Position SC Gold - Coaches Choice Awards

Darkie

Leadership Group
Joined
12 Apr 2014
Messages
25,408
Likes
65,485
AFL Club
Collingwood
#41
Good discussion above. I think there are a range of factors contributing, including the rise in Heeney and Roughead's stocks, as well as the rookie outlook.

In terms of certainty that a particular player would be a top 6/8/2/6 scorer on their line, though, I'd say Macrae would be amongst my first handful or so in the comp.

Starting selections are obviously a real balancing act though.
 

Bomber18

Leadership Group
Joined
11 Nov 2012
Messages
27,409
Likes
65,138
AFL Club
Essendon
#42
I will monitor some of these breakout contenders or pods.

(Not to steal PC's thunder) But as of 4/3/2017

Heeney 28.4%
Petracca 13.0%
Caddy 12.2%
Mills 10.1%
Titch 9.8%
Vince 9.3%
Billings 3.4%
Higgins 2.9%
Salem 1.9%
Lloyd 1.8%
 
Joined
31 Dec 2014
Messages
544
Likes
304
AFL Club
Collingwood
#43
I will monitor some of these breakout contenders or pods.

(Not to steal PC's thunder) But as of 4/3/2017

Heeney 28.4%
Petracca 13.0%
Caddy 12.2%
Mills 10.1%
Titch 9.8%
Vince 9.3%
Billings 3.4%
Higgins 2.9%
Salem 1.9%
Lloyd 1.8%
Mildly surprised at Titch so low, but I must admit as D-Day draws closer I've started to have some doubts too. I took him out today to accommodate a 2/2/4 FWD line with the extra cash from going down to JOM instead. The old gut feel tells me to put him back in though ... really torn. I see Petracca gaining some traction too. He's in for me. Just got to watch the last Melbourne JLT highlights; he can do everything on a football field and is built like a tank.
 

Bomber18

Leadership Group
Joined
11 Nov 2012
Messages
27,409
Likes
65,138
AFL Club
Essendon
#44
Mildly surprised at Titch so low, but I must admit as D-Day draws closer I've started to have some doubts too. I took him out today to accommodate a 2/2/4 FWD line with the extra cash from going down to JOM instead. The old gut feel tells me to put him back in though ... really torn. I see Petracca gaining some traction too. He's in for me. Just got to watch the last Melbourne JLT highlights; he can do everything on a football field and is built like a tank.
Yep Petracca was higher than I expected.
 
Joined
22 Feb 2013
Messages
9,668
Likes
20,502
AFL Club
Hawthorn
#50
Plenty of changes this week with the JLT Series causing people to adjust their teams - in particular the masses lighting the fuse on da Bomb's ownership!

SC Gold Coaches Choice Award - as of the 5/3/17

Overall:
1. Fyfe (50%, was 51%)
2. Danger (49%, was 49%)
3. Gawn (46%, was 47%)
4. da Bomb (new, 41%)
5. Dahl (40%, was 40%)
6. Roughy (39%, was 37%)
7. Swallow D (39%, was 40%)
8. S&PShaker (38%, was 36%)
9. Scottishsuitcase (34%, was 39%)
10. Oldmotherhibberd (new, 33%)

Drop outs - Pigeon, Adams
New - da Bomb, Oldmotherhibbard

Defenders:
1. Oldmotherhibberd (33%, was 24%)
2. Pigeon (30%, was 33%)
3. Adams (30%, was 32%)
4. Shaw (29%, was 29%)
5. Stewart (27%, was 26%)
6. Ryan (27%, was 32%)
7. Hampton (new, 26%)
8. Laird (26%, was 20%)
9. Doch (22%, was 23%)
10. ElectricVW (new, 20%)

Drop outs - Shazzaberg, Berry
New - Hampton, ElectricVW

Mids (pure only):
1. Fyfe (50%, was 51%)
2. Danger (49%, was 49%)
3. da Bomb (41%, was 27%)
4. Swallow D (39%, was 39%)
5. S&PShaker (38%, was 36%)
6. Beams (new, 23%)
7. Freedom (22%, was 26%)
8. Pendles (21%, was 22%)
9. Bont (20%, was 21%)
10. Watson (new, 19%)

Drop outs - MyStoreMyers, Heppell
New - Beams, Watson

Rucks (pure only):
1. Gawn (46%, was 47%)
2. Sandi (28%, was 22%)
3. Goldy (15%, was 14%)
4. Preuss (new, 13%)
5. RegRundy (11%, was 12%)
6. Witts (9%, was 11%)
7. Martin (6%, was 7%)
8. English (4%, was 4%)
9. Eagles (4%, was 5%)
10. Jacobs (3%, was 4%)

Drop outs - Mummy
New - Preuss

Forwards:
1. Dahl (40%, was 40%)
2. Roughy (39%, was 37%)
3. Scottishsuitcase (34%, was 39%)
4. Heeney (28%, was 28%)
5. Eddy (27%, was 26%)
6. Black (27%, was 24%)
7. Pickettfence (25%, was 26%)
8. Strnman (20%, was 22%)
9. Macrae (new, 19%)
10. Easyryder (19%, was 24%)

Drop outs - Bowes
New - Macrae
 

KLo30

Leadership Group
Joined
27 Jan 2014
Messages
18,104
Likes
52,784
AFL Club
North Melb.
#51
Love your work PC.

Shouldn't it be Youngmotherhibberd to distinguish between the North version and Oldmotherhibberd the Melbourne version?
 
Last edited:

THCLT

BBL|05 Winner
Joined
13 Sep 2014
Messages
18,593
Likes
118,245
AFL Club
North Melb.
#52
Love your imagination and creativity in the names...:)
 

IDIG

Leadership Group
Joined
8 Mar 2012
Messages
35,325
Likes
20,501
AFL Club
Essendon
#53
Massive jump for JOM :eek:

I refuse to cheat and use SC Gold to figure out who 'pigeon' is so will sit here staring at the screen until i do!
 

MrMurdoch

300 Games Club
Joined
2 Apr 2013
Messages
1,571
Likes
82
AFL Club
Collingwood
#56
I struggle waaay more than I should with some of these nicknames
 
Joined
20 May 2014
Messages
3,346
Likes
8,275
AFL Club
St Kilda
#58
I cannot work out who is Freedom. I'm stumped.
If it's who I think it is, the problem may be that you're only thinking of SC relevant players. IMO he's the only player on the list who definitely shouldn't be. He may be a free man, but he's not free from hamstring problems.
 
Top