News Herald Sun SuperCoach Articles

Joined
9 Feb 2015
Messages
9,440
Likes
57,906
AFL Club
West Coast
SuperCoach AFL 2024: Injury news, teams whispers for round 23
Harry Sheezel is one of the most popular picks in SuperCoach – and he’s in doubt for prelim final week. And so are Tim English and Charlie Curnow. Get the latest here.

Al Paton

Follow

@al_superfooty


3 min read
August 13, 2024 - 11:10AM

North Melbourne and more than 110,000 SuperCoaches are sweating on the fitness of Harry Sheezel ahead of round 23.
The Kangaroos star, who is yet to miss a game since making his AFL debut in round 1, 2023, pulled up sore following the Roos’ loss to West Coast. He is set to be rested for most of the week before a decision is made on his fitness to face the Western Bulldogs on Sunday.

Sheezel, who is the third-most popular player in SuperCoach and the fifth-top scorer in the game in just his second season, appeared hampered by a leg issue for much of the second half against the Eagles.

Coach Alastair Clarkson said after the game: “He got a bit of an ankle, he got stomped on or something. He was a little bit sore in the second half … Hopefully it’s just a knock. We’ll get it assessed during the week and he’s good to go again.”

Fox Footy’s Drew Jones reported that scans on Monday revealed no serious injury, but a decision won’t be made on Sheezel’s availability until later in the week.


ENGLISH PATIENT IN DOUBT

Bulldogs ruckman Tim English is “borderline” to face the Kangaroos after picking up his own ankle injury.

Coach Luke Beveridge confirmed on AFL 360 on Monday night that the 2023 All-Australian ruckman was hurt in Sunday’s loss to Adelaide – in which he lost the hitouts to Reilly O’Brien 58-16.

“He hurt his ankle yesterday ... he had a scan and it’s come up with the fact that he’s got an injury there. So he’ll be touch and go this week,” Beveridge said.

Asked if it was a serious injury, Beveridge said: “Don’t think so. He’ll be boderline, I think, on selection this week.”

English features in more than 55,000 SuperCoach teams.

If he misses, the ruck duties will likely tall to 25-gamer Sam Darcy against Tristan Xerri, who is making a strong case to be this year’s All-Australian ruck – in his past three games he has had 75 disposals, 30 tackles and scored 151, 144 and 185 SuperCoach points.

CURNOW CURSE

Charlie Curnow’s season is in doubt with an ankle problem, but Carlton is yet to rule him out of Sunday’s clash against West Coast.

The star goalkicker had to be helped from the field after collapsing while trying to make a lead against Hawthorn on Sunday.

Curnow was in doubt to play against Hawthorn after rolling his ankle the week before, but coach Michael Voss dismissed any question the club took a risk in playing the full-forward.

He said after the game: “Unfortunately it’s just a niggle players get at this part of the year. It is one of those we are going to have to manage ... we’ll just take 24 hours and make sure we get the right assessment.”

Curnow, who is part of more than 34,000 SuperCoach teams, scored 178 and 186 in his two games against West Coast in 2023, kicking a combined 19 goals.

Carlton’s injury woes also include Adam Saad (hamstring) and Harry McKay (leg). The Blues are expected to release an updated injury list late on Tuesday.

GAWN POWERS HOME

Max Gawn may not be100 per cent fit, but the Demons captain is planning to finish the year strong, even if Melbourne can’t make the finals.

In his regular appearance on Triple M, Gawn rejected the idea he could be put in cotton wool to prepare for 2025.

“If I got injured I would rest, but ... there’s a lot of pride in the jumper and you can’t turn culture on and off,” he said.

“If we, let’s say, threw the towel in the next two, that is hard to get back over the pre-season and next year.”

Gawn, who scored 177 SuperCoach points last weekend, said there was still plenty to play for in the final two rounds against Gold Coast and Collingwood.

The clash against the Magpies has been scheduled for Friday night in round 24.

“Hopefully they are in finals contention and we can spoil it for them,” Gawn said.
 
Joined
9 Feb 2015
Messages
9,440
Likes
57,906
AFL Club
West Coast
SuperCoach AFL 2024: Trade replacements for injured stars in round 23 rated

Tim English. OUT. Charlie Curnow. OUT. Clayton Oliver. OUT. Their replacements will decide SuperCoach prelim finals. Our experts rate the best options for your team.

