News Herald Sun SuperCoach Articles

Joined
9 Aug 2012
Messages
40,127
Likes
151,432
AFL Club
Carlton
Docherty would "love" to be back in 2019

Chris Vernuccio

Chris Vernuccio, Tim Michel

Carlton co-captain Sam Docherty hasn’t completely shut the door on a comeback this year but won’t put pressure on himself by setting a return date.

The injured defender had a second knee reconstruction last December after missing the entire 2018 season.

While his rehabilitation is progressing at a quicker rate compared to his previous ACL recovery, Docherty said he won’t play if he is not comfortable with how his knee has recovered.

“With ACL rehabs we don’t actually set timelines on when we’re trying to return. I think that mentally puts you in a bad headspace where you start chasing dates,” Docherty told SEN radio.

“We’re just progressing through my rehab and ticking things off. If it gets late in the year and we’ve ticked everything off and I’m training and going really well, that will be the conversation that we have later in the year.

“There’s a slight possibility and if I put myself in a position where we’re all comfortable then I might still play.

“It’s a hard one. Everyone keeps asking but I don’t have an answer. I’d love to get back out there which is probably the best answer I can get.”

Docherty said he has been running and changing directions for a couple of weeks.

Even though Docherty has been close to the action as a quasi-assistant coach on the interchange bench, he said he missed being out on the field particularly with the Blues having a couple of narrow losses.

“I feel like I want to run out there and actually play the game and impact it like I think I could be able to do.”

Docherty, meanwhile, said Carlton must be “smarter” in crunch moments after squandering winning positions against Gold Coast and Hawthorn in the past three weeks.

The Blues went down by two points to the Suns after conceding a goal with 14 seconds to play, while they led Hawthorn by six goals in the second quarter before copping a five-point defeat.

The losses either side of a win over Western Bulldogs have left Carlton with a 1-5 record as it prepares to face fellow struggler North Melbourne on Sunday.

“We are really confident in the way we are playing our footy and what we can produce week in week out in terms of a contest and putting ourselves in games,” Docherty said.

“I think the next step for our group is being a bit smarter toward the end of games and being able to get our way through and turn these small losses into wins.”

Docherty said watching the last minute from the sidelines had been “frantic” as Zac Fisher hit the post with a rushed snap which would have put Carlton level.

“Our inability to wrest momentum back throughout that third quarter when the Hawks really got a run on in the end, really hurt us,” he said.
 
Joined
9 Aug 2012
Messages
40,127
Likes
151,432
AFL Club
Carlton
North Melbourne star Majak Daw is closing in on a return to senior football

SAM EDMUND, Herald Sun

43 minutes ago

Subscriber only

Majak Daw is closing in on a return to the field this season.

Daw is nearing full pace in running drills at Arden Street, little more than four months after suffering horrific injuries in an incident on the Bolte Bridge.

A timeline has not been set for what would be one of the game’s most miraculous comebacks, but a playing return is now a realistic possibility at some stage after North Melbourne’s bye in Round 14.

Daw sustained hip and pelvic fractures when he was rescued from the Yarra River on December 17, but has constantly impressed Kangaroos officials on the journey to recovery.

REVIEW LOOMING: HEAT ON SLOW STARTING ROOS

SUPERCOACH: THE BIG TRADES YOU MUST MAKE

BAROMETER: CHECK OUT EVERY CLUB’S INJURY LIST

“He’s exceeded all our expectations and we’re extremely happy with what he’s been able to achieve in this time,” North Melbourne head physio Matt Turnbull said in April.

“We tend to see trends in different players around how they retain their muscle bulk, their flexibility and that sort of thing, but we were surprised at the speed of how he was able to retain those components.

“But he’s got a lot more steps in his rehab process. We’ve been quite meticulous … every time we give ‘Maj’ a new stimulus, it’s followed up with a close examination of his pain, his range, his strength parameters and that’s going to continue given the injuries we’ve seen.”

Daw’s teammate Jamie Macmillan told the Herald Sun recently that a Daw return would transcend football.

