Opinion 2024 AFL SuperCoach Planning Thread

Joined
20 Mar 2016
Messages
1,397
Likes
4,836
Merrett is always gettable when upgrade season is in session, and he doesn't have the favourable bye that both Port and Fremantle have fixtured.
It’s still a favourable bye you can use to slingshot Merrett to a Gulden, Dunkley type though.

I suppose it’s just funny seeing more love for LDU who (unlike Merrett) hasn’t been able to string together a full season of premium midfield scoring yet.

Also, being “gettable at some point in season” is probably one of the better “worst flaws” I’ve seen for someone in the elite premium midfield group this year I must admit. Most of the other elite mids have either role, injury, age or early bye issues 👍
 
Last edited:

Darkie

Leadership Group
Joined
12 Apr 2014
Messages
25,415
Likes
65,520
AFL Club
Collingwood
The knock on Ryan was he wasn't kicking the ball more than 40m. Whether he's overcoming an injury I can't recall.

edit

View: https://twitter.com/Taezer87/status/1758314587496251530
I am pretty sure it was an ankle.

Kicks over 40 metres also have a lower threshold for being deemed effective, if I recall correctly (I think even a long kick to a contest suffices), so if he was struggling to kick long, that would be a decent headwind.

I’m also fairly sure I heard that he was kicking it >40 more recently though.
 
Joined
12 Jan 2014
Messages
3,765
Likes
11,768
AFL Club
West Coast
Why no chatter about Ryan?

Good bye and highest scoring defender last year?

On track for another big score tonight? Taking kick ins?

Am I missing something?
I think one of the reasons Ryan doesn’t have higher support is that he burned people for a few seasons in the past. What happened in the past should not determine what you do in a new year when we should reset but as humans that is exactly what we do. We let it influence us.

His first four years were upward growth resulting in a 107 ave in 2020. People jumped on in 2021 thinking he is on his way to premo status but he disappointed somewhat with 99. One of those seasons where you cannot justify trading him out but it isn’t what you paid for. So in 2022 some people forgave him and thought he would bounce back and others saw a premo scorer at a discount price and they both jumped on. He rewarded them with 96. Thoughly annoying those that had backed him in to return to his 107 form and disappointing those that were on him for the first time expecting a value buy. In fact it was only his last six games that saved him that year. At the end of rd 17 his ave was 90 and included six scores of 75 or less and some owners may have ditched him by this time. But from rd 18 he went bonkers. Which probably sent people that had traded him out completely bonkers. His last six scores were 128, 128, 110, 146, 65, 100. He put up two tons in the finals as well.

Then come 2023 many of those previous owners decided not again. So imagine their frustration to see him go 109 without one game below 83. Seven of his first eight games produced tons and showed his capacity for a high ceiling. Where was that for the past two years when I had you?

And people who had never owned him may have thought the 107 was a bit of a spike given the following years and may have looked elsewhere in 2023.

Hence I think he may have put off a lot of coaches in the past and that combined with the reports of his recent kicking “problem” could be reflected in his ownership this year.
 
Joined
13 Jun 2022
Messages
5,231
Likes
17,250
AFL Club
St Kilda
I think one of the reasons Ryan doesn’t have higher support is that he burned people for a few seasons in the past. What happened in the past should not determine what you do in a new year when we should reset but as humans that is exactly what we do. We let it influence us.

His first four years were upward growth resulting in a 107 ave in 2020. People jumped on in 2021 thinking he is on his way to premo status but he disappointed somewhat with 99. One of those seasons where you cannot justify trading him out but it isn’t what you paid for. So in 2022 some people forgave him and thought he would bounce back and others saw a premo scorer at a discount price and they both jumped on. He rewarded them with 96. Thoughly annoying those that had backed him in to return to his 107 form and disappointing those that were on him for the first time expecting a value buy. In fact it was only his last six games that saved him that year. At the end of rd 17 his ave was 90 and included six scores of 75 or less and some owners may have ditched him by this time. But from rd 18 he went bonkers. Which probably sent people that had traded him out completely bonkers. His last six scores were 128, 128, 110, 146, 65, 100. He put up two tons in the finals as well.

Then come 2023 many of those previous owners decided not again. So imagine their frustration to see him go 109 without one game below 83. Seven of his first eight games produced tons and showed his capacity for a high ceiling. Where was that for the past two years when I had you?

And people who had never owned him may have thought the 107 was a bit of a spike given the following years and may have looked elsewhere in 2023.

Hence I think he may have put off a lot of coaches in the past and that combined with the reports of his recent kicking “problem” could be reflected in his ownership this year.
Talk about people holding a grudge!, 109 last season is good enough for me.
 
Top