Al Paton and Patch

10 min read
August 15, 2024 - 11:50AM

After sailing through the first 16 rounds of the season almost without incident, injuries have hit SuperCoaches like a truck in the run home.
Tim English, Charlie Curnow and Clayton Oliver have all been ruled out for preliminary final week, and Harry Sheezel is under a major injury cloud.

For coaches with trades up their sleeve, now is the time to take advantage on rivals who went too hard, too early.

So, who are the best replacements for this week’s injured stars? Our experts rate the most traded in players this week – and scroll down for full round 23 match-up analysis.

1. TRISTAN XERRI $683,900 RUC
Al Paton: BUY. Normally wouldn’t advise spending over $680k on anyone but if you have the cash, spend up on the best scorer in SuperCoach.

Tim Michell: BUY. Best ruckman in SuperCoach this year and could be up against Sam Darcy this week. Xerri is a legitimate captaincy option for the next two weeks and incredibly is the most expensive player in SuperCoach after round 22. He needs to score about 110 to eclipse $700k. It was only seven weeks ago he scored 141 against the Bulldogs.

Patch: BUY. Best ruck in the game and will be lining up against Sam Darcy on the weekend. Lock him in and C him.

Chloe Williams: BUY. Buy. Just buy.

2. DYLAN MOORE $501,000 FWD
AP: BUY. Not sure why I didn’t consider him with my 40th trade, which I used last week on Izak Rankine. Moore is the No.5 forward this year and could destroy Richmond this weekend.

TM: BUY. The Hawks are going to play finals with games against North Melbourne and Richmond in the next two weeks looking like they could be a SuperCoach feast. I like his captain James Sicily as a trade in this week for his high ceiling but Moore is a great option too.

Patch: BUY. He’s good! I really like him. Has a super run home.

CW: BUY. If you can get there, do it. He has Richmond and North Melbourne to come, and the Hawks are flying. A three-round average of 95.3 with a huge ceiling.

3. MAX GAWN $597,900 RUC
AP: CONSIDER. I prefer Rowan Marshall around this price based on fixtures, but even a banged-up Gawn can do what few others can in SuperCoach.

TM: PASS. I’d assume this is people trading out Tim English with one trade left who can’t get to Xerri. Gawn was heroic against Port Adelaide and although he’s determined to play out the season he’s doing so on one leg. Based on match-ups I’d go Rowan Marshall instead.

Patch: BUY. I prefer Xerri but if Big X is too dear for you, then Max will bring you home.

CW: BUY. If you can’t afford Xerri, Gawn could guide you to a finals win off the back of a 177 as he will look to galvanise the under-fire Dees.

4. TOM POWELL $425,700 MID/FWD
AP: PASS. Past three games have been what we were hoping for earlier in the year, but I still don’t trust Clarko.

TM: PASS. Four weeks ago he scored 39. I know his role has been better in the last three rounds but anything close to that score from round 19 and you can kiss your hopes of SuperCoach league glory goodbye.

Patch: AVOID. Well, well, well... look who’s come crawling back. (Us, we’ve come crawling back). He’s been really good the past few weeks, but that’s been with George Wardlaw out. I’m not sold on how they score together.

CW: BUY. Can we go back there? For two weeks, yes. Even if Wardlaw comes back in, Sheezel could well be done for the year. Worth the risk to win your finals.



5. ARCHIE ROBERTS $117,300 DEF
AP: CONSIDER. If you have two trades (!) and a downgrade gets you up to Xerri, go for it. Defensive bench cover might be needed, too, if Harry Sheezel doesn’t get up.

TM: BUY. If Brad Scott ruins Saad El Hawli’s price for next year after ruining Roberts two weeks ago I’ll be angrier than Patch was when Mac Andrew kicked that goal after the siren.

Patch: BUY. Yeah sure, although he’ll be sub at some stage.

CW: PASS. He could be the sub, with a low score, or even if you need a doughnut … I’m sure you will come across one with this week’s carnage!

6. IZAK RANKINE $552,600 FWD
AP: BUY. Now have Moore ahead of him but Izak can still bust out some big scores. Looked a bit rusty last week after four games out.