“I would be lying if I said I hadn’t thought about it and Maj talks about it a lot,” Macmillan said.

“It’s his end goal and if it were to happen, not only us as teammates would be in his corner.

“You would have the opposition coach and fans and whole AFL community rallying behind him. He has had his troubles but now everyone wishes him the best.”

Majak Daw in full flight. Picture: Michael KleinMajak Daw is North Melbourne training. Picture: AAP Images

Daw returned to the club on February 11 to take part in the official team photo before his return to running on an anti-gravity treadmill was celebrated by teammates and players across the competition in mid-March.

Demons star ruckman Max Gawn said it was the “best thing I’ve seen”.

By early April Daw was running on-ground.

RELATED CONTENT

Coaches: Gazza is great like his dad

Coaches: Gazza is great like his dad

Fan’s set-up claim over ‘disgusting’ sledge

Fan’s set-up claim over ‘disgusting’ sledge

“I’m very excited by this. I’ve been waiting for this for so long. Maybe I couldn’t sleep last night because of this,” Daw told the Kangaroos website.

Daw, who used an open letter in January, to state he was “blessed with a second chance at life”, is expecting his first child with partner Emily McKay.

“I hope to be back out there playing in the blue and white stripes soon,” he said.

The 28-year-old was a backline revelation in 2018 in a breakout 18-game season in a key defensive post.
 
Joined
9 Aug 2012
Messages
40,127
Likes
151,432
AFL Club
Carlton
Superstar midfielder Josh Kelly has re-signed with Greater Western Sydney on an unprecedented deal

BEN HORNE, The Daily Telegraph

40 minutes ago

Subscriber only

GWS have locked in Josh Kelly on an unprecedented deal that could make the superstar midfielder a Giant for life.

The Giants will announce on Wednesday that the most sought-after player on the AFL open market has signed a two-year contract, but The Daily Telegraph understands Kelly will have options to extend and make the deal span for anywhere between six to 10 seasons.

Kelly has sacrificed big money to remain in western Sydney in pursuit of the franchise’s maiden premiership, knocking back landmark offers from desperate Victorian clubs Carlton, St Kilda and North Melbourne.

FREE AGENT: WHY GIANTS THINK CONIGLIO WILL STAY

SUPERCOACH: THE BIG TRADES YOU MUST MAKE

BAROMETER: CHECK OUT EVERY CLUB’S INJURY LIST

There is a strong belief that Kelly’s signature will in turn help convince the Giants’ other off-contract juggernaut Stephen Coniglio to reject offers from south of the border to also commit long-term.

Kelly has been tipped by many to become the Giants’ first-ever Brownlow Medallist ever since he was picked up as a No. 2 draft pick in the 2013 draft.

At 24 years of age and with a body that’s largely kept clear of serious injury, Kelly has long been seen as one of the most prized free agency prizes in recent AFL history.

Josh Kelly has signed an unprecedented deal with the Giants. Picture: AAP Images

Provided Kelly’s enjoyment of life away from family in Sydney’s west remains where it is, it’s understood he has the option to extend to as long as 10 years at the Giants — shades of Lance Franklin’s game-changing commitment to the Harbour City.

No player in the AFL is currently contracted to 2025 aside from Richmond’s Tom Lynch, but there are various options Kelly can choose to trigger in his new deal at GWS.

Options in contracts don’t get officially lodged with the AFL, but it’s understood Giants management and Kelly’s management have covered several bases covering the long-term future in lengthy discussions behind the scenes.

Kelly would have knocked back significantly bigger offers from suitors in Melbourne who were equally confident of snaring his signature two years back when he last signed on with the Giants.

GWS believe Kelly’s commitment is an iron-clad endorsement of the culture and bond they have built in the west of the town.

If Hawthorn were to pitch to GWS’ other off-contract ace Coniglio the chance to play with Jaeger O’Meara, then the Giants have an emphatic counter in the pledge made by Kelly.

In the club’s formative years, players would look over their shoulders and feared that they could sign only to end up on their own should a mass exodus come.

