Position SC Gold - Coaches Choice Awards
- Thread starter PC
- Start date
Post JLT2 & after the Heeney news 7/3/2017
Heeney 21.3%
Nank 18.1%
Tuohy 14.5%
Petracca 14.5%
Caddy 12.4%
Mills 11.3%
Titch 9.6%
Vince 9.2%
Billings 5.7%
Higgins 3.1%
Salem 1.9%
Lloyd 2.3%
As expected Nank, Tuohy increase and Heeney decreases. Interesting to see where more of the Heeney numbers will go as more people update their sides.
Heeney 21.3%
Nank 18.1%
Tuohy 14.5%
Petracca 14.5%
Caddy 12.4%
Mills 11.3%
Titch 9.6%
Vince 9.2%
Billings 5.7%
Higgins 3.1%
Salem 1.9%
Lloyd 2.3%
As expected Nank, Tuohy increase and Heeney decreases. Interesting to see where more of the Heeney numbers will go as more people update their sides.
Very interesting that the top 10 % owned currently there are
4 premos (Fyfe, Danger, Dahlhaus, Gawn)
4 mid pricers - (JOM, Swallow, Roughy, Sandi)
2 rookies (SPP, Hibberd)
S00000 there are only 2 rookies and 1 that might not play - in the top 10! I may be wrong but this seems really different to previous years where everyone has the rookie locks. It is going to be an interesting season methinks! Surely a few other rookies like Stewart and Hampton will be top 10 in ownership when R 1 starts.
4 premos (Fyfe, Danger, Dahlhaus, Gawn)
4 mid pricers - (JOM, Swallow, Roughy, Sandi)
2 rookies (SPP, Hibberd)
S00000 there are only 2 rookies and 1 that might not play - in the top 10! I may be wrong but this seems really different to previous years where everyone has the rookie locks. It is going to be an interesting season methinks! Surely a few other rookies like Stewart and Hampton will be top 10 in ownership when R 1 starts.
Soooooo close to go time...
SC Gold Coaches Choice Award - as of the 12/3/17
Overall:
1. Fyfe (53%, was 50%)
2. Danger (49%, was 49%)
3. da Bomb (45%, was 41%)
4. S&PShaker (43%, was 38%)
5. Gawn (42%, was 46%)
6. Dahl (41%, was 40%)
7. Roughy (40%, was 39%)
8. Swallow D (40%, was 39%)
9. Sandi (new, 36%)
10. Newmotherhibberd (35%, was 33%)
Drop outs - Scottishsuitcase
New - Sandi
Defenders:
1. Newmotherhibberd (35%, was 33%)
2. Hampton (35%, was 26%)
3. Shaw (34%, was 29%)
4. Adams (29%, was 30%)
5. Stewart (28%, was 27%)
6. Pigeon (28%, was 30%)
7. Laird (25%, was 26%)
8. ElectricVW (22%, was 20%)
9. Doch (21%, was 22%)
10. Ryan (20%, was 27%)
Drop outs - N/A
New - N/A
Mids (pure only):
1. Fyfe (53%, was 50%)
2. Danger (49%, was 49%)
3. da Bomb (45%, was 41%)
4. S&PShaker (43%, was 38%)
5. Swallow D (39%, was 39%)
6. Beams (31%, was 23%)
7. Pendles (20%, was 21%)
8. Bont (20%, was 20%)
9. Barrett (new, 19%)
10. Freedom (18%, was 22%)
Drop outs - Watson
New - Barrett
Rucks (pure only):
1. Gawn (42%, was 46%)
2. Sandi (36%, was 28%)
3. Preuss (14%, was 13%)
4. Goldy (13%, was 15%)
5. RegRundy (9%, was 11%)
6. Witts (9%, was 9%)
7. Martin (6%, was 6%)
8. English (5%, was 4%)
9. Eagles (4%, was %)
10. Mummy (new, 3%)
Drop outs - Jacobs
New - Mummy
Forwards:
1. Dahl (41%, was 40%)
2. Roughy (40%, was 39%)
3. Eddy (28%, was 27%)
4. Pickettfence (28%, was 25%)
5. Black (25%, was 27%)
6. Taralalato (new, 24%)
7. Tankervis (new, 23%)
8. Scottishsuitcase (21%, was 34%)
9. Strnenanimaicanlicaw (20%, was 20%)
10. Macrae (19%, was 19%)
Drop outs - Heeney, Easyryder