TM: BUY. Doesn’t need many disposals to score big SuperCoach points. Looked certain to ton when he had three early goal assists against the Western Bulldogs before slowing. He’s a point of difference pick and made for big stages like this week’s Showdown.

Patch: BUY. I think he’s neat. Bring him in if you can afford him.

CW: CONSIDER. He didn’t have the greatest SuperCoach return last week, but it’s the Showdown.


7. MATTHEW KENNEDY $398,100 FWD/MID
AP: CONSIDER. Can score well if he gets midfield time but who knows who will play where for the Blues as Michael Voss tries to plug holes left, right and centre.

TM: PASS. What the? Where has this come from? I suspect with Harry McKay and Charlie Curnow ruled out that Kennedy is going to spend a fair bit of time forward against West Coast. Don’t go there unless you think he can kick 3-4 goals. Prefer James Peatling or Matteas Phillipou if you’re strapped for cash.

Patch: WHAT. A Kennedy being relevant in SuperCoach? What is this, 2016? I’ll defer to whatever Tim writes here, I got no clue.

CW: CONSIDER. I personally am a fan. He doesn’t have the best numbers this year, but his 119 last week proved what he can do with full midfield minutes. I would have said ‘buy’, but I’m almost certain he gets thrown forward among the Carlton carnage.

8. ROWAN MARSHALL $604,600 RUC
AP: BUY. Averaging 127.5 over his past four and has a fantastic match-up against the Cats this weekend.

TM: BUY. See above. I think he’s the best English trade option.

Patch: BUY. Yeah sure. He’s playing, which is more than you can say for Tim English.

CW: BUY. Another great English replacement. A three-round average of 129, with match-ups against Geelong – who give up a lot of points to ruckmen – and Carlton, who are struggling for numbers.

9. ISAAC HEENEY $506,000 FWD/MID
AP: BUY. Imagine trading in Heeney for Charlie Curnow in round 23.

TM: BUY. How are there still people who don’t have Heeney? That last quarter against Collingwood would have been seriously painful viewing for non-owners.

Patch: BUY. Who is buying Heeney who doesn’t already have him? Yes. Absolutely. But also, what are you doing?

CW: HUH. People … don’t have him? Why? Check the match-ups for someone who has a high ceiling, but you can’t go wrong with Heeney after an 80-point quarter last week.

10. DANIEL CURTIN $131,800 DEF/MID
AP: BUY: I want him to stay cheap for next year but can’t see the Crows dropping him after last week’s effort.
TM: BUY. If you’re using your last trade (or trades) it’s probably wise to go for Curtin’s DPP over Archie Roberts. But this is coming from a guy who traded in Curnow, McKay and Saad for depth only for them to be injured in the same game.
Patch: AVOID. Nah dawg. He’ll be sub again.
CW: CONSIDER. If you need DPP, and have trades to burn, why not
 
Joined
13 Jun 2022
Messages
5,228
Likes
17,244
AFL Club
St Kilda
SuperCoach AFL 2024: Trade replacements for injured stars in round 23 rated

Tim English. OUT. Charlie Curnow. OUT. Clayton Oliver. OUT. Their replacements will decide SuperCoach prelim finals. Our experts rate the best options for your team.

Al Paton and Patch

10 min read
August 15, 2024 - 11:50AM

After sailing through the first 16 rounds of the season almost without incident, injuries have hit SuperCoaches like a truck in the run home.
Tim English, Charlie Curnow and Clayton Oliver have all been ruled out for preliminary final week, and Harry Sheezel is under a major injury cloud.

For coaches with trades up their sleeve, now is the time to take advantage on rivals who went too hard, too early.

So, who are the best replacements for this week’s injured stars? Our experts rate the most traded in players this week – and scroll down for full round 23 match-up analysis.

1. TRISTAN XERRI $683,900 RUC
Al Paton: BUY. Normally wouldn’t advise spending over $680k on anyone but if you have the cash, spend up on the best scorer in SuperCoach.