But those days are gone and the Giants have locked away most of their big names to long-term deals, including Harry Himmelberg, Adam Kennedy and Matt de Boer already this year.

RELATED CONTENT

Players confront coach after wild rumour

Players confront coach after wild rumour

Outright cheating or brilliant slight of hand?

Outright cheating or brilliant slight of hand?

Giants coach Leon Cameron said on Tuesday he’s confident Coniglio will also commit.

With Josh Kelly’s deal done, the Giants will be hoping Stephen Coniglio is next. Picture: AAP Images

“Yeah I am. I don’t see any reason why not,” he said.

“Progressive talks are going well and I always say there are two parts to a negotiation. There’s the club, who want to do it ASAP and there’s the player and the manager who will take their time.

“You look for a happy medium in between and we seem to have done that over the last three or four years and I don’t see that not happening over the next month or two.”

Originally published as Locked in! Giants land Kelly with stunning deal
 
Joined
9 Aug 2012
Messages
40,127
Likes
151,432
AFL Club
Carlton
AFL SuperCoach: How to survive and thrive in during the bye rounds
Tim Michell, Herald Sun
May 1, 2019 7:30am
Subscriber only
You might be looking at the bye rounds as tomorrow’s problem.
After all, Round 12 hardly seems like an issue when you’ve got up to 10 trades to make before six teams have a week off.
ROBBO: WHY CRITICISM OF JACK SILVAGNI IS UNFAIR
RISING STAR: DUURSMA EXPLAINS ROAMING BRIAN ENCOUNTER
APPLE ISLE: DOOR OPEN FOR RIVALS TO SWOOP IN TASMANIA

But as we approach a period when many of the sought-after premiums have dropped to an enticing price, decisions on which players you bring in will determine how you navigate the trickiest three weeks of the campaign.
Jack Macrae’s absence will leave thousands of team short in midfield during Round 12. Picture: Michael Klein.
ROUND 12
Byes: Essendon, Fremantle, Hawthorn, Port Adelaide, St Kilda, Western Bulldogs
The first of the byes for 2019 doesn’t take too many of the most popular SuperCoach selections off the table. It would be around this time those with Tom Liberatore will be weighing up whether to move him on, but his numbers so far suggest he should at least get you through the bye rounds if you can afford to hold him in Round 12. The absence of Nat Fyfe and Jack Macrae will hurt some teams, while those who missed the boat on top-two forward Travis Boak will get some grace when Port Adelaide has a week off. If you still have any of Port Adelaide’s rookies — Xavier Duursma, Zak Butters, Willem Drew or Connor Rozee — Round 12 would be the time to wave goodbye to them.

TRADE TIP: Don’t target any players who will be missing in Round 13. With Patrick Dangerfield, Tim Kelly, Isaac Heeney, Max Gawn, Brodie Grundy and a host of other stars to absent, you can’t afford to be bringing in more points which will end up on your bench a week later.

TOP PLAYERS MISSING

Tom Liberatore (45.5% of teams)
Tom Rockliff (31.5% of teams)
Jack Macrae (26.3% of teams)
Nat Fyfe (23.7% of teams)
James Worpel (22.2% of teams)
Travis Boak (17.1% of teams)
James Sicily (13.3 % of teams)
Marcus Bontempelli (9.9% of teams)
Zach Merrett (5.3% of teams)
Dylan Shiel (7.4% of teams)

PREMIUMS TO TARGET

Whoever you bring in for Round 12 is going to miss one of the next two weeks. Your trade targets will ultimately come down to the structure of your team, but the popularity of Round 13 players suggests bringing in those who will be available for the first two weeks of the byes would be the best move. Josh Kelly had a delayed start to the year but has been flying since returning to the GWS Giants team, while his teammates Lachie Whitfield and Stephen Coniglio are both premium options. Rory Laird is at his likely base price heading into Round 7 and doesn’t have a bye until Round 14, while Matt Crouch is another reliable scorer who will play in Round 13. Just be mindful you won’t have access to these players in the last week of the byes.
VC/C OPTIONS

Lock in Patrick Dangerfield or Tim Kelly as VC on Friday night or use Patrick Cripps or Lachie Neale when Carlton plays Brisbane Lions on Saturday. The byes provide greater flexibility for loopholes and if you are carrying players who have a weekend off, you can use them to place your VC on a player later in the round such as Coniglio or Josh Kelly. All eyes will be on the Max Gawn-Brodie Grundy battle on the Monday of a four-day Round 12.

