Opinion Round 2: Teams and In Game Discussions

Joined
10 Feb 2014
Messages
11,375
Likes
21,228
AFL Club
Essendon
bombers outs are a bit surprising
Yeah, thought the same thing. Fantasia is best 22 (this year or not), he will be a gun - so someone had to make way.

Not sure what to make of Mckernan out. Bird has been pretty underwhelming I suppose. Simpkin wasn't bad. Maybe Brown goes forward.

I guess we'll need Kommer's forward pressure, Hartley extra tall in defence - I suppose I've sort of answered the question.

Mainly McKernan confuses me. He didn't have a great game on the weekend, but he's being played out of position. He's not a ruck, and we need all the forward grunt we can get. Adds more credence to the idea that Brown will go forward (not great for his scoring potential.)

Thinking Cooney is pretty lucky to escape the chop.

I guess as Essendon supporters we should expect it this year.

As supercoachers, the rest of you should take note. It's going to be all over the shop. Half these guys haven't had a proper pre-season, and half the team haven't ever played together.

The irony is, we'll get better as the season goes on, but the amount of kids we play will mean we can't run out games, so we'll still lose. Actually, that's not irony in anything but an Alanis Morrisette fashion* - it's just what's going to happen.

*some of things she sings about in that song are actually, by definition, ironic.
 
Last edited:
Joined
25 Jan 2013
Messages
1,570
Likes
1,373
AFL Club
Essendon
bombers outs are a bit surprising
Yeah, thought the same thing. Fantasia is best 22 (this year or not), he will be a gun - so someone had to make way.

Not sure what to make of Mckernan out. Bird has been pretty underwhelming I suppose. Simpkin wasn't bad.

I guess we'll need Kommer's forward pressure, Hartley extra tall in defence - I suppose I've sort of answered the question.

Mainly McKernan confuses me. He didn't have a great game on the weekend, but he's being played out of position. He's not a ruck, and we need all the forward grunt we can get.

Thinking Cooney is pretty lucky to escape the chop.
The coaches will still be figuring out what the best 22 is. Will take a while. Disappointed Simpkin is out, hopefully back in next week. Thought he'd be handy against the likes of Viney, Jones, Oliver and co
 
Joined
27 Jan 2014
Messages
6,769
Likes
14,766
AFL Club
Fremantle
Same for me, although I am looking long and hard for a damn loophole, I may have one that I can use, provided that Menadue goes reasonably well tomorrow night like last week.
I've got Max King at R3 and Menadue in the Friday night game but the only way Menadue is going to score more than Goldstein is if Goldy gets gastro and if Goldy doesn't play because he has gastro I would rather have the VC on Danger so I am going to play it like a lockout game this week and have the C on Goldy and the VC on Danger and let it ride.
 
Joined
24 Apr 2013
Messages
11,173
Likes
13,044
AFL Club
Carlton
Still wondering what the inclusion of Hartley will do to Brown.
Will Brown play forward or will Hartley take the best forward and allow Brown more freedom down back?
 
Joined
11 Feb 2014
Messages
5,329
Likes
28,688
AFL Club
Collingwood
Hi All ,
Have everyone but Grimley playing how do you go about picking the right rookies for on/off the ground
D have Dea , Adams ,( Brown , Hartley E )
M Mills , Hewett , Kerridge , ( Oliver E ,Davis ,Gresham )
F Menadue , McCarthy , ( AMT , McGovern E )

I have placed brackets around the ones for bench , have i chosen correctly or ideas and thoughts please , no trades done either
 
Joined
24 Jan 2014
Messages
507
Likes
940
AFL Club
St Kilda
Hi All ,
Have everyone but Grimley playing how do you go about picking the right rookies for on/off the ground
D have Dea , Adams ,( Brown , Hartley E )
M Mills , Hewett , Kerridge , ( Oliver E ,Davis ,Gresham )
F Menadue , McCarthy , ( AMT , McGovern E )

I have placed brackets around the ones for bench , have i chosen correctly or ideas and thoughts please , no trades done either
Personally I wouldn't change a thing
 
Joined
28 Dec 2012
Messages
4,021
Likes
2,719
Hi All ,
Have everyone but Grimley playing how do you go about picking the right rookies for on/off the ground
D have Dea , Adams ,( Brown , Hartley E )
M Mills , Hewett , Kerridge , ( Oliver E ,Davis ,Gresham )
F Menadue , McCarthy , ( AMT , McGovern E )

I have placed brackets around the ones for bench , have i chosen correctly or ideas and thoughts please , no trades done either
I'd play Brown over McCarthy
 
Joined
11 Feb 2014
Messages
5,329
Likes
28,688
AFL Club
Collingwood
I'd play Brown over McCarthy
So swap Brown and AMT positions and place brown on ground ...hmmm don't like McCarthy or does Brown have more scoring ability or will just get more sc points , appreciate the thoughts
 

Bomber18

Leadership Group
Joined
11 Nov 2012
Messages
27,409
Likes
65,138
AFL Club
Essendon
Still wondering what the inclusion of Hartley will do to Brown.
Will Brown play forward or will Hartley take the best forward and allow Brown more freedom down back?
I think Ambrose will start forward and Brown in defence but they will probably switch around. If Brown spends 2 qtrs down back hopefully that's enough to get his score to a 60+ score.
Those with Hartley, I'd probably start him on ground or as E over Brown/AMT. I'm beginning to wish I started him too!
 
Joined
28 Dec 2012
Messages
4,021
Likes
2,719
So swap Brown and AMT positions and place brown on ground ...hmmm don't like McCarthy or does Brown have more scoring ability or will just get more sc points , appreciate the thoughts
I think Brown has better scoring potential than McCarthy, especially with Hartley. It's not that I don't like him just not on my field. (I won't have Brown on my field either)
 
Joined
11 Feb 2014
Messages
5,329
Likes
28,688
AFL Club
Collingwood
I think Ambrose will start forward and Brown in defence but they will probably switch around. If Brown spends 2 qtrs down back hopefully that's enough to get his score to a 60+ score.
Those with Hartley, I'd probably start him on ground or as E over Brown/AMT. I'm beginning to wish I started him too!
Hi Bomber , i have all of them what would you do if you were me start/non start as per post above , thx
 
Joined
3 Dec 2014
Messages
4,358
Likes
7,050
AFL Club
Essendon
I would start/loophole Hartley if I had him.
I don't so I'm loopholing Brown.
And starting Tippa? Or not starting either and looping Brown?

I think I might start Adams and loop Tippa this week, after last week starting Brown, looping Tippa then playing Adams on field instead.
 
Joined
8 Mar 2012
Messages
565
Likes
225
AFL Club
Collingwood
Hey, I'm at home .... What are you implying? :p
Haha I was waiting for a response like that!
How good would it be that all home teams won this round! that would mean every team has won and lost a game after round 2. Odds of about 130/1
 
Top