Discussion General Discussion

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
29 Apr 2014
Messages
128
Likes
94
AFL Club
St Kilda
does anyone know if they are taking away that trade/substitue thingy? I cant seem to do it at the moment?
eg - Buy Zorko MID
Sell a FWD
Move Zorko to FWD
buy a MID ?
 

Goodie's Guns

Leadership Group
Joined
21 May 2012
Messages
22,312
Likes
31,158
AFL Club
Hawthorn
does anyone know if they are taking away that trade/substitue thingy? I cant seem to do it at the moment?
eg - Buy Zorko MID
Sell a FWD
Move Zorko to FWD
buy a MID ?
I'm pretty sure its still in, but won't be able to be utilised as such until the lockout and season starts.
Therefore just move Zokro, but deleting him from MID and re-selecting him in the FWD's.
 

Darkie

Leadership Group
Joined
12 Apr 2014
Messages
25,410
Likes
65,497
AFL Club
Collingwood
A bit of help if you fine people would be so kind. I drew up the first iteration of my team and was surprised to find: No players from Brisbane, Hawthorn or Port; Three players from Carlton, Geelong and Sydney. It got me thinking about composition.

Winning teams presumably get the lions share of the available SC points. Hawthorn players seem to have the points shared around. Some elite players get a lot of points although they are not in winning teams. Should one choose elites from poorer teams?

Thoughts appreciated - ideally backed by statistics.

Three quick points for you Chels:

- Given that initial SC prices are set based on last year's average, what we should generally all be looking for is players who can outperform last year's average. Most teams that were poor in 2014 will likely remain so - so if there's a significant disadvantage to playing in a weak team, it should be priced in to a large degree. If you decide that a player's team is important, perhaps focus on the teams you think will lift their ladder position, rather than those you think will simply end up in a high position. Similarly in relation to spread - perhaps the question should be whether/how the spread changes.

- The draw is an obvious issue to consider - especially as this changes from year to year, and therefore is less likely to be priced in.

- See the link below. For me, the lesson is that if you are looking for someone to score 120+ - noting that you shouldn't expect that from more than about two or three players - you should very likely pick Ablett, and then focus on your expected top four teams. I don't know that this would necessarily hold with a lower cutoff, say 110, but for M1, M2, etc, the top ranked teams should be your second port of call after Ablett.

http://www.supercoachscores.com/threads/1063-Questions-For-Rowsus/page148
 
Last edited:
Joined
8 Jan 2015
Messages
917
Likes
1,657
AFL Club
Sydney
Three quick points for you Chels:

- Given that initial SC prices are set based on last year's average, what we should generally all be looking for is players who can outperform last year's average. Most teams that were poor in 2014 will likely remain so - so if there's a significant disadvantage to playing in a weak team, it should be priced in to a large degree. If you decide that a player's team is important, perhaps focus on the teams you think will lift their ladder position, rather than those you think will simply end up in a high position. Similarly in relation to spread - perhaps the question should be whether/how the spread changes.

- The draw is an obvious issue to consider - especially as this changes from year to year, and therefore is less likely to be priced in.

- See the link below. For me, the lesson is that if you are looking for someone to score 120+ - noting that you shouldn't expect that from more than about two or three players - you should very likely pick Ablett, and then focus on your expected top four teams. I don't know that this would necessarily hold with a lower cutoff, say 110, but for M1, M2, etc, the top ranked teams should be your second port of call after Ablett.

http://www.supercoachscores.com/threads/1063-Questions-For-Rowsus/page148
Many thanks Darkie, much obliged amigo
 
Joined
22 Jan 2013
Messages
3,858
Likes
1,652
AFL Club
Collingwood
for the life of me i cannot find where to sign up to sc gold. think im retarded can someone inform me as to where i find it. Thanks in advance
 
Joined
8 Jan 2014
Messages
6,968
Likes
11,084
AFL Club
Melbourne
I found it difficult as well. I think you go to the team page and then click on the SC GOLD option on the top right. I think that then prompts you to sign up.
As I said, it took me a wile to figure it out and now I'm not exactly sure how I did it, so I hope I have pointed you in the right direction :)
If that doesn't work, try the player research page and there might be a link there.
 
Joined
16 Mar 2012
Messages
3,547
Likes
611
AFL Club
Carlton
I had a dream overnight that Joel Selwood scored 55 and 52 in the first two matches of the season. I was whinging to somebody about picking him and checked his score for the third match of the season (surely I should have traded him out) and he was the 3rd ranked player in the 3rd quarter.

a) This is disturbing and a clear indication I think about Supercoach too much.
b) I don't believe Selwood scoring so poorly twice in a row is possible, although I have had other sporting related dreams become true. I once had a dream that I was in the mounting yard discussing my surprise at a long shot winning the Emirates Stakes, although no horses name was mentioned. It was in 2007 and Tears I Cry won at $61 (I backed another long shot in reality so it was quite irritating).
 