Tim Michell: BUY. Best ruckman in SuperCoach this year and could be up against Sam Darcy this week. Xerri is a legitimate captaincy option for the next two weeks and incredibly is the most expensive player in SuperCoach after round 22. He needs to score about 110 to eclipse $700k. It was only seven weeks ago he scored 141 against the Bulldogs.

Patch: BUY. Best ruck in the game and will be lining up against Sam Darcy on the weekend. Lock him in and C him.

Chloe Williams: BUY. Buy. Just buy.

2. DYLAN MOORE $501,000 FWD
AP: BUY. Not sure why I didn’t consider him with my 40th trade, which I used last week on Izak Rankine. Moore is the No.5 forward this year and could destroy Richmond this weekend.

TM: BUY. The Hawks are going to play finals with games against North Melbourne and Richmond in the next two weeks looking like they could be a SuperCoach feast. I like his captain James Sicily as a trade in this week for his high ceiling but Moore is a great option too.

Patch: BUY. He’s good! I really like him. Has a super run home.

CW: BUY. If you can get there, do it. He has Richmond and North Melbourne to come, and the Hawks are flying. A three-round average of 95.3 with a huge ceiling.

3. MAX GAWN $597,900 RUC
AP: CONSIDER. I prefer Rowan Marshall around this price based on fixtures, but even a banged-up Gawn can do what few others can in SuperCoach.

TM: PASS. I’d assume this is people trading out Tim English with one trade left who can’t get to Xerri. Gawn was heroic against Port Adelaide and although he’s determined to play out the season he’s doing so on one leg. Based on match-ups I’d go Rowan Marshall instead.

Patch: BUY. I prefer Xerri but if Big X is too dear for you, then Max will bring you home.

CW: BUY. If you can’t afford Xerri, Gawn could guide you to a finals win off the back of a 177 as he will look to galvanise the under-fire Dees.

4. TOM POWELL $425,700 MID/FWD
AP: PASS. Past three games have been what we were hoping for earlier in the year, but I still don’t trust Clarko.

TM: PASS. Four weeks ago he scored 39. I know his role has been better in the last three rounds but anything close to that score from round 19 and you can kiss your hopes of SuperCoach league glory goodbye.

Patch: AVOID. Well, well, well... look who’s come crawling back. (Us, we’ve come crawling back). He’s been really good the past few weeks, but that’s been with George Wardlaw out. I’m not sold on how they score together.

CW: BUY. Can we go back there? For two weeks, yes. Even if Wardlaw comes back in, Sheezel could well be done for the year. Worth the risk to win your finals.



5. ARCHIE ROBERTS $117,300 DEF
AP: CONSIDER. If you have two trades (!) and a downgrade gets you up to Xerri, go for it. Defensive bench cover might be needed, too, if Harry Sheezel doesn’t get up.

TM: BUY. If Brad Scott ruins Saad El Hawli’s price for next year after ruining Roberts two weeks ago I’ll be angrier than Patch was when Mac Andrew kicked that goal after the siren.

Patch: BUY. Yeah sure, although he’ll be sub at some stage.

CW: PASS. He could be the sub, with a low score, or even if you need a doughnut … I’m sure you will come across one with this week’s carnage!

6. IZAK RANKINE $552,600 FWD
AP: BUY. Now have Moore ahead of him but Izak can still bust out some big scores. Looked a bit rusty last week after four games out.

TM: BUY. Doesn’t need many disposals to score big SuperCoach points. Looked certain to ton when he had three early goal assists against the Western Bulldogs before slowing. He’s a point of difference pick and made for big stages like this week’s Showdown.

Patch: BUY. I think he’s neat. Bring him in if you can afford him.

CW: CONSIDER. He didn’t have the greatest SuperCoach return last week, but it’s the Showdown.


7. MATTHEW KENNEDY $398,100 FWD/MID
AP: CONSIDER. Can score well if he gets midfield time but who knows who will play where for the Blues as Michael Voss tries to plug holes left, right and centre.

TM: PASS. What the? Where has this come from? I suspect with Harry McKay and Charlie Curnow ruled out that Kennedy is going to spend a fair bit of time forward against West Coast. Don’t go there unless you think he can kick 3-4 goals. Prefer James Peatling or Matteas Phillipou if you’re strapped for cash.

Patch: WHAT. A Kennedy being relevant in SuperCoach? What is this, 2016? I’ll defer to whatever Tim writes here, I got no clue.

