Opinion Player X vs Player Y

[Ben's Beasts]

Z Merrett v Motlop?

Z Merrett

 

[PC]

Z Merrett

Motlop too inconsistent for you BB?

 

[Ben's Beasts]

Motlop too inconsistent for you BB?

Yeah that's pretty much it.

I also think Merrett is more likely to play more games than him and average more than him this year.

 

[Ben's Beasts]

KK & Z Merrett v Malceski & Dahlhaus

 

[Aneil915]

KK & Z Merrett v Malceski & Dahlhaus

That's a hard one Ben, what do u think each one will average?

Maybe KK 90-95 & Z Merrett 85-90 v Malceski 85-90 & Dahlhaus 100-105

I'd go Malceski and Dahlhaus given that Dahlhaus will be a top 6 forward you would think where as the others I don't think will be top 7-8.

 

[Monya Meow Meow]

KK & Z Merrett v Malceski & Dahlhaus

It would be KK + ZM for me

 

[t.thomas6]

B Smith vs Eski vs Birchall vs *

*any others that can be lumped in here?

 

[Goodie's Guns]

B Smith vs Eski vs Birchall vs *

*any others that can be lumped in here?

Birchall for mine, especially if he gets the midfield time that I read about earlier today.

 

[t.thomas6]

B Smith vs Eski vs Birchall vs *

*any others that can be lumped in here?

Birchall for mine, especially if he gets the midfield time that I read about earlier today.

Smith's draw really puts him last in my mind. If Eski can find form he MAY be a good pick...but I did hear about Birchall's mid time hence why I brought him into the discussion

 

[Monya Meow Meow]

B Smith vs Eski vs Birchall vs *

*any others that can be lumped in here?

At the moment it seems to be Birch > Smith > Eski

 

[Bomber18]

Smith's draw really puts him last in my mind. If Eski can find form he MAY be a good pick...but I did hear about Birchall's mid time hence why I brought him into the discussion

Curse that report . I was hoping Smith has a blinder in the NAB and everyone starts him xD

 

[Jurn Stern]

Goldstein, M8 rookie, K.Simpson VS LBerger, Sloane, Malcheski

 

[Eagling]

Goldstein, M8 rookie, K.Simpson VS LBerger, Sloane, Malcheski

Goldstein, rookie, Simpson easily.

 

[Ben's Beasts]

Goldstein, M8 rookie, K.Simpson VS LBerger, Sloane, Malcheski

Goldstein, rookie, Simpson easily.

I agree.

I don't mind the Sloane and Malceski picks but Leuey is pus.

 

[Goodie's Guns]

Goldstein, M8 rookie, K.Simpson VS LBerger, Sloane, Malcheski

Goldstein, M8 rookie, K.Simpson by a mile for me

Only Sloane is of interest to me in the second option

 

[benderiffic]

Goldstein, M8 rookie, K.Simpson VS LBerger, Sloane, Malcheski

I am looking at something similar:

Boyd/Libba v Malceski/Fyfe

 

[whiteTiga2k]

where did you guys read about birchall playing midfield?

 

[PC]

Yeah that's pretty much it.

I also think Merrett is more likely to play more games than him and average more than him this year.

Supplementary question then Motlop v Franklin?

 

[Monya Meow Meow]

where did you guys read about birchall playing midfield?

I believe it was GG who posted in the DEF thread:

At Hawthorn's intra club match yesterday, defender Grant Birchall was seen playing the majority of the match in the centre and at stoppages.

 

[Chasing]

Boomer + Nic nat VS Dahlhouse + tippet?