Player X vs. Player Y

[The Experiment]

Trading Kelly this week...Coniglio v Zerrett?

Coniglio seems a must have and still relatively cheap...would want to see another solid score out of Zerrett and with a BE of 130, you can probably afford to wait and see

 

[Darkie]

Hurley (533k) vs Yeo (509k)?

Yeo if playing midfield, otherwise Hurley would be more consistent.

I think Yeo for 20k cheaper isn't a bad move. He has the potential to go bigger and plays Carlton this week. Could even VC Yeo if you wanted to.

Thank you both ... it does seem like Hurley is the safer bet, but that Yeo probably has the higher ceiling.

At the moment I’m erring on Hurley because it’s harder to see him being a negative POD, but this has given me some food for thought.

 

[Adrenaline]

Thank you both ... it does seem like Hurley is the safer bet, but that Yeo probably has the higher ceiling.

At the moment I’m erring on Hurley because it’s harder to see him being a negative POD, but this has given me some food for thought.

yeo will get you more points throughout the season bc i expect Hurley will miss a couple of games. if your looking at consistency hurley is the man to get. yeo scores will be up and down.

 

[whiteTiga2k]

Just quickly.

Gray+70k VS Cripps+67k VS Oliver?

 

[freowho]

Just quickly.

Gray+70k VS Cripps+67k VS Oliver?

Gray has the potential to create a bigger gap between himself and the other forwards so I would go Gray.

 

[blue dreamer]

Just quickly.

Gray+70k VS Cripps+67k VS Oliver?

I love Cripps but think he will be expected to do too much with the limited Carlton midfield especially with Murph out for 4, Gray then Oliver for mine.

 

[TommyGobbler]

Yeo v Sicily + 80k

 

[Johnsy44]

Going a week early on one

Mirra vs Guelfi

 

[Snowman]

Going a week early on one

Mirra vs Guelfi

Hard to know but I'd be wary of Guelfi facing a 4 day break going into rnd6 which you would think would mean quite a few changes to those teams. So if i was to go early on one it'd be Mirra

 

[Bomber18]

Going a week early on one

Mirra vs Guelfi

I think Mirra is the safer bet. Guelfi has a very short break post ANZAC day so there is some chance he's not on the bubble next round.

 

[Saintellica]

Brayshaw or Barry to Coffield?

 

[Zimmer]

Brayshaw or Barry to Coffield?

Think I'm going Barry.

Coniglio v Merrett v R. Gray?

 

[Bomber18]

Think I'm going Barry.

Coniglio v Merrett v R. Gray?

Merrett for me.
Value picks usually are the best ones. I think 530k now for Cogs is overs.
Gray could average 110 in the fwd line but it might only be 108 from here on in as he's at a 120 avg now.
Back in Zerrett!

 

[Saintellica]

Think I'm going Barry.

Coniglio v Merrett v R. Gray?

I have Coniglio - is in great form at the minute and hopefully more consistent point scorer than Gray. Merrett seems a risk right now with tags.

Coniglio Gray Merrett

 

[Ntay4]

McLean vs Mundy vs Acres (Or any other forward) (I have gray and heeney)

 

[Goodie's Guns]

McLean vs Mundy vs Acres (Or any other forward) (I have gray and heeney)

I think McLean is just about the next best FWD after the two you already have, even though he didn't have his best week score wise he still had low 20's for disposals from memory, and it was just his DE% in poor conditions that hurt his score.

 

[Goodie's Guns]

To trade...

Garlett (Both Mirra & Naughton on field, Holman bench)

vs.

Murphy (Holman on field, only one of Mirra & Naughton on field, will loophole)

???

If I trade Murphy I think I'll be pretty tight on funds for next weeks planned trades which include Dangerfield and Oliver in.

 

[Maccas marvels]

To trade...

Garlett (Both Mirra & Naughton on field, Holman bench)

vs.

Murphy (Holman on field, only one of Mirra & Naughton on field, will loophole)

???

If I trade Murphy I think I'll be pretty tight on funds for next weeks planned trades which include Dangerfield and Oliver in.

Murphy trade better for on field scores and Garlett for cash generation. Depends on your plan to use the cash made from a Garlett trade, does this allow you to upgrade a premium next week. If that’s the case I would move Garlett on and use Murphy as loophole until he returns

 

[blue dreamer]

More X Y Z

To replace Buddy with a keeper, who scores more for the rest of the season, Heeney, Mundy, McLean.

Really only wanted to spend what I get for Buddy but I think getting one of these three might be a better option (will just need a little more tweaking for Danger).

Edit: add (value pick) Travis Boak to the discussion please.

 

[nath_99]

Upgrade in a few weeks time..

M.Crouch vs Pendlebury for last MID spot?