A round without top scorers Lachie Neale, Patrick Dangerfield, Brodie Grundy and Max Gawn is going to be tough for SuperCoaches. Picture: Chris Hyde/Getty Images.
 
Joined
9 Aug 2012
Messages
40,127
Likes
151,432
AFL Club
Carlton
ROUND 13
Byes: Brisbane Lions, Geelong, Collingwood, Melbourne, Sydney Swans, West Coast
The round most SuperCoaches are dreading. Some of the most popular and dependable picks will be missing and thousands of benches will have millions of dollars on them through the likes of Patrick Dangerfield, Max Gawn, Brodie Grundy, Isaac Heeney and Lachie Neale. This shapes as the most difficult round of the season, but if you can bank some money in preparation to bring in the likes of Travis Boak, Nat Fyfe or Jack Macrae, you’ll gain an edge over other coaches.
TRADE TIP: Prepare for this round by building your bank by downgrading to rookies with the best job security who become available from Round 7 onwards. While it’s important to be making money, you’ll need as many scoring players as you can get to maximise your score during the bye rounds.

TOP PLAYERS MISSING

Patrick Dangerfield (72% of teams)
Brodie Grundy (50.2% of teams)
Max Gawn (48% of teams)
Isaac Heeney (37.7% of teams)
Lachie Neale (34% of teams)
Jake Lloyd (32.4% of teams)
Tim Kelly (27.4% of teams)
Clayton Oliver (23.8% of teams)
Shannon Hurn (10.9% of teams)
Adam Treloar (10.4% of teams)
Tom Stewart (5.6% of teams)
Josh Kennedy (1.2% of teams)
PREMIUMS TO TARGET
Use your three trades to bring in players who have already had their bye and will be available for the rest of the season. Topscoring midfielders Nat Fyfe and Jack Macrae should be your No. 1 and No. 2 targets, while Travis Boak (forward) and James Sicily (defence) would be wise investments to bolster the other key areas of your team.

VC/C OPTIONS
Zach Merrett plays on Friday against Hawthorn, while Nat Fyfe is up against Port Adelaide on Saturday. Patrick Cripps plays against Jack Macrae’s Western Bulldogs on Saturday. With only one Sunday game, you’ll need to have made your VC pick by Saturday night. Stephen Coniglio, Josh Kelly and Lachie Whitfield will be top captain picks on Sunday when North Melbourne plays GWS Giants. Use the likes of Patrick Dangerfield or Brodie Grundy from your bench to bring Fyfe, Cripps or Macrae into play on the Saturday. If you have Grundy and Max Gawn, you can chuck the C on one of them if your vice-captain fires as they both aren’t playing.

Sam Walsh will stay in most teams until at least Round 14, when Carlton his its bye. Picture: Daniel Pockett/Getty Images.
RELATED CONTENT

Raceday focus: Tips for Warrnambool Day Two
Raceday focus: Tips for Warrnambool Day Two


