2/4, happy to have one less premium if it means mid pricers over dodgy rookies on field.

 

[Connoisseur]

That seems like a squad with all genuine premos.

Grundy and Marshall are currently the only players between the E Yeo to J Kelly price range. 15/30 players between the W Phillips to E Yeo price range with three on the bench, with C McKenna as the cheapest player on the field. Once more rookies are announced hopefully I can drop a bit back and bring in an 11th “premium”.

 

[blue dreamer]

Finally deleted my mid price madness team and came up with this team in about 10 minutes.

Madden for looping.

Surprised myself with Saad and Hollands and don't know how the forwards became so skinny. about to go get ready for work and looking forward to some interesting comments at break time tonight.

Docherty, Saad. Yeo, Jones, Goater, Ginbey, (McKenna, Gilbee)

Laird, Neale, Bont, Cripps, Taranto, Hopper, Ashcroft, Phillips, (Hollands, Constable, Chesser)

Darcy, Marshall, (Madden)

Dunkley, Gulden, Fyfe, Allen, Sheezel, Phillipou, (Greene, Davey)

$ 22,100 itb

 

[Shannon]

Finally deleted my mid price madness team and came up with this team in about 10 minutes.

Madden for looping.

Surprised myself with Saad and Hollands and don't know how the forwards became so skinny. about to go get ready for work and looking forward to some interesting comments at break time tonight.

Docherty, Saad. Yeo, Jones, Goater, Ginbey, (McKenna, Gilbee)

Laird, Neale, Bont, Cripps, Taranto, Hopper, Ashcroft, Phillips, (Hollands, Constable, Chesser)

Darcy, Marshall, (Madden)

Dunkley, Gulden, Fyfe, Allen, Sheezel, Phillipou, (Greene, Davey)

$ 22,100 itb

Put Taranto in your fwd line over Allen, Mackenzie or Callaghan in his place in the midfield would be my suggestion

 

[randomcliche]

Hey lads, first post, intending to be a more prominent poster on here. Love my team, only issue is, I want Bruhn in for Flanders / maybe even Cogs while flicking Flanders to Sheezel.
10k ITB, no idea how to find the $. Any ideas? Pretty firm on every selection, but feel free to give it a critique, and see if you can find a way to get Bruhn in for Flanders. Cheers

This is the strongest team in a raw premo, MP count I’ve seen. You’ll tinker the bench and be extraordinarily well set if the expansive range of MPs come off. My team is Premo mid heavy M5, so looks very different, but by no means as clever as this! Great quality in the individual premo choices. Cheers

 

[Goodie's Guns]

Finally deleted my mid price madness team and came up with this team in about 10 minutes.

Madden for looping.

Surprised myself with Saad and Hollands and don't know how the forwards became so skinny. about to go get ready for work and looking forward to some interesting comments at break time tonight.

Docherty, Saad. Yeo, Jones, Goater, Ginbey, (McKenna, Gilbee)

Laird, Neale, Bont, Cripps, Taranto, Hopper, Ashcroft, Phillips, (Hollands, Constable, Chesser)

Darcy, Marshall, (Madden)

Dunkley, Gulden, Fyfe, Allen, Sheezel, Phillipou, (Greene, Davey)

$ 22,100 itb

Put Taranto in your fwd line over Allen, Mackenzie or Callaghan in his place in the midfield would be my suggestion

Seconded, my exact initial thoughts.

May need to go Saad down to a $500k DEF to be able to fix Gilbee to a playing DEF as well. Or Fyfe to Flanders if you were set on Saad and not so certain on the $500K DEF options.