Player X vs. Player Y

[Courtesans]

Yeo v McLean?

Yeo. Playing a great role.

 

[Nathan]

Yeo v McLean?

Yeo.

This will be my question in the 2019 ‘midfield’ thread.

Both to lose DPP, will be interesting to see just how low there ownership is as they look the best candidates for the annual gun selection that lost dpp.

 

[JLK5]

Bont vs Selwood?

 

[Snowman]

Yeo. Playing a great role.

Agreed. But just as importantly he's matured into a very very good player

 

[MC's Mix]

Bont vs Selwood?

Controversial perhaps, but as a Bont owner I think I'd prefer Joel! Seems to take far less effort for him to score 120s and he is almost never stuck forward. With Danger playing a higher % of game time forward, Selwood is more frequently charged with leading the mids and benefits score-wise.

Good luck either way!

 

[jaca]

Treloar replacement... Oliver, Neale or Bont?

Have:

Fyfe, Titch, Kelly, Danger, Dusty, Cripps, Zorko, Rocky (M9).

 

[freowho]

Treloar replacement... Oliver, Neale or Bont?

Have:

Fyfe, Titch, Kelly, Danger, Dusty, Cripps, Zorko, Rocky (M9).

Oliver is the least likely to be trolled by the coach.

 

[GrainFedBeef]

Treloar replacement... Oliver, Neale or Bont?

Have:

Fyfe, Titch, Kelly, Danger, Dusty, Cripps, Zorko, Rocky (M9).

Oliver is the least likely to be trolled by the coach.

Oliver easily.

Who out of Neale vs Bont. Have the first 6 above and Oliver. Going for league.

 

[freowho]

Oliver easily.

Who out of Neale vs Bont. Have the first 6 above and Oliver. Going for league.

Neale. Bont seems less reliable with Injury and playing forward.

What if you waited a week and went more podish with Sloane? I also don't mind Selwood now that he's had a week of rest.

 

[Willyorwonty]

Neale. Bont seems less reliable with Injury and playing forward.

What if you waited a week and went more podish with Sloane? I also don't mind Selwood now that he's had a week of rest.

I have Oliver, but wouldn't be averse to having Neale over him. Both well ahead of Bont.
Look at Neale's last 10 weeks.

 

[GrainFedBeef]

Neale. Bont seems less reliable with Injury and playing forward.

What if you waited a week and went more podish with Sloane? I also don't mind Selwood now that he's had a week of rest.

Sloane best at M9 given his up and down scoring pattern. Adelaide a long way from their best and taggers more prevelant this year.

I have Oliver, but wouldn't be averse to having Neale over him. Both well ahead of Bont.
Look at Neale's last 10 weeks.

agree, last 10 good.

 

[Prochard]

Treloar replacement... Oliver, Neale or Bont?

Have:

Fyfe, Titch, Kelly, Danger, Dusty, Cripps, Zorko, Rocky (M9).

Oliver easily.

 

[Prochard]

Bont vs Selwood?

Have both. Disagree with the appearance that Selwood scores easily. Can sometimes have very frustrating DT:SC ratios when his clanger count goes through the roof. Also the #1 tagged at Geelong for god knows why...

I say Bont by just.

 

[Prochard]

Yeo v McLean?

Yeo. Not considering Mclean until he shows me that he can play well against tough teams and without Macrae.

Nec minnit 155...

 

[Tamuhawk]

Pendles + De Goey Vs Kelly + Petracca + $130k.

 

[Willyorwonty]

Pendles + De Goey Vs Kelly + Petracca + $130k.

Think Pendles + De Goey looks like a nice trade given DeGoey gets more mid time with Treloar out.

Depends how settled the rest of your team is and what the cash may be used for I guess.

Would getting Lachie Neale vs Josh Kelly free up enough extra cash ($30k) in order to turn Petracca into something more meaningful?

 

[KellyMartinToNorth2018]

hurley vs webster vs howe?

 

[Tamuhawk]

Think Pendles + De Goey looks like a nice trade given DeGoey gets more mid time with Treloar out.

Depends how settled the rest of your team is and what the cash may be used for I guess.

Would getting Lachie Neale vs Josh Kelly free up enough extra cash ($30k) in order to turn Petracca into something more meaningful?

I forgot to mention the cash comes from my 2nd trade of guelfi to smith. Therefore no cash to turn petracca into anyone at all if I went treloar to Neale. (Basically have about 18k)

This probably should be in the trades thread but... It's Treloar to Pendles & 70k to turn Petracca to De Goey or any one lower. Or it was Guelfi to Joel Smith (pushing brander to fwds) and Treloar to Kelly which gives me that 130k cash. Don't think I want Neale as I've got Walters up fwd as well as Fyfe. Also this time last year I traded Neale in and got burnt really bad so I still have scars from that.

 

[MC's Mix]

hurley vs webster vs howe?

Howe > Hurley > Webster

 

[BomberSam]

hurley vs webster vs howe?

Howe > Hurley > Webster

Webster > Hurley > Howe