‘Pudgy’ star’s ‘unthinkable’ takeover
‘Pudgy’ star’s ‘unthinkable’ takeover


ROUND 14
Byes: Adelaide, Carlton, Gold Coast, GWS Giants, North Melbourne, Richmond
Breathe a sigh of relief. Most of the popular SuperCoach premiums are back and if you planned your trades properly, you should be able to easily cover the 18 players you need to field this round. Sam Walsh will be a head scratcher as he’s posting premium numbers, but if his break even is close to his average this could be the round to part with the No. 1 pick. There’s no such option with the likes of Cripps, Whitfield, Coniglio or Kelly, who will need to sit on your bench before returning in Round 15.
TRADE TIP: With no coming byes to worry about after Round 14, use your two trades to make your team as strong as possible for the final bye of the season. If you can make three upgrades you’ll be on a winner, but adding one rookie and two top picks will be a more likely strategy for most coaches. Watch the break evens closely and if you can add a player whose price is headed north, jump on and have them rise heading toward the business end of the season.
TOP PLAYERS MISSING
Sam Walsh (73.1% of teams)
Patrick Cripps (59.3% of teams)
Brodie Smith (43.3% of teams)
Lachie Whitfield (37.7% of teams)
Rory Laird (34.9% of teams)
Stephen Coniglio (20.2% of teams)
Matt Crouch (14.1% of teams)
Rory Sloane (11% of teams)
Josh Kelly (3.4% of teams)
Ben Cunnington (1.3% of teams)
PREMIUMS TO TARGET
Take your pick. Patrick Dangerfield is understandably already in most teams, while his teammate Tim Kelly has been gaining popularity as a forward. If you’ve been eyeing Sam Menegola after his price plummeted, reward your patience by bringing him in at a snip of his starting value. This is the week to start planning for Max Gawn and Brodie Grundy if you didn’t start the ‘set and forget’ ruck duo, while Sydney’s prolific half-back flanker Jake Lloyd should be high on your shopping list. He’s looming large as the No. 1 defender again.

VC/C OPTIONS
Zach Merrett is likely to cop attention from Mark Hutchings in the first game of the round, so look elsewhere. Max Gawn will be favoured to rack up a huge score against either Rory Lobb or Sean Darcy, while Lachie Neale might cop attention from Jack Steele on Saturday but still appears a safe bet. Brodie Grundy will be a popular captaincy pick when he takes on Tim English on Sunday. Grundy scored 160 against the Bulldogs in Round 4.
 
Joined
9 Aug 2012
Messages
40,127
Likes
151,432
AFL Club
Carlton
Is the 2019 draft crop better than 2018?? Apparently so.

Western Bulldogs legend Brad Johnson says AFL clubs are salivating over this year’s draft class, which he believes could be every bit as good as the 2018 crop.

As the likes of No.1 pick Sam Walsh, Connor Rozee, Jordan Clark and Marty Hore take the competition by storm, the AFL Academy coach says his group is stacked with talent.

Leigh Montagna has said recruiters believe stars Matt Rowell and Noah Anderson will be better than Walsh, but Johnson says they are not the only ones standing out.

After the AFL made changes to its elite training camps and nationwide programs at the end of last season, Johnson says his group of youngsters pulled together in April just four days before beating the Casey Demons VFL side.

“The main thing for me is the side that beat North Melbourne’s VFL side last year (Walsh’s class), that was a really strong draft to come out of that and those boys had a number of camps together to get to know each other and play well,” Johnson said.

Matt Rowell in action for the AFL Academy against Casey. Picture: AFL Media

“This year, they were together four days and then played Casey Demons and got a win. What that does is it makes people stand up and go, ‘we mention those two guys (Rowell and Anderson), well we could have an equivalent draft coming up two years in a row with what the talent was able to produce in such a short period of time against Casey’.

“That’s where the strength is probably comparable across the group, rather than just mentioning two guys.”

Several club’s positioned themselves with high picks for last year’s draft — Gold Coast had three in the top six (Jack Lukosius 2, Izak Rankine 3 and Ben King 6) and Port Adelaide three in the top 18 (Rozee 5, Zak Butters 12, Xavier Duursma 18).

But Johnson says there will be another frenzy of draft pick trading as they clamour for the best young talent.

“With what we’ve seen and how quickly these young men adapted together to play the footy they did across the whole group, then I think everyone sits back now and goes ‘wow, we’ve got probably something special coming again’,” Johnson said.

“As the year goes on, these guys will get stronger again, play better footy so we’re in a really good position now to have a big draft.”
 