CW: CONSIDER. I personally am a fan. He doesn’t have the best numbers this year, but his 119 last week proved what he can do with full midfield minutes. I would have said ‘buy’, but I’m almost certain he gets thrown forward among the Carlton carnage.

8. ROWAN MARSHALL $604,600 RUC
AP: BUY. Averaging 127.5 over his past four and has a fantastic match-up against the Cats this weekend.

TM: BUY. See above. I think he’s the best English trade option.

Patch: BUY. Yeah sure. He’s playing, which is more than you can say for Tim English.

CW: BUY. Another great English replacement. A three-round average of 129, with match-ups against Geelong – who give up a lot of points to ruckmen – and Carlton, who are struggling for numbers.

9. ISAAC HEENEY $506,000 FWD/MID
AP: BUY. Imagine trading in Heeney for Charlie Curnow in round 23.

TM: BUY. How are there still people who don’t have Heeney? That last quarter against Collingwood would have been seriously painful viewing for non-owners.

Patch: BUY. Who is buying Heeney who doesn’t already have him? Yes. Absolutely. But also, what are you doing?

CW: HUH. People … don’t have him? Why? Check the match-ups for someone who has a high ceiling, but you can’t go wrong with Heeney after an 80-point quarter last week.

10. DANIEL CURTIN $131,800 DEF/MID
AP: BUY: I want him to stay cheap for next year but can’t see the Crows dropping him after last week’s effort.
TM: BUY. If you’re using your last trade (or trades) it’s probably wise to go for Curtin’s DPP over Archie Roberts. But this is coming from a guy who traded in Curnow, McKay and Saad for depth only for them to be injured in the same game.
Patch: AVOID. Nah dawg. He’ll be sub again.
CW: CONSIDER. If you need DPP, and have trades to burn, why not
Or if you're on a budget like me, Keays or Hogan, Keays for me.
 
Joined
30 Jun 2012
Messages
4,731
Likes
9,085
AFL Club
Brisbane
Speaking of budget. I just cancelled my herald sun subscription account after they emailed me telling me of a price jump. - annoyingly poor that one needs to call up and receive a human sales pitch, reminder that it is all in the terms and conditions, and an offer (surprisingly annoying) of a few months at a very small fee schedule (I suspect they hope people forget to call an cancel again at the end of it).

Anyway, I'm just trying to figure out if it is worth continuing SC at all without a subscription, as I wonder if it will be just too annoying. I mean, I know this is possibly in poor taste considering we all love and enjoy Supercoach, but wonder how the other half fair without paying the 32 bucks a month. I mean, i prefer many other free and more interesting sites for my news anyway, so...

Any thoughts on this?

Cheers
 
Joined
15 Mar 2019
Messages
15,032
Likes
57,909
AFL Club
Hawthorn
Speaking of budget. I just cancelled my herald sun subscription account after they emailed me telling me of a price jump. - annoyingly poor that one needs to call up and receive a human sales pitch, reminder that it is all in the terms and conditions, and an offer (surprisingly annoying) of a few months at a very small fee schedule (I suspect they hope people forget to call an cancel again at the end of it).

Anyway, I'm just trying to figure out if it is worth continuing SC at all without a subscription, as I wonder if it will be just too annoying. I mean, I know this is possibly in poor taste considering we all love and enjoy Supercoach, but wonder how the other half fair without paying the 32 bucks a month. I mean, i prefer many other free and more interesting sites for my news anyway, so...

Any thoughts on this?

Cheers
I have never subscribed. Never done well either, but I don't think the two are linked.
 

Connoisseur

Leadership Group
Joined
3 Jul 2017
Messages
38,953
Likes
126,605
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
Speaking of budget. I just cancelled my herald sun subscription account after they emailed me telling me of a price jump. - annoyingly poor that one needs to call up and receive a human sales pitch, reminder that it is all in the terms and conditions, and an offer (surprisingly annoying) of a few months at a very small fee schedule (I suspect they hope people forget to call an cancel again at the end of it).

