Strategy 2023: Player X v Player Y

[zac-ster]

Touk replacement
Butters Vs Sheeze (Def/Fwd cover Vs DCam (Ruck cover) Vs Parish Vs Whitfield

 

[Ironhawk]

Butters vs Macrae

Macrae

Touk replacement
Butters Vs Sheeze (Def/Fwd cover Vs DCam (Ruck cover) Vs Parish Vs Whitfield

Parish

 

[BarginHunter]

Newman vs Hinge vs TBD

 

[Ironhawk]

Newman vs Hinge vs TBD

Prefer Newman to Hinge.

Assume TBD is allowing the suggestion of alternatives?

 

[jb2626]

Serong vs Jackson vs Newman?

 

[Ironhawk]

Serong vs Jackson vs Newman?

Probably Serong, just ahead of Jackson. TBC based on what happens with Williams in his appeal.

 

[froffershanners]

Newman vs Short

 

[Ironhawk]

Newman vs Short

Prefer Newman, but could go either way here.

 

[wolfbunny]

Serong v Butters

 

[Ironhawk]

Serong v Butters

Butters. No basis, gut feeling he scores higher.

 

[wolfbunny]

Butters. No basis, gut feeling he scores higher.

Thanks @Ironhawk

 

[wolfbunny]

Serong to allow bench cover in defence OR Jackson (no defensive cover)
Probably silly but really want Jackson upside

Serong, given this year's injuries and still 3 weeks to go, cover could come in handy! And his scoring has been solid all year.

 

[BarginHunter]

Witherden vs Duncan vs Short vs Hinge/Lloyd

Or

Bolton vs Dusty vs Dale

Tbh i kinda like the look of Dale but Bolton and Witherden have been good recently

The others are just there incase im overlooking them or you reckon they are better

 

[Ironhawk]

Witherden vs Duncan vs Short vs Hinge/Lloyd

Or

Bolton vs Dusty vs Dale

Tbh i kinda like the look of Dale but Bolton and Witherden have been good recently

The others are just there incase im overlooking them or you reckon they are better

Go with your gut. Remember there's only two games left, so you need to consider opponents a lot more so than recent form at this time of year.

First combo: Ignoring the mid eligibility, assuming you want them as a DEF only. Witherden has been one of the Eagles best lately, except against North. Lloyd and Hinge have been fairly consistent around 100 in recent weeks. Short and Duncan don't stand out as the best pick to me. Agree on Witherden, just ahead of Lloyd.

Second combo: Comparing two MF v a D. Depends who this will be replacing on field. You know what you'll get with Dale, Bolton is more up and down, don't think Dusty scores as well with little to play for. I would go for Bolton based on match ups, but Dale is the safer pick.

 

[BarginHunter]

Go with your gut. Remember there's only two games left, so you need to consider opponents a lot more so than recent form at this time of year.

First combo: Ignoring the mid eligibility, assuming you want them as a DEF only. Witherden has been one of the Eagles best lately, except against North. Lloyd and Hinge have been fairly consistent around 100 in recent weeks. Short and Duncan don't stand out as the best pick to me. Agree on Witherden, just ahead of Lloyd.

Second combo: Comparing two MF v a D. Depends who this will be replacing on field. You know what you'll get with Dale, Bolton is more up and down, don't think Dusty scores as well with little to play for. I would go for Bolton based on match ups, but Dale is the safer pick.

Excellent review as always Ironhawk 👏

Id say yeah Dale and Witherden are both ahead of the rest, just ik Witherden hasnt had the best injury record and cant afford for him to go down early

Lloyd and Macrae can cancel out a bunch of PODs BUT Witherden and Dale will give me my own POD

Basically as im upgrading Dcam i want someone who can surely get closer to their projected then he has of late

 

[Ironhawk]

Excellent review as always Ironhawk 👏

Id say yeah Dale and Witherden are both ahead of the rest, just ik Witherden hasnt had the best injury record and cant afford for him to go down early

Lloyd and Macrae can cancel out a bunch of PODs BUT Witherden and Dale will give me my own POD

Basically as im upgrading Dcam i want someone who can surely get closer to their projected then he has of late

Well, I was definitely wrong on Dusty. Bolton looking like a good pick still though from that combo. Short pretty average as I expected in the other combo.

 

[BarginHunter]

Well, I was definitely wrong on Dusty. Bolton looking like a good pick still though from that combo. Short pretty average as I expected in the other combo.

Its all good
I was thinking along the same as u anyways

 

[zac-ster]

DOC replacement

Young Vs Sheez Vs Short?

 

[Chumpion]

Which 2 do I play in field?

Cameron (59) vs Johnson vs Hewett (WCE one) vs Sturt

 

[wolfbunny]

Which 2 do I play in field?

Cameron (59) vs Johnson vs Hewett (WCE one) vs Sturt

Take Cameron's score over Sturt I think, Walters back in equals 2 small forwards crumbing, less crumbs to go around.
I have Johnson, but he can throw up a stinker and get subbed out (though has a higher ceiling currently), don't think Hewett will.
So Cameron and Hewett.