Strategy Round 2: Trades

Joined
16 Jun 2013
Messages
5,465
Likes
11,297
AFL Club
Adelaide
In same situation as a few here, have a few not named/playing this week including Greene, Balta, Ridley, Hore and Hately. Kicking myself for not starting Rocky as I'd pretty much locked him in. I went down a Guns and rookies approach in mids instead. Trying to figure a justifiable way to get Rocky via Greene, but have no DPP links and not too sure I really want to toss Greene so quickly. B Smith in mids may have been a mistake but will watch him go round this week. Hately may struggle to get a game soon, not sure. Ridley JS? so could go Ridley to Andrews, then Greene down to Shultz, but no forward rookie is standing out. Have no Butters or Duursma. Might just do no trades with no cover in defence or forward and see what happens next week. Could get Rock if I went Greene to Shultz and Hately to Rock.
 
Joined
19 Mar 2019
Messages
354
Likes
845
AFL Club
Richmond
In same situation as a few here, have a few not named/playing this week including Greene, Balta, Ridley, Hore and Hately. Kicking myself for not starting Rocky as I'd pretty much locked him in. I went down a Guns and rookies approach in mids instead. Trying to figure a justifiable way to get Rocky via Greene, but have no DPP links and not too sure I really want to toss Greene so quickly. B Smith in mids may have been a mistake but will watch him go round this week. Hately may struggle to get a game soon, not sure. Ridley JS? so could go Ridley to Andrews, then Greene down to Shultz, but no forward rookie is standing out. Have no Butters or Duursma. Might just do no trades with no cover in defence or forward and see what happens next week. Could get Rock if I went Greene to Shultz and Hately to Rock.
Had Greene last year,never again,even at that price. The roller coaster ride was making me sick ?. He will either get injured and/or suspended. Don’t know if Ridley is playing 2s or not today, but I have that dilemma as well,surprised he was dropped so quickly,but that worries me in regards to his JS. I’m leaning towards a trade.Parker,Drew or Setterfield would be the forward rookies to get,assuming you don’t have them.
 
Last edited:
Joined
25 Jun 2015
Messages
1,695
Likes
3,409
AFL Club
Essendon
Had Greene last year,never again,even at that price. The roller coaster ride was making me sick ?. He will either get injured and/or suspended. Don’t know if Ridley is playing 2s or not today, but I have that dilemma as well,surprised he was dropped so quickly,but that worries me in regards to his JS. I’m leaning towards a trade.
Ridley not playing in 2s. Will be at senior game I assume.
 
Joined
23 Mar 2012
Messages
223
Likes
81
AFL Club
Geelong
Anyone think that Hore will be getting back into the Melbourne side soon or was he merely a placeholder for May? Would rather keep Collins if he's getting games and get rid of Hore if he's not going to get a run anytime soon.
I'm not a Melbourne fan but I'm pretty surprised Frost kept his spot, he was terrible last week - he seems to be most weeks. Geelong are only playing 2 tall forwards so it's not a matchup thing either.
 
Joined
27 Mar 2015
Messages
4,906
Likes
5,442
AFL Club
Carlton
Turns out I forgot to trade Collins to Duursma and have planned to go Heeney and Hately to Moore and Rocky next week...
 
Joined
5 Jul 2012
Messages
3,525
Likes
5,553
AFL Club
Fremantle
Looks like I’ll need duursma and Scott...and want to keep my options open for next week...

So may be forced to do cousins to Scott this week...apart from trading a perfectly fit player, anyone see any major issue in this move?
 
Joined
7 Jan 2013
Messages
1,739
Likes
6,349
AFL Club
Hawthorn
Looks like I’ll need duursma and Scott...and want to keep my options open for next week...

So may be forced to do cousins to Scott this week...apart from trading a perfectly fit player, anyone see any major issue in this move?
I think it depends on if you need the cash to fix a structure issue next week. (For example if it allows you to get a Moore in to bolster FWD or DEF rookie scores and JS)

I went a week early on Duursma for Balta for similar reasons (running 3 rookies onfield in defense) but Balta was dropped and had an 18 in his scoreline. Even then seeing JRoo getting injured and knowing Balta will likely be back had me feeling instant trade regret.

Cousins had an ok score in Rd1 (72) compared to Scott’s (103) but they could quite easily swap scoring places today. If Scott backs up he is certainly a must have but his 103 only counts for first price rise.

So yes if the cash is needed to fix structure next week but otherwise I’d say hold if it’s just cause you think you’ve missed an early bolter rookie.

(As for my trade it seems to have turned out ok with Duursma perhaps improving his JS and port with two injuries but I was sweating on Duursma spudding it up.)
 
Joined
25 Jul 2012
Messages
47,728
Likes
107,806
AFL Club
Collingwood
Good call. Don’t trade champions
when you pay $ 660 k for a player you are probably hoping for more of last night's score.

Looking forward to seeing Geelong on TV Thursday night and seeing how their "new" midfield operates
 
Top