Player X vs. Player Y

[Herbie66]

Not a huge fan of any of the first five you mentioned.

Would wait for Laird to become affordable. He is a must have defender.

Cheers mate.

Yep agree on Laird , very stupid mistake not starting him.

Lesson learnt

 

[Herbie66]

Not a huge fan of any of the first five you mentioned.

Would wait for Laird to become affordable. He is a must have defender.

curious Ben , outside of Laird , Hibberd , Simpson , Yeo who do you see as the other Top 8 defenders being ? or to early to tell.

 

[Ben's Beasts]

curious Ben , outside of Laird , Hibberd , Simpson , Yeo who do you see as the other Top 8 defenders being ? or to early to tell.

Savage is looking the goods with his 102 average even though his team is crap. Hurley will almost certainly be a top 8 defender. Sicily looking like he will be around the top 8. Then it has to be Hurn with his 106 average and his SC friendly role this season.

 

[Herbie66]

Savage is looking the goods with his 102 average even though his team is crap. Hurley will almost certainly be a top 8 defender. Sicily looking like he will be around the top 8. Then it has to be Hurn with his 106 average and his SC friendly role this season.

Cheers mate

I meant Hurley instead of Hibberd by the way

Starting Shaw , Bonner + 6 rookies meant I nailed the rookies (mostly) now trying to work out the premiums to target and hoping they may drop in price.

 

[Slammer]

Grundy and Zerrett vs NicNat and Heeney

 

[GrainFedBeef]

Grundy and Zerrett vs NicNat and Heeney

Grundy and Heeney look to be top 2/3 for their respective areas, do you have to choose. Whilst in isolation the combos might be similar, you may be able to catch up to Heeney in fwd line with others, whereas you will leak more points in rucks if Nic Nat doesnt close the current sizeable gap.

 

[Steuby]

Oliver Vs Macrae Vs Lachie Neale vs Zerrett for Kelly

 

[IDIG]

Oliver Vs Macrae Vs Lachie Neale vs Zerrett for Kelly

If money is not as issue and you’re grabbing them now, it would have to be Macrae or Oliver.

 

[Darkie]

Hurley (533k) vs Yeo (509k)?

 

[Johnsy44]

Coffield vs going week early on Mirra/Guelfi

 

[Professor]

Hurley (533k) vs Yeo (509k)?

Yeo if playing midfield, otherwise Hurley would be more consistent.

 

[Bomber18]

Coffield vs going week early on Mirra/Guelfi

Coffield for me but going a week early could work if you have a good plan.

 

[Bomber18]

Hurley (533k) vs Yeo (509k)?

I think Yeo for 20k cheaper isn't a bad move. He has the potential to go bigger and plays Carlton this week. Could even VC Yeo if you wanted to.

 

[teatai]

Heeney vs Yeo

either one would mean I don’t field a fwd rookie

 

[The Experiment]

Billings v Hibberd

If you were going to trade one, which would it be? Other one probably hangs around for the rest of the season

 

[Ben's Beasts]

Heeney vs Yeo

either one would mean I don’t field a fwd rookie

Heeney as he's more consistent. Reckon both will end up in most teams.

 

[Ben's Beasts]

Billings v Hibberd

If you were going to trade one, which would it be? Other one probably hangs around for the rest of the season

I think Billings is more likely to turn his season around. Last week he had 23 touches and 81 AF but poor disposal meant he didnt get a good SC score. Surely the Saints can only get better from here which will hopefully mean Billings gets better too. Reckon he starts to hit the scoreboard soon too for some extra points.

Hibberd has had a role change which has seen his disposals per game plummet. If he continues to play the same role then I think he will be an 80 SC type of player all year unfortunately.

 

[TerryB]

Billings v Hibberd

If you were going to trade one, which would it be? Other one probably hangs around for the rest of the season

Billings stats are not as bad as his scores. I would keep him.
Hibberd seems to be playing a different role this year, while this continues so will his low scores.

 

[Seedsman]

Billings v Hibberd

If you were going to trade one, which would it be? Other one probably hangs around for the rest of the season

I’d trade Hibberd. Billings can turn it around and has always been an up/down player

 

[Seedsman]

Trading Kelly this week...Coniglio v Zerrett?