Joined
9 Aug 2012
Messages
40,127
Likes
151,432
AFL Club
Carlton
? Demons sad state.

Staggering stats reveal Melbourne has not scored from a centre clearance in past two games

Jay Clark, Herald Sun

May 1, 2019 7:39pm

Subscriber only

We thought they would be footy’s most potent force.

Entering the new season, Melbourne’s prodigiously talented wrecking ball crew in the middle of the ground loomed as the team most likely to thrive under the new six-six-six starting position rules.

You could picture Clayton Oliver and Co. thriving under the feet of Max Gawn with a little bit more space in the engine room to burst away.

AFL RETURN? BULLDOGS’ WHITTEN OVAL PUSH

BALLS UP: ELIGIBILITY RULES CLOUD MID-SEASON DRAFT

After all, they were ranked No. 1 from scores from centre clearances last year.

But, in what has become the most extraordinary stat in football, Melbourne has not registered a single score from centre clearances over the past two games.

Clayton Oliver (left) and Angus Brayshaw were expected to thrive in 2019. Pic: Getty Images

That‘s a big fat donut, from four hours of football.

Statistically, Melbourne has gone from a pack of Great White sharks to friendly seahorses in the engine room in 2019.

Overall, their scores from stoppages have slid alarmingly from 34 points to 21 points per game this season, ranked 18th in the league.

While the defence has been the big talking point for Melbourne over the first six rounds, all eyes will be on this forward half connection when the Demons try and save their ailing season against an injury-hit Hawthorn at the MCG on Saturday.

Macca’s take on the underperforming Dees.

Alastair Clarkson’s men are always well-organised behind the ball, and James Sicily and Ben Stratton love gobbling up junk ball use.

Dees’ coach Simon Goodwin was more concerned about the fundamentals of the Demons’ game in the loss to Richmond last week, adamant that “the scoring will come, I’m confident of that”.

Nine of 22 Herald Sun tipsters in the pre-season magazine picked Melbourne to win a drought-breaking flag this year, but their blade is blunt, at the moment.

This season, Melbourne has racked up the fourth-most inside forwards 50m entries, but scored from only 33 per cent of these forward forays over the first six rounds, again ranked 18th.

Gawn is still the most dominant tap ruckman in the competition, but remarkably, the Demons can’t score from a stoppage, the exact part of the game they were expected to dominate once again this season.

In many cases, the Demons’ midfielders’ accuracy by foot has plummeted this year.

Yes Melbourne like to play a high-pressure territory game, but that doesn’t excuse some of the missed targets in the early part of the season. And we know how sharp the Hawks have been by foot transitioning the ball up the ground, for more than a decade.

RELATED CONTENT

AFL dreams in jeopardy amid draft mess

AFL dreams in jeopardy amid draft mess

Rozee runs rings around the rest

Rozee runs rings around the rest

The AFL average for retaining the ball on kicks inside 50m is 47 per cent, according to Champion Data.

But the bulk of the Dees come under the league benchmark. They include prime movers Jack Viney (20 per cent), Angus Brayshaw (37), Clayton Oliver (39), Jake Melksham (42) and James Harmes and Nathan Jones (45).

Overall, the Demons are ranked 14th for kicking efficiency in the forward half.

Clearly, it’s time to sharpen up.
 
Joined
9 Aug 2012
Messages
40,127
Likes
151,432
AFL Club
Carlton
Mid Season draft calamity

Mid-season draft prospects could have their AFL dreams dashed because of eligibility rules

Sam Landsberger, Herald Sun

12 minutes ago

Subscriber only

The AFL dreams of dozens of players are in limbo because of confusion over eligibility rules for the mid-season draft.

All players hopeful of being picked up must have nominated for last year’s national draft.

But several would-be AFL players failed to do so and some believed their previous nomination was valid for three years.

A little-known criteria change enforced in 2017 means all players must now nominate annually.

DERMIE: DANGER, PENDLES LEAD MY VIC ORIGIN TEAM

PRESSURE: DEMONS URGE PATIENCE ON WEIDEMAN

West Adelaide late developer Elliot Dunkin, who is averaging 19 disposals in the SANFL, is on the radar of one AFL club but he is ineligible because he didn’t fill in last year’s form.

