Player X vs. Player Y

[Ben's Beasts]

Nah to fond of English, but if you think he is the best rookie to sacrifice then I guess I could consider it

I think in your position I would bypass English and just stick with Olango. But If you really want English then I would probably cut ZGL of the ones you mentioned as I don't think his scoring capacity is too great and in a good team like GWS I think his JS is reasonably shaky.

 

[Ben's Beasts]

Any other opinions on this?

I think Lloyd and Savage are a lot better picks than McGrath. I have both Lloyd and Savage but if I had to pick one it would be Lloyd, just.

 

[GoGeta]

Righto, I've backed myself into a bit of a corner here and I have the VC on Dusty and no FD

I am going to need to bring a FD in...so who out of the following would you sacrifice to bring in a FD...

Doedee v Finlayson v Holman v Banfield v ZGL v Ryan

Id drop Ryan, but just about everyone is more keen on him than i am.

 

[Presto]

Righto, I've backed myself into a bit of a corner here and I have the VC on Dusty and no FD

I am going to need to bring a FD in...so who out of the following would you sacrifice to bring in a FD...

Doedee v Finlayson v Holman v Banfield v ZGL v Ryan

I was in a similar position but rather than sacrifice Doedee/Finlayson/Holman/Ryan I got rid of English and brought Olango in.

 

[TommyGobbler]

McLean v Lobb

 

[The Experiment]

McLean v Lobb

I've got both, but probably McLean...at least he has a clean bill of health and a full preseason behind him

 

[Weedys Crop]

Mclean v Sicily ( might be already mentioned )
Brayshaw v banfield or both

 

[TopGrizzly]

Barry vs. Fogarty

 

[Seedsman]

Merrett and Bonner and $100k v Bontempelli and Sicily

 

[GoGeta]

Merrett and Bonner and $100k v Bontempelli and Sicily

Option 2 mate by a country mile..

 

[lakb24]

Bonner & Tom Bell + 132k (to bring in Danger potentially) VS Venables & Hurley/Hibberd?

 

[TommyGobbler]

Bonner & Tom Bell + 132k (to bring in Danger potentially) VS Venables & Hurley/Hibberd?

Venables & Hibberd

 

[GrainFedBeef]

Mclean v Sicily ( might be already mentioned )
Brayshaw v banfield or both

McLean more likely to be a premium, more mid/wing time and talk Dahlhause was up for trade last year as surplus to their needs. Sicily high volatility player, tag risk, 80k cheaper and better dpp.

Banfield - better value, could easily average the same.

McLean v Lobb

Mclean healthy, Lobb value and with limited game showed he can be 100 type player although this is based on just a few games. With limited quality rook depth, if Lobb misses any games then back up score will be questionable. would go Lobb if this is F5-6.

Barry vs. Fogarty

Barry. we know Gellong announced Tim Kelly earlier in the week and Scott said Fog was behind Constable all week in his thinking, Fog got the nod because he is a better foward. Assuming he disappears when Danger back.

Barry - named late, although no other port rooks were announced earlier. think Port is close to full strength except for Gray.

Think Barry, both Fogs, Murphy and Doodee could all be missing next week.

 

[bunlit]

Christensen (F5) and ZGL (F7) + 125k vs Lobb (F5) and Murphy (D8) and field Finlayson

 

[GoGeta]

Bonner & Tom Bell + 132k (to bring in Danger potentially) VS Venables & Hurley/Hibberd?

Leave midpriced madness alone, pick a premo and a rookie.

 

[Goodie's Guns]

A very late X vs. Y...

Danger + Rookie

vs.

Coniglio + Devon/Petracca

 

[Goodie's Guns]

Devon Smith vs Coniglio

Picking one, I'd take Coniglio

 

[stephen]

A very late X vs. Y...

Danger + Rookie

vs.

Coniglio + Devon/Petracca

Reckon option 2 is 80 points up on this round alone, and probably up most weeks anyway, even factoring for C scores. Option 2 by a long way. Like both Devon and Petracca but probably Devon first.

 

[TopGrizzly]

Barry. we know Gellong announced Tim Kelly earlier in the week and Scott said Fog was behind Constable all week in his thinking, Fog got the nod because he is a better foward. Assuming he disappears when Danger back.

Barry - named late, although no other port rooks were announced earlier. think Port is close to full strength except for Gray.

Think Barry, both Fogs, Murphy and Doodee could all be missing next week.

Sorry GFB, I meant D Fogarty from Adelaide. My thinking is he may have better JS now with Lynch and Tex missing R1

 

[The Experiment]

Christensen (F5) and ZGL (F7) + 125k vs Lobb (F5) and Murphy (D8) and field Finlayson

Rightly or wrongly I've gone Chrstensen to Lobb....

I choose Lobb/Murphy/field Finlayson