Opinion Player X vs Player Y
- Thread starter yakka
- Start date
)
- Joined
- 21 May 2012
- Messages
- 22,312
- Likes
- 31,158
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
Cheers mate, that's the order I have them as well. Price is a bit of an issue, I've been working on numerous different trade plans to accomodate my required D6, premium MID, and Lycett over the next couple of weeks. Neale still only in around 7% of sides still, so I'm more inclined to go him and back him in ahead of Ward potentially...
- Joined
- 1 Feb 2015
- Messages
- 177
- Likes
- 55
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
Lycett vs Deledio vs Dahlhaus (on return)
I've been planning for Dahlhaus but Lycett will give me the link up with the rucks. Deledio is a proven SC gun but the more expensive of the three.
Current forward line:
Zorko, Martin, Merrett, Montagna, Hall, Kerridge (Rose, Phillips)
Kerridge the one to make way for one of the above three.
I've been planning for Dahlhaus but Lycett will give me the link up with the rucks. Deledio is a proven SC gun but the more expensive of the three.
Current forward line:
Zorko, Martin, Merrett, Montagna, Hall, Kerridge (Rose, Phillips)
Kerridge the one to make way for one of the above three.
As it stand, you currently have 7 forwards playing for the round so only 6 will count towards your score this round unless you can move Cox to R3 and/or have a non playing DPP in your midfield.
Assuming the former, I would use Kerridge to get Montagna, provided that you're not planning on keeping him as M9/F7 cover for the remainder of the season. Kerridge has a relatively high BE going into this round and is more likely to lose cash than Petracca. You can wait until next week to decide on what to do with Barlow once we have more information on the nature of his injury.
Assuming the former, I would use Kerridge to get Montagna, provided that you're not planning on keeping him as M9/F7 cover for the remainder of the season. Kerridge has a relatively high BE going into this round and is more likely to lose cash than Petracca. You can wait until next week to decide on what to do with Barlow once we have more information on the nature of his injury.
8 trades left, do i trade barlow to sloane, libba to phillips. This allows DBJ and PEtraca upgrades next week, complete team with 4 trades for finals
Or do i trade dunkley to phillips, allowing DBJ upgrade next week. so 6 trades remain with petracca holding the no-premo spot until Barlow comes back?
Or do i trade dunkley to phillips, allowing DBJ upgrade next week. so 6 trades remain with petracca holding the no-premo spot until Barlow comes back?
Thanks Idig and THLCT, much appreciated.
Ended up trading out Barlow, mainly on gutfeel that he either takes more time than expected to return (Freo might put the cue in the rack), or that Barlow reverts to an average of 90-95.
On tonight's performance Kerridge needs to go, he is deteriorating and I think might only be a 70-80 player for R16-23. Leaves me exposed re. trades but i have OK cover for short term injuries plus some $ in the kitty. No point keeping him as F7/M9 as I think Petracca can score about the same.
Ended up trading out Barlow, mainly on gutfeel that he either takes more time than expected to return (Freo might put the cue in the rack), or that Barlow reverts to an average of 90-95.
On tonight's performance Kerridge needs to go, he is deteriorating and I think might only be a 70-80 player for R16-23. Leaves me exposed re. trades but i have OK cover for short term injuries plus some $ in the kitty. No point keeping him as F7/M9 as I think Petracca can score about the same.