Anyway, I'm just trying to figure out if it is worth continuing SC at all without a subscription, as I wonder if it will be just too annoying. I mean, I know this is possibly in poor taste considering we all love and enjoy Supercoach, but wonder how the other half fair without paying the 32 bucks a month. I mean, i prefer many other free and more interesting sites for my news anyway, so...

Any thoughts on this?

Cheers
Articles can usually be accessed via archive.ph to bypass the paywall if posted under the masthead. Generic stuff to be repeated here either after or before the fact. Advanced stats not publicly available posted in the article will likely be posted in one of the threads from someone.

Breakevens available on Footywire, etc projections should not be taken seriously and green and red lights for players unavailable or available are for lazy people relying on a secondary source when the primary sources are already known and is not an exhaustive task to check.

Probability of being able to take advantage of the double weekly prize winning offer if a subscriber is exteremely low and not worth it in the long run.

In relation to Supercoach, there is little to no benefit of being a subscriber and I feel the SC Plus subscription is akin to throwing money down a well.
 
Joined
30 Jun 2012
Messages
4,731
Likes
9,085
AFL Club
Brisbane
Articles can usually be accessed via archive.ph to bypass the paywall if posted under the masthead. Generic stuff to be repeated here either after or before the fact. Advanced stats not publicly available posted in the article will likely be posted in one of the threads from someone.

Breakevens available on Footywire, etc projections should not be taken seriously and green and red lights for players unavailable or available are for lazy people relying on a secondary source when the primary sources are already known and is not an exhaustive task to check.

Probability of being able to take advantage of the double weekly prize winning offer if a subscriber is exteremely low and not worth it in the long run.

In relation to Supercoach, there is little to no benefit of being a subscriber and I feel the SC Plus subscription is akin to throwing money down a well.
I have never subscribed. Never done well either, but I don't think the two are linked.
These are both very good answers... Appreciate the answers. Food for thought.

Cheers!
 
Joined
7 Sep 2020
Messages
12,069
Likes
42,460
Speaking of budget. I just cancelled my herald sun subscription account after they emailed me telling me of a price jump. - annoyingly poor that one needs to call up and receive a human sales pitch, reminder that it is all in the terms and conditions, and an offer (surprisingly annoying) of a few months at a very small fee schedule (I suspect they hope people forget to call an cancel again at the end of it).

Anyway, I'm just trying to figure out if it is worth continuing SC at all without a subscription, as I wonder if it will be just too annoying. I mean, I know this is possibly in poor taste considering we all love and enjoy Supercoach, but wonder how the other half fair without paying the 32 bucks a month. I mean, i prefer many other free and more interesting sites for my news anyway, so...

Any thoughts on this?

Cheers

Can you access Supercoach articles with just the one off subscription to gold?
 
Last edited:

Darkie

Leadership Group
Joined
12 Apr 2014
Messages
25,401
Likes
65,466
AFL Club
Collingwood
Can you access Supercoach articles with just the one off subscription to gold?
I don’t believe so - I never have in the past, and just checked again and was unable to.

@Beijing_Sting, I have had an SC Gold subscription for many years and have found that it is very useful, especially if you are keen/time poor/happy to pay for the convenience of having breakevens, player filters etc at hand. I think it’s still c. $20, which to me is a good tradeoff for the time saving, albeit this will vary from person to person.

If you were paying somewhere towards $32 per month for a Herald Aun subscription, $20 per season for Gold is probably quite a palatable alternative in providing much of what you want (ex the articles), without the vast majority of the cost.
 
Joined
9 Aug 2012
Messages
40,127
Likes
151,429
AFL Club
Carlton
I don’t believe so - I never have in the past, and just checked again and was unable to.

@Beijing_Sting, I have had an SC Gold subscription for many years and have found that it is very useful, especially if you are keen/time poor/happy to pay for the convenience of having breakevens, player filters etc at hand. I think it’s still c. $20, which to me is a good tradeoff for the time saving, albeit this will vary from person to person.

If you were paying somewhere towards $32 per month for a Herald Aun subscription, $20 per season for Gold is probably quite a palatable alternative in providing much of what you want (ex the articles), without the vast majority of the cost.
I'm being charged $40 every four weeks, up from $36. I have access to all digital content, SC get the paper delivered every weekend. I'm not too fussed at the cost as I claim it as a tax deduction. 😎
 
Top