New - Taralalato, Tankervis
SC Gold Coaches Choice Award - as of the 12/3/17
Overall:
1. Fyfe (53%, was 50%)
2. Danger (49%, was 49%)
3. da Bomb (45%, was 41%)
4. S&PShaker (43%, was 38%)
5. Gawn (42%, was 46%)
6. Dahl (41%, was 40%)
7. Roughy (40%, was 39%)
8. Swallow D (40%, was 39%)
9. Sandi (new, 36%)
10. Newmotherhibberd (35%, was 33%)
Drop outs - Scottishsuitcase
New - Sandi
Defenders:
1. Newmotherhibberd (35%, was 33%)
2. Hampton (35%, was 26%)
3. Shaw (34%, was 29%)
4. Adams (29%, was 30%)
5. Stewart (28%, was 27%)
6. Pigeon (28%, was 30%)
7. Laird (25%, was 26%)
8. ElectricVW (22%, was 20%)
9. Doch (21%, was 22%)
10. Ryan (20%, was 27%)
Drop outs - N/A
New - N/A
Mids (pure only):
1. Fyfe (53%, was 50%)
2. Danger (49%, was 49%)
3. da Bomb (45%, was 41%)
4. S&PShaker (43%, was 38%)
5. Swallow D (39%, was 39%)
6. Beams (31%, was 23%)
7. Pendles (20%, was 21%)
8. Bont (20%, was 20%)
9. Barrett (new, 19%)
10. Freedom (18%, was 22%)
Drop outs - Watson
New - Barrett
Rucks (pure only):
1. Gawn (42%, was 46%)
2. Sandi (36%, was 28%)
3. Preuss (14%, was 13%)
4. Goldy (13%, was 15%)
5. RegRundy (9%, was 11%)
6. Witts (9%, was 9%)
7. Martin (6%, was 6%)
8. English (5%, was 4%)
9. Eagles (4%, was %)
10. Mummy (new, 3%)
Drop outs - Jacobs
New - Mummy
Forwards:
1. Dahl (41%, was 40%)
2. Roughy (40%, was 39%)
3. Eddy (28%, was 27%)
4. Pickettfence (28%, was 25%)
5. Black (25%, was 27%)
6. Taralalato (new, 24%)
7. Tankervis (new, 23%)
8. Scottishsuitcase (21%, was 34%)
9. Strnenanimaicanlicaw (20%, was 20%)
10. Macrae (19%, was 19%)
Drop outs - Heeney, Easyryder
New - Taralalato, Tankervis
Last edited:
Bumping PC's wonderful work last year of the most popular selections
http://www.supercoachscores.com/threads/2837-SC-Gold-Most-Popular-Players
Coaches Award Nominations
ROUND ONE IS HERE! - 26/3/16
Def
1 Brown M (Ess) - 57%
2 Weitering - 52%
3 AMT - 47%
4 Shaw - 39%
5 Dea - 37%
6 Adams - 37%
7 Hartley - 23%
8 Rich - 18%
9 Laird - 15%
10 Rance - 15%
Rookies are the name of the game now! Over 50% of players owning Brown (Ess) and that expensive first year Blues player... AMT very popular, as well as Adams and Dea - interestingly, even though Hartley wasn't named, 23% kept him - I expect that could be either lack of funds or lack of time. SCS favourite Laird into the top 10 at 15%, while SCS discussion point Shaw in 39% of teams - man that is going to hurt if he gets on a roll early...
Mid
1 Danger - 53%
2 Libba - 53%
3 Mills - 49%
4 Ablett - 45%
5 Fyfe - 41%
6 Davis - 38%
7 Rocky - 33%
8 Oliver - 26%
9 Pendles - 24%
10 Gresham - 21%
Mids as you would expect with the lack of choice in the rookies - plenty choosing the one of the big 5, and Libba still popular. Starting team mids this year will be very same same I feel.
Ruc
1 OldGrimey - 32%
2 Goldy - 30%
3 Gawn - 26%
4 Cox M - 23%
5 NicNat - 20%
6 Martin - 13%
7 Lobbe - 13%
8 Blicavs - 11%
9 Currie - 10%
10 Smith - 9%
If the mids are same same, the rucks are not. FEAR THE BEARD moves to third most popular (BB you are a trendsetter), Cox flops to 4th (sorry, couldn't resist). No ruck in more than a third of teams, in fact only 2 premium choices in more than a quarter of teams. As every year, rucks will make and break.