Joined
22 Jan 2013
Messages
3,858
Likes
1,652
AFL Club
Collingwood
I had a dream overnight that Joel Selwood scored 55 and 52 in the first two matches of the season. I was whinging to somebody about picking him and checked his score for the third match of the season (surely I should have traded him out) and he was the 3rd ranked player in the 3rd quarter.

a) This is disturbing and a clear indication I think about Supercoach too much.
b) I don't believe Selwood scoring so poorly twice in a row is possible, although I have had other sporting related dreams become true. I once had a dream that I was in the mounting yard discussing my surprise at a long shot winning the Emirates Stakes, although no horses name was mentioned. It was in 2007 and Tears I Cry won at $61 (I backed another long shot in reality so it was quite irritating).
Hope your dream doesnt come true mate im pretty set on starting him although im testing out a new way atm of 2 prem mid and pretty much set and forget def/ruck/fwds so in that senario hes out and have GAJ and rocky
 
Joined
23 Mar 2012
Messages
19,855
Likes
929
AFL Club
Carlton
I had a dream overnight that Joel Selwood scored 55 and 52 in the first two matches of the season. I was whinging to somebody about picking him and checked his score for the third match of the season (surely I should have traded him out) and he was the 3rd ranked player in the 3rd quarter.

a) This is disturbing and a clear indication I think about Supercoach too much.
b) I don't believe Selwood scoring so poorly twice in a row is possible, although I have had other sporting related dreams become true. I once had a dream that I was in the mounting yard discussing my surprise at a long shot winning the Emirates Stakes, although no horses name was mentioned. It was in 2007 and Tears I Cry won at $61 (I backed another long shot in reality so it was quite irritating).
I had a nightmare once that I was at 1993 Grand Final and Carlton would pick Mark Athorn and Tim Powell in the team, leave Kouta and Peter Dean out and then start Athorn on Michael Long at opening bounce. I tried to pinch myself I was still asleep but sadly I was awake and the nightmare was happening.
 
Joined
18 Mar 2012
Messages
2,908
Likes
2,565
AFL Club
Essendon
I had a nightmare once that I was at 1993 Grand Final and Carlton would pick Mark Athorn and Tim Powell in the team, leave Kouta and Peter Dean out and then start Athorn on Michael Long at opening bounce. I tried to pinch myself I was still asleep but sadly I was awake and the nightmare was happening.
Nightmare ? sounds like a wet dream to me :p
 
Joined
18 Mar 2012
Messages
2,908
Likes
2,565
AFL Club
Essendon
Not sure if its been mentioned but i just realized with the increased weekly prizes from 1st to top 5 they have ditched the top score for the year prize , so no car to be won from i have read.
 
Joined
8 Jan 2014
Messages
6,968
Likes
11,084
AFL Club
Melbourne
I had a dream overnight that Joel Selwood scored 55 and 52 in the first two matches of the season. I was whinging to somebody about picking him and checked his score for the third match of the season (surely I should have traded him out) and he was the 3rd ranked player in the 3rd quarter.

a) This is disturbing and a clear indication I think about Supercoach too much.
b) I don't believe Selwood scoring so poorly twice in a row is possible, although I have had other sporting related dreams become true. I once had a dream that I was in the mounting yard discussing my surprise at a long shot winning the Emirates Stakes, although no horses name was mentioned. It was in 2007 and Tears I Cry won at $61 (I backed another long shot in reality so it was quite irritating).
Sometimes your subconscious brain can assemble various bits of information from different sources and present it in a logical format as a dream. It can also manifest as a hunch or educated guess. These can sometimes be quite accurate and so I think it is always worthwhile to think about whether there is any sound reasoning or facts behind the dream or hunch.

For this reason I thought I would have a quick look at SC Gold to see if it was projecting low scores for Selwood in the first few rounds. As it turns out, the projections look quite good so I guess this wasn't the source. It did get me to thinking however about the accuracy of the SC Gold weekly projections and whether they are any good or not. I seem to remember Rowsus a while ago making some comment about them not being very good but I can't remember exactly what he said. I would be interested to know whether anyone uses the SC Gold weekly projections and whether they have found them to be reliable or not. If you don't use SC Gold, then what do you use?

I may also copy this post to the Questions for Rowsus thread as I'm sure he will have some thoughts on this matter.
 

Philzsay

Leadership Group
Joined
21 Mar 2012
Messages
10,448
Likes
14,965
AFL Club
Essendon
Any body else see this in the Herald Sun? Some guy has produced a championship ring for himself for winning his SuperCoach league.

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/a...r-league-winners/story-fni5f3gz-1227214315006
Been hard to miss him, he has been trying to flog his $99 ring in a number of SC places.