Other prospects new to the VFL, SANFL and WAFL this year are ineligible because they didn’t bother nominating last year when they were starring in country leagues with no hope of an AFL career.

The AFL will now consider granting special exemptions for prospects who have been left devastated by their current ineligibility.

The league must decide between breaking their own rules or leaving a bunch of young footballers devastated.

The late uncertainty means clubs are still unsure who they can draft on May 27.

“No other sport in the world operates like this,” one club figure said.

“Rules on the run … again.”

Football boss Steve Hocking has told disgruntled player managers he will look into the “anomaly”.

A memorandum sent to clubs by AFL integrity officer Ken Wood, and obtained by the Herald Sun, reveals players put on rookie lists this month will bank $70,000 without playing a game.

The battlers will receive a base salary of $50,000 plus a further $20,000 if they are not retained on any AFL list in 2020.

They will pocket about $4500 a match, spiking potential earnings to around $150,000 for four months of work.

Clubs do not believe Sydney has priority access to Kyle Dunkley as a father-son, but there was no official clarification in Wood’s rules.

Kurt Tippett is poised to sign a retirement form, giving the Swans a pick.

AFL footy boss Steve Hocking has told player managers he will look into the mid-draft “anomaly”. Picture: Getty Images

Dunkley completed a VFL pre-season with Footscray and is averaging 18.5 disposals, eight tackles, 4.5 clearances, 1.3 goals and 123 SuperCoach points as a 19-year-old for Gippsland Power.

The hard worker, and brother of premiership Dog Josh, is a being considered by some clubs.

Recruiters will exploit the concept, affecting an already-lean talent pool in 2019.

They want to get the jump on November’s national draft by pumping six months of development into teenagers such as Dunkley or Mitch Riordan (Dandenong Stingrays).

But the AFL wanted clubs to grab, for example, a mature ruckman if they had lost multiple big men.

State-league players are unlikely to make an impact in 2019 given their lower fitness bases and requirement to learn new game plans.

Players cut at the end of the season will become delisted free agents. They have until 5pm tomorrow to nominate online.

The AFL will run medical tests on May 22 and the draft will be run in reverse ladder order after Round 10.

Most clubs are set to use a pick.

THE AFL’S MEMO TO CLUBS

Please note that nominations for the 2019 Mid-Season Rookie Draft open at 9am (EST) on Monday 29th April and close at 5pm (EST) on Friday 3rd May.

RELATED CONTENT

Lugg, Riley headed for northern exposure

Lugg, Riley headed for northern exposure

Bulldogs bid to bring footy back to Whitten Oval

Bulldogs bid to bring footy back to Whitten Oval

All nominations are to be completed online only. Please note that Draft Nominations for the Mid-Season Rookie draft DO NOT carry over to the 2019 NAB AFL Draft.

Player Eligibility to Nominate

The following eligibility criteria applies to Players nominating for the Mid-Season Rookie Draft:

• Players must have previously nominated for the most recent National Draft

Note: A Player who nominated for and was not selected during the Draft and who has committed for a further year as a 19-year-old Northern or NGA Academy Player is an exception and is not eligible for selection in the SSP

OR

• Players must have previously been on the list of an AFL Club (not required to nominate for the previous Draft) refers tothe following situations: o A Delisted Player

Note: A Player delisted by a Club cannot be reselected in the 2019 Mid-Season Rookie Draft by the same Club in the period immediately following their delisting.

• A Retired Player and/or a Player who has delisted himself and has not been on an AFL List for one Football Year or more. Eg, Cyril Rioli retired in 2018, and therefore is not eligible to be selected in the 2019 Mid-season Rookie Draft as he did not nominate for the most recent National Draft.
 
Joined
9 Aug 2012
Messages
40,127
Likes
151,432
AFL Club
Carlton
Fantasy Freako’s Round 7 Form Guide: Whose ruck-mid connection is strongest?

