Player X vs. Player Y

[Zimmer]

Simpson v Yeo?

 

[Professor]

Simpson v Yeo?

Yeo, playing in a better team, more tons than Simmo. Yeo going up by $18k this week (projected) Your $30k higher investment will net you extra equity & more consistency. Yeo can play anywhere which adds to his scoring potential.

 

[Leroy]

Merret or T Kelly on field at M8?

They're possibly even playing on each other given no Scooter to tag.

 

[XabiFernando]

Keeffe v Cumming a bit early (please don't award points for the pun).

JS critical. Cheers!

 

[Nathan]

Merret or T Kelly on field at M8?

They're possibly even playing on each other given no Scooter to tag.

Kelly.

Geelong should dominate.

 

[Leroy]

Merret or T Kelly on field at M8?

They're possibly even playing on each other given no Scooter to tag.

Kelly.

Geelong should dominate.

I know now that I've asked the question whatever choice I make will be wrong, so I'll be following that line of thought (similar to my own) and go Kelly.

 

[Seedsman]

Need to keep one of Brayshaw or Holman! Which one?

 

[telephone]

Who to start out of Ronke, Fritsch and ZGL?

 

[IDIG]

Who to start out of Ronke, Fritsch and ZGL?

Just the one of them? If so probably Fritsch for me, with Ronke a close second and ZGL a distant third.

 

[benderiffic]

Really struggling with this one guys
English to Crossley v Holman to Ronke?
Other trade is Naughton to Simmo

 

[Deeman1]

256k 19 trades

Laird, Shaw, Lloyd, Murray, Finlayson, Cole (Murphy, Keefe)
Mitchell, Fyfe, Martin, Merrett, Oliver, Cripps, Kelly, Coniglio (Brayshaw, Banfield, Garlett)
Gawn, Martin (Olango)
Lambert, Smith, Petracca, Silicy, Dunkley Fritsch (Henry, Spargo)

Finlayson to Simpson

Merrett to Danger

Garlett to Ronke

Help appreciated

 

[The Experiment]

Really struggling with this one guys
English to Crossley v Holman to Ronke?
Other trade is Naughton to Simmo

English to Crossley probably the sensible trade....English not playing, Crossley cheaper than Ronke...offers you some ruck cover

English to Crossley would be the trade i'd make

 

[Adrenaline]

256k 19 trades

Laird, Shaw, Lloyd, Murray, Finlayson, Cole (Murphy, Keefe)
Mitchell, Fyfe, Martin, Merrett, Oliver, Cripps, Kelly, Coniglio (Brayshaw, Banfield, Garlett)
Gawn, Martin (Olango)
Lambert, Smith, Petracca, Silicy, Dunkley Fritsch (Henry, Spargo)

Finlayson to Simpson

Merrett to Danger

Garlett to Ronke

Help appreciated

either option 1 or 2 for me. i think merett wont be a top 10 mid. he will have ok games and some poor games. danger will be consistent and he is really in second gear.

 

[The Experiment]

256k 19 trades

Laird, Shaw, Lloyd, Murray, Finlayson, Cole (Murphy, Keefe)
Mitchell, Fyfe, Martin, Merrett, Oliver, Cripps, Kelly, Coniglio (Brayshaw, Banfield, Garlett)
Gawn, Martin (Olango)
Lambert, Smith, Petracca, Silicy, Dunkley Fritsch (Henry, Spargo)

Finlayson to Simpson

Merrett to Danger

Garlett to Ronke

Help appreciated

Option 1 or 2 for me as well mate....sacrificing Merrett, who is proving to be somewhat inconsistent this year, to get danger into your already full midfield is probably worth the trade

 

[GrainFedBeef]

Completed Naughton to Olivier

Should I go Lycett to Grundy (has Saints, then Bulldogs, Melb and Freo which can all be harder for rucks), despite Lycett feeling like his has peaked. Rnd 12 bye is good.

or bring in Yeo for either Finlayson or Henry.

Laird Sicily Savage Doedee Finlayson Murphy (Hurley, Duman)

Danger Martin Fyfe Dusty Olivier Cripps T Kelly Spargo (J Kelly, Coffield, Barry)

Gawn Lycett McInerney

Mclean Heeney Smith Petracca. Fritsch Guelfi (ZGL, Henry)

Help appreciated. Have exact $$ to go Henry to Yeo. Henry BE 18, but needs a massive score to not have a high BE next week.

 

[Herbie66]

Completed Naughton to Olivier

Should I go Lycett to Grundy (has Saints, then Bulldogs, Melb and Freo which can all be harder for rucks), despite Lycett feeling like his has peaked. Rnd 12 bye is good.

or bring in Yeo for either Finlayson or Henry.

Laird Sicily Savage Doedee Finlayson Murphy (Hurley, Duman)

Danger Martin Fyfe Dusty Olivier Cripps T Kelly Spargo (J Kelly, Coffield, Barry)

Gawn Lycett McInerney

Mclean Heeney Smith Petracca. Fritsch Guelfi (ZGL, Henry)

Help appreciated. Have exact $$ to go Henry to Yeo. Henry BE 18, but needs a massive score to not have a high BE next week.

Hi GFB

Have you thought about Lycett - > Ryder in Rd 11 ?

I am thinking of Barry -> Phillips , Henry - > JJK for next week , surely his form and scores soon.

Doesn't help with your Yeo decision this week though, can you delay a few rounds for another cow to fatten then do 1 down , Murray - > Yeo in Rd 13.

Just a few thoughts

 

[Herbie66]

Hi GFB

Have you thought about Lycett - > Ryder in Rd 11 ?

I am thinking of Barry -> Phillips , Henry - > JJK for next week , surely his form and scores soon.

Doesn't help with your Yeo decision this week though, can you delay a few rounds for another cow to fatten then do 1 down , Murray - > Yeo in Rd 13.

Just a few thoughts

oops Finlayson not Murray

 

[Deeman1]

either option 1 or 2 for me. i think merett wont be a top 10 mid. he will have ok games and some poor games. danger will be consistent and he is really in second gear.

Option 1 or 2 for me as well mate....sacrificing Merrett, who is proving to be somewhat inconsistent this year, to get danger into your already full midfield is probably worth the trade

Cheers guys, reckon I will just take the opportunity to get Danger in, will leave enough cash to go 1 up 1 down next week.

Much appreciated

 

[Maccas marvels]

256k 19 trades

Laird, Shaw, Lloyd, Murray, Finlayson, Cole (Murphy, Keefe)
Mitchell, Fyfe, Martin, Merrett, Oliver, Cripps, Kelly, Coniglio (Brayshaw, Banfield, Garlett)
Gawn, Martin (Olango)
Lambert, Smith, Petracca, Silicy, Dunkley Fritsch (Henry, Spargo)

Finlayson to Simpson

Merrett to Danger

Garlett to Ronke

Help appreciated

Option 2..... if ever you want danger it should be this week

 

[GrainFedBeef]

Hi GFB

Have you thought about Lycett - > Ryder in Rd 11 ?

I am thinking of Barry -> Phillips , Henry - > JJK for next week , surely his form and scores soon.

Doesn't help with your Yeo decision this week though, can you delay a few rounds for another cow to fatten then do 1 down , Murray - > Yeo in Rd 13.

Just a few thoughts

Thanks Herbie. Going for league. Ryders last score encouraging, although given injuries in my team this year not sure I trust Ryder to play out the season. Nearly Brough Cruch back in last week although decided I needed to see another week from him. Hurley, Crouch, J Kelly and a host of rookie injuries have hurt this season.

No doubt I will forget all this and bring rocky in at round 11, at least in mids he can be covered easier.