2015: Rookies

[Imcjb]

Heeney v miller job security till buys, who would avoid the vest more, who will score more?

"@FOXFootyLive

Jaeger O'Meara has dislocated his right kneecap in NEAFL. Will have scans this arvo. Rocket to update from MCG later. #AFLDeesSuns "

Will help Miller no doubt

 

[IDIG]

Got a similar predicament myself. Take Heeney over CEY knowing he won't start as sub or keep CEY with the thought that he has better JS than Heeney.

Anyone??

 

[Bomber18]

I've gone completely mental and going to go Goodes to Whitecross to get macintosh's score on the ground. Saad and Macintosh can hold D5 and D6, and I'll hope Whitecross can come in eventually!

 

[Goodie's Guns]

Hmm so Hogan 79, good pick, nearly should have put him on the field.
Salem 55, not bad considering what it was looking like, hopefully he improves.
Saad great!
Vandenberg great!
Miller not what I was looking for when I decided to put him on the field. Hopefully keeps his spot and improves next week.

 

[OzRulesFootball]

Saad, VandenBerg and Hogan all on my bench with (e) but Miller on bench.
Saleem on field and Heeney game started and he on bench. Mixed bag so far.

Just in general watching ruck stores this round like a Hawk to see how this new scoring impacts the game.

 

[OzRulesFootball]

Hmm so Hogan 79, good pick, nearly should have put him on the field.
Salem 55, not bad considering what it was looking like, hopefully he improves.
Saad great!
Vandenberg great!
Miller not what I was looking for when I decided to put him on the field. Hopefully keeps his spot and improves next week.

Saad, VandenBerg and Hogan all on my bench with (e) but Miller on bench.
Saleem on field and Heeney game started and he on bench. Mixed bag so far.

Just in general watching ruck stores this round like a Hawk to see how this new scoring impacts the game.

I see we got basically the same Goodies
Actually I suspect those selections of rookies are quite common for a lot of teams.
Somewhat frustrated had Hogan and Saleem around wrong way for what happened but quite happy Miller I left outright for bench. I still like him though. Think he will be good one but first week score poor.

 

[IDIG]

Anyone got a gut feel for Saad v Lonie's JS?

30k or whatever diff in price as well

 

[stephen]

Anyone got a gut feel for Saad v Lonie's JS?

30k or whatever diff in price as well

Expect Saad's JS is higher but would also think they're both ahead of Schneider who's also in today and will come out when they want to play taller. Also think Lonie has higher ceiling. FWIW I've got Lonie and not Saad.

 

[Bontempele]

Anyone got a gut feel for Saad v Lonie's JS?

30k or whatever diff in price as well

Billings will be back in a couple of weeks. So that will mean the end of one of Templeton, Saad, Lonie or Schneider.

I suspect Schneider will go, although they may want his experience. If so, Lonie will most likely go depending on performance.

I'm getting Lonie, because Saad has to average almost 10 more to go up the same amount. Just gonna hope Schneider is the one who goes.

I think Membrey or Bruce will go if they want to bring in Tom Lee. Membrey plays as a 3rd tall as he's not very mobile.

 

[IDIG]

Anyone got a gut feel for Saad v Lonie's JS?

30k or whatever diff in price as well

I can't help but laugh that i stuck with Saad. Only 15 odd points diff but just sums up how many 50/50s i've got wrong this week.

 

[OzRulesFootball]

I had to take Lonie instead of Saad due to my Ramsay mix up. Not having much fun with rookies like Cripps, Sheed going no good first round, Oxley subbed out after looking ok and Saleem on ground up forward over Hogan.
With Rocky injured this round sucks big time for me. I've had worse starts though so bring on next week and see if I can find some luck go my way.

 

[pjay79]

Which of these mid rookies would be the better pick (if not the sub):

Cockatoo $177k
Lang $159k
Gregson $117k

Or Anderson $141k

 

[Goodie's Guns]

Which of these mid rookies would be the better pick (if not the sub):

Cockatoo $177k
Lang $159k
Gregson $117k

Or Anderson $141k

Anderson if not sub.

 

[PC]

Which of these mid rookies would be the better pick (if not the sub):

Cockatoo $177k
Lang $159k
Gregson $117k

Or Anderson $141k

Anderson, Lang, Cockatoo, Gregson in that order imo

 

[Darkie]

Anderson, Lang, Cockatoo, Gregson in that order imo

Exactly how I ranked them as well.

 

[benderiffic]

Can only pick one of Gregson and Anderson due to not being able to afford a higher priced rookie. Thoughts?

 

[_Slip_]

Can only pick one of Gregson and Anderson due to not being able to afford a higher priced rookie. Thoughts?

Anderson

 

[krk004]

Anderson v Lang?

Not enough $$ for Cockatoo.

 

[_Slip_]

Anderson v Lang?

Not enough $$ for Cockatoo.

Lang starting but for full season I like Anderson more.

 

[Zimmer]

Anderson v Lang?

Not enough $$ for Cockatoo.

Anderson.