Opinion Player X vs Player Y

D

Dannyk

Rising Star Nominee
#821
Joined
18 Jan 2014
Messages
149
Likes
3
AFL Club
Carlton
#821
Blaze said:
Birch over Macmillan just as he is more proven as a scorer but I don't really like either personally I am taking both Smith and Yeo over either at this stage. Out of Smith and Yeo I think Yeo has more upside. Brodie I think will return to mainly off half back this year with some time through the wing/mids. This role suits him and his scoring and if he can get through without getting knocked out he will score well! Brodie first picked in my def this year

Sloane v Parker - love sloaney but never liked him for my sc for some reason - Parker offers more upside but prob more risk like you say. Fyfe over Pendles easy for me but I always think pendles will drop off a bit but he never does lol

Mummy I think is a good pick as long as your team risk profile allows it! I like Nic Nat at that price though - think he will kick more goals resting forward this year which will ony improve his scoring

I can't judge the fwds at all - just risk everywhere there. Buddy or no buddy is such a tough decision this year as he is well priced...id take him over Greene I prob won't take buddy but not having him scares me a great deal. Wingard over Dahl for price but think Dahl probably shades him for average over the year. Their prices are both fair for there output IMO so no upside but solid picks if they suit your structure
Click to expand...

Sloane was actually 4th over-all ranked player in 2014 averaging 115. Bit surprised to read that!
 
Blaze

Blaze

#822
Joined
7 Apr 2012
Messages
3,096
Likes
5,921
AFL Club
Adelaide
#822
Dannyk said:
Sloane was actually 4th over-all ranked player in 2014 averaging 115. Bit surprised to read that!
Click to expand...
I know he's a gun and from my club but just don't want to pick him for some odd reason! FWIW I don't think he will be impacted that much by the tag this year
 
Prochard

Prochard

#823
Joined
27 Feb 2013
Messages
3,929
Likes
223
AFL Club
Collingwood
#823
Wingard vs Tippett vs Franklin vs Motlop?

At the moment I have them exactly in that order.

Thanks
 
Brettthejett

Brettthejett

#824
Joined
22 Jan 2013
Messages
3,858
Likes
1,652
AFL Club
Collingwood
#824
Prochard said:
Wingard vs Tippett vs Franklin vs Motlop?

At the moment I have them exactly in that order.

Thanks
Click to expand...
Im not sold on wingard he hasnt even entered my team once in the off season. With Lids,Dusty,Barlow all pushing 105+ i cant see him being a top 6 fwd
 
D

Dannyk

Rising Star Nominee
#825
Joined
18 Jan 2014
Messages
149
Likes
3
AFL Club
Carlton
#825
Prochard said:
Wingard vs Tippett vs Franklin vs Motlop?

At the moment I have them exactly in that order.

Thanks
Click to expand...
I would have them in an identical order. I think Bud could be a trap. Tippett shades him as he can be used as your ruck / fwd swingman.
Chad should ave high 90s but not sure if he can crack the 100 ave
 
Prochard

Prochard

#826
Joined
27 Feb 2013
Messages
3,929
Likes
223
AFL Club
Collingwood
#826
What about
Lobbe+Dalhouse
Vs
Tippett+Wingard
Vs
Tippett+Franklin?
Vs
Lobbe+Tippett?
Vs
Goldstein+Wells?
 
kakarot

kakarot

#828
Joined
6 May 2013
Messages
1,244
Likes
245
AFL Club
Carlton
#828
Libba M5 + Crouch M6 (663k) vs. Cripps M5 + 123k (M9 say) Rookie (642k)

In this scenario, Cripps would stay in my side unless LTI.
 
Eagling

Eagling

#829
Joined
3 Feb 2014
Messages
3,702
Likes
5,297
AFL Club
West Coast
#829
Hey guys; I've got a question about team structure and such.

Would you prefer:

D2: Yeo
D3: Smith
D4: Wiliams
R2: Lobbe
R3: Grimley
F3: Tippett
F4: Merrett

OR

D2: Smith/Yeo
D3: Williams
D4: Jesse Lonergan
R2: Tippett
R3: King
F3: Merett
F4: Franklin
F5/6/7/8: Grimley.


----

Basically it boils down to Jesse Lonergan v Matthew Lobbe.
 
Darkie

Darkie

Leadership Group
#830
Joined
12 Apr 2014
Messages
25,410
Likes
65,498
AFL Club
Collingwood
#830
Ablett for me Goodies. Probably more fit, better preseason, more proven, better scorer, better ceiling, cheaper, less role uncertainty.
 
Darkie

Darkie

Leadership Group
#831
Joined
12 Apr 2014
Messages
25,410
Likes
65,498
AFL Club
Collingwood
#831
kakarot said:
Libba M5 + Crouch M6 (663k) vs. Cripps M5 + 123k (M9 say) Rookie (642k)

In this scenario, Cripps would stay in my side unless LTI.
Click to expand...
Easily option one.

I'd back Libba to outscore Cripps, and he gives a heap of loose change.
 
Hondo

Hondo

#834
Joined
13 Mar 2012
Messages
2,790
Likes
2,985
AFL Club
Adelaide
#834
Eagling said:
Hey guys; I've got a question about team structure and such.

Would you prefer:

D2: Yeo
D3: Smith
D4: Wiliams
R2: Lobbe
R3: Grimley
F3: Tippett
F4: Merrett

OR

D2: Smith/Yeo
D3: Williams
D4: Jesse Lonergan
R2: Tippett
R3: King
F3: Merett
F4: Franklin
F5/6/7/8: Grimley.


----

Basically it boils down to Jesse Lonergan v Matthew Lobbe.
Click to expand...
I feel like there's a lot of spec picks in both lists. Too many really. It makes me want to respond with a "one I dislike the least" rather than what I prefer.
 
teatai

teatai

#838
Joined
24 Feb 2015
Messages
815
Likes
1,192
AFL Club
North Melb.
#838
Shaw, Priddis, mid rookie, Dahlhaus + $45,100 vs Eski, Fyfe, Danger, Wells $6,300
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top