Player X vs. Player Y
- Thread starter Jurn Stern
- Start date
I like McLean of those 3 who i’m seriously considering as a replacement for Billings 
While I’d expect Greene to be a likely top fwd on average, I think the injury/suspension risk is too great to grab at close to full price. Menegola’s scoring seems dependent on opportunity and which vacancy in the midfield there is (completely unresearched POV I should add).
While I’d expect Greene to be a likely top fwd on average, I think the injury/suspension risk is too great to grab at close to full price. Menegola’s scoring seems dependent on opportunity and which vacancy in the midfield there is (completely unresearched POV I should add).
Last edited:
- Joined
- 20 Mar 2018
- Messages
- 185
- Likes
- 2
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
I have a similar choice in who (and when) to upgrade Lycett. The way I’m looking at it is that unforeseen injury aside NicNat should be good for 100+ average from here. Only way I can see going him over Grundy hurting is if Grundy goes 120+ season from here as I think I can find another 20 points a game elsewhere else using the cash saved going NicNat.
So the question is do you see Grundy going elite this year as per Goldstein 2015 ... he just might based on what we’ve seen so far against some pretty good ruck opposition (McEvoy, Kreuzer and Jacobs)
Still undecided myself ...
So the question is do you see Grundy going elite this year as per Goldstein 2015 ... he just might based on what we’ve seen so far against some pretty good ruck opposition (McEvoy, Kreuzer and Jacobs)
Still undecided myself ...
Thanks mate, here is my current team
Defence- Laird, Savage, Simpson, Doedee, Finlayson, Murray (Brander and Naughton
Mids- Titch, Kelly, Fyfe, Zorko, Cripps, Coniglio, Kelly, Holman (Brayshaw, Banfield and Garlett)
Rucks- Gawn and Lycett (Olango)
Forward- Walters, Smith, Petracca, Curnow, Sicily, English (Ryan and Fritsch)
$129,600 in bank
Already have 2 underperforming/injured mids in Zorko and Kelly so i kind of wanted a top team mid to replace Kelly. I really would like Gray but don't like the early bye, but he will definitely be in my team soon. Will be trading Brayshaw to Either Spargo or Coffield but leaning towards Spargo, i am hoping ZGL isnt names until next week so i can trade Ryan to him. Next week i could also potentially go Lycett and Holman to Danger and ZGL
Defence- Laird, Savage, Simpson, Doedee, Finlayson, Murray (Brander and Naughton
Mids- Titch, Kelly, Fyfe, Zorko, Cripps, Coniglio, Kelly, Holman (Brayshaw, Banfield and Garlett)
Rucks- Gawn and Lycett (Olango)
Forward- Walters, Smith, Petracca, Curnow, Sicily, English (Ryan and Fritsch)
$129,600 in bank
Already have 2 underperforming/injured mids in Zorko and Kelly so i kind of wanted a top team mid to replace Kelly. I really would like Gray but don't like the early bye, but he will definitely be in my team soon. Will be trading Brayshaw to Either Spargo or Coffield but leaning towards Spargo, i am hoping ZGL isnt names until next week so i can trade Ryan to him. Next week i could also potentially go Lycett and Holman to Danger and ZGL
If it were me, I'd go:
Kelly to Yeo and switch Finlayson into the mids. Brayshaw to Coffield.
Ryan to Guelfi, Naughton* to Mirra week after
Holman* to Danger in Round 7.
*Could also switch this order around with DPP depending on who looks like making more cash
But that's just me, I'd try target all the right rookies first and then have a plan to patch up the rest of the holes. This plan is actually similar to what I'm doing myself to get Danger (cat is out of the bag!).
Kelly to Yeo and switch Finlayson into the mids. Brayshaw to Coffield.
Ryan to Guelfi, Naughton* to Mirra week after
Holman* to Danger in Round 7.
*Could also switch this order around with DPP depending on who looks like making more cash
But that's just me, I'd try target all the right rookies first and then have a plan to patch up the rest of the holes. This plan is actually similar to what I'm doing myself to get Danger (cat is out of the bag!).