Fwd
1 Kerridge - 67%
2 WellStep? - 60%
3 Chopsticks - 40%
4 Menadue - 39%
5 Barlow - 37%
6 PetRocka - 36%
7 BenKen - 34%
8 Buddy - 22%
9 Hall - 21%
10 De Goey - 18%
http://www.supercoachscores.com/threads/2837-SC-Gold-Most-Popular-Players
Coaches Award Nominations
ROUND ONE IS HERE! - 26/3/16
Def
1 Brown M (Ess) - 57%
2 Weitering - 52%
3 AMT - 47%
4 Shaw - 39%
5 Dea - 37%
6 Adams - 37%
7 Hartley - 23%
8 Rich - 18%
9 Laird - 15%
10 Rance - 15%
Rookies are the name of the game now! Over 50% of players owning Brown (Ess) and that expensive first year Blues player... AMT very popular, as well as Adams and Dea - interestingly, even though Hartley wasn't named, 23% kept him - I expect that could be either lack of funds or lack of time. SCS favourite Laird into the top 10 at 15%, while SCS discussion point Shaw in 39% of teams - man that is going to hurt if he gets on a roll early...
Mid
1 Danger - 53%
2 Libba - 53%
3 Mills - 49%
4 Ablett - 45%
5 Fyfe - 41%
6 Davis - 38%
7 Rocky - 33%
8 Oliver - 26%
9 Pendles - 24%
10 Gresham - 21%
Mids as you would expect with the lack of choice in the rookies - plenty choosing the one of the big 5, and Libba still popular. Starting team mids this year will be very same same I feel.
Ruc
1 OldGrimey - 32%
2 Goldy - 30%
3 Gawn - 26%
4 Cox M - 23%
5 NicNat - 20%
6 Martin - 13%
7 Lobbe - 13%
8 Blicavs - 11%
9 Currie - 10%
10 Smith - 9%
If the mids are same same, the rucks are not. FEAR THE BEARD moves to third most popular (BB you are a trendsetter), Cox flops to 4th (sorry, couldn't resist). No ruck in more than a third of teams, in fact only 2 premium choices in more than a quarter of teams. As every year, rucks will make and break.
Fwd
1 Kerridge - 67%
2 WellStep? - 60%
3 Chopsticks - 40%
4 Menadue - 39%
5 Barlow - 37%
6 PetRocka - 36%
7 BenKen - 34%
8 Buddy - 22%
9 Hall - 21%
10 De Goey - 18%
It's interesting Libba at 53% last year. I know coaches who did really well without him, others that started him and thought he was a success and others who kept him too long and got punished with him.
Many traded him in early after a hot start but missed 2 of the only 5 times he scored 100.
Ended up averaging 90 when many me included thought he would push over 100. Ended up probably not mattering if you started him or not.
Then this year we have JOM at 50%, me included. I wonder if we will look back and see a repeat.
Many traded him in early after a hot start but missed 2 of the only 5 times he scored 100.
Ended up averaging 90 when many me included thought he would push over 100. Ended up probably not mattering if you started him or not.
Then this year we have JOM at 50%, me included. I wonder if we will look back and see a repeat.
- Joined
- 4 Jan 2016
- Messages
- 822
- Likes
- 878
- AFL Club
- Essendon
I wish I had've done that, as originally planned, ended up holding, thought I had planned my last few trades well then I think Libba and 3 others went down in the same week (possibly 2) causing mayhem... Will be trying to be vigilant this year and sticking to my plan with JOM and other mid-pricers... Once I work out what that is...
Knee injuries are bad m'kay 
Seriously though, would we see JOM ownership as high as it is if we had 3 or 4 viable mid rookies to start on field?
Seriously though, would we see JOM ownership as high as it is if we had 3 or 4 viable mid rookies to start on field?
Hell I even have him at this point as I checked my rule book and there was no such "Don't pick a player who has missed two years with completely stuffed up knees" rule in there. I suppose I'll add it soon, just not sure if I'll add it in the next two weeks or during the season if/when he burns us.