I won't be buying it based on what I consider deceptive advertising:

- Less than a day of creating the website he posted on BF that "He saw an advert for the ring on facebook and bought it immediately". I later simply asked him on BF if he was the owner of the website and despite logging in he has not bothered to answer.
- He created an account on here, started a new thread about how he had bought the ring and just had to show us.... Never bothered to actually engage us on SC issues. Thread was deleted.
- Created a twitter account and spammed over 100 footy players with the same identical tweet.
- The website has no contact details. No phone number. No address. No names. Not even an email address. I only found out his name by doing a Whois search of the web address.

As far as I am concerned if that is the way he wishes to conduct business then there is no way I can trust the product.

Each to their own, but caveat emptor!
 
Last edited:
Joined
11 Apr 2012
Messages
761
Likes
106
AFL Club
Richmond
Been hard to miss him, he has been trying to flog his $99 ring in a number of SC places.

I won't be buying it based on what I consider deceptive advertising:

- Less than a day of creating the website he posted on BF that "He saw an advert for the ring on facebook and bought it immediately". I later simply asked him on BF if he was the owner of the website and despite logging in he has not bothered to answer.
- He created an account on here, started a new thread about how he had bought the ring and just had to show us.... Never bothered to actually engage us on SC issues. Thread was deleted.
- Created a twitter account and spammed over 100 footy players with the same identical tweet.
- The website has no contact details. No phone number. No address. No names. Not even an email address. I only found out his name by doing a Whois search of the web address.

As far as I am concerned if that is the way he wishes to conduct business then there is no way I can trust the product.

Each to their own, but caveat emptor!
Oh, I had no idea. It was the first time I'd heard about it but from your experience Philzsay he doesn't sound too classy.
 
Joined
16 Mar 2012
Messages
3,547
Likes
611
AFL Club
Carlton
Here are the finals averages for players that played in 3 finals last season:
Sam Mitchell 131.3
Nick Dal Santo 126.0
Luke Hodge 125.7
Todd Goldstein 123.7
Luke Parker 119.7
Travis Boak 110.0
Jordan Lewis 108.7
Robbie Gray 108.3
Josh Kennedy 108.0
Lance Franklin 106.7
Oliver Wines 105.7
Levi Greenwood 103.3
Kieren Jack 102.7
William Langford 101.0
Sam Gibson 100.3
Hamish Hartlett 96.7
Chad Wingard 96.3
Drew Petrie 96.3
Ben Cunnington 93.7
Bradley Hill 93.0
Brad Ebert 92.7
Daniel Hannebery 89.7
Luke Breust 88.3
Jack Gunston 88.3
Isaac Smith 87.3
Justin Westhoff 87.3
Josh Gibson 87.0
Jarryd Roughead 86.3
Scott Thompson 86.0
Adam Goodes 85.3
David Hale 85.3
Jared Polec 85.3
Jay Schulz 85.3
Shaun Burgoyne 83.0
Liam Shiels 83.0
Kurt Tippett 82.7
Ben McGlynn 82.3
Nick Smith 81.7
Samuel Wright 81.3
Grant Birchall 80.7
Nathan Grima 78.7
Mike Pyke 77.3
Jack Ziebell 76.3
Angus Monfries 74.7
Andrew Swallow 74.7
Matthew Lobbe 73.3
Benjamin Stratton 73.0
Nick Malceski 72.0
Michael Firrito 71.7
Thomas Jonas 71.7
Daniel Wells 71.3
Jake Lloyd 71.0
Jake Neade 70.7
Rhyce Shaw 69.7
Gary Rohan 67.3
Jack Hombsch 67.3
Kane Cornes 65.7
Jasper Pittard 65.0
Cameron O'Shea 64.7
Ben Brown 63.7
Lindsay Thomas 63.3
Luke McDonald 62.7
Ted Richards 62.3
Matthew Broadbent 61.0
Paul Puopolo 60.7
Jarrad McVeigh 60.7
Brian Lake 60.3
Alipate Carlile 60.0
Harry Cunningham 59.3
Shaun Atley 59.0
Lewis Jetta 58.0
Matthew Spangher 57.3
Matthew White 56.7
Heath Grundy 55.7
Jackson Trengove 54.3
Dane Rampe 53.7
Taylor Duryea 50.7
Kayne Turner 46.7
Aaron Black 45.0
Sam Reid 41.7
Craig Bird 36.7
Andrew Moore 34.7
Ryan Bastinac 14.7

Obviously these scores aren't considered when setting prices so any huge difference in average is worth some consideration when selecting a player. Ziebell and Wingard are the only two players that have altered my views somewhat by their finals scores.

I wish taggers could be picked as defenders (usually more defensive than rebounding defenders). Really liked Langford's finals series and definitely would have picked him in a def spot but not interested in him as a mid.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top