Fantasy Freako, Herald Sun

an hour ago

Subscriber only

Rucks and midfielders are the scoring bread and butter of every SuperCoach team, but which club’s combination offers you a path to competition gold?

Champion Data’s Fantasy Freako looks at the best ruck-midfield combinations with the best connections in the game in this week’s Form Guide.

SUPERCOACH WHISPERS: WHAT YOU MIGHT HAVE MISSED

TRADE GUIDE: HOLD FIRE ON THESE STARS

Which club’s ruck-mid twosome synchs up best at stoppages?

Gathers from a hitout (a possession gained from a teammate’s hitout-to-advantage) are one of several statistics that fall under the contested possession umbrella.

It is also a statistic that rewards two players — the ruckman with a hitout-to-advantage and the player that wins the contested possession. It should be no surprise to anyone that midfielders dominate this metric, as they are at the feet of the ruckmen at the stoppage.

The No.1 SuperCoach player in the competition, Lachie Neale is the king of the gathers from hit-outs this season with 27 — three more than Ben Cunnington. Tom Rockliff (21) and Clayton Oliver (20) rank third and fourth in that order, while there are a host on 18, one of which is Brayden Fiorini — a real surprise packet of 2019.

Custom table

PlayerClubGamesGathers from a hitoutSuperCoach AVGLachie NealeBrisbane627136Ben CunningtonNorth Melbourne624113Tom RockliffPort Adelaide621103Clayton OliverMelbourne620101Touk MillerGold Coast61895Angus BrayshawMelbourne61898Dom SheedWest Coast61893Brayden FioriniGold Coast618103Patrick CrippsCarlton617129Jaeger O'MearaHawthorn517101

If we look at the best ruck-rover combination after six rounds — Todd Goldstein and Cunnington have combined more than any other duo (21 times) — with Stefan Martin and Neale not too far behind on 19. Max Gawn has both and third and fourth places covered, with Angus Brayshaw (17) and Oliver (16) the beneficiaries of his tap work. Rounding out the top-five is Jarrod Witts/Fiorini (15).

At centre bounces, the clear standout is Ben McEvoy and Jaeger O’Meara — combining on 10 occasions. The fact that O’Meara has missed one match makes this even more impressive. With Tom Mitchell sidelined, O’Meara is the one player that has benefited the most at Hawthorn — improving his disposals (+7), contested possessions (+4) and points per game (+8).

There is a three-way tie at ball up stoppages, with Gawn/Brayshaw, Martin/Neale and Goldstein/Cunnington all combining seven times. The Witts/Fiorini combination is next best with six.

Brodie Grundy has come into his own at throw in stoppages, combining with Scott Pendlebury and Steele Sidebottom seven times. Gawn/Oliver have also combined seven times at throw ins.

Marty Hore has become a key figure at Melbourne and you can play him on the field with confidence. Picture: David CroslingROOKIE WATCH

There results were mixed last round, with Marty Hore (86), Charlie Constable (79), Jack Ross (89) and Xavier Duursma (84) posting decent numbers. Sam Collins (66) and Jack Scrimshaw (62) were in-betweens, while Tom Atkins (47), Michael Gibbons (51) and Jack Petruccelle (48) were all underwhelming.

Once again, moving on cash cows at the right time will once again be at the forefront for SuperCoaches. Collins (70 BE) is perhaps the only player you’d consider trading out this week, so if you’re cashed up, then that is the most obvious move to make. You could also trade him down to one of the bubble boys ahead of Round 7 — Lachlan Young (-24 BE) should he retain his place in the side.

I definitely wouldn’t go early on one-gamer Noah Answerth, even though he looked right at home in Brisbane’s defence on his AFL debut — scoring 69 points. Zac Bailey is nearing a return from injury which could see Answerth get squeezed out. Either way, just wait one more week.

The No.1 trade-in target this round is the mature-aged Will Hayes. He has scored 70 and 55 points from his two games and already has a SuperCoach ownership nearing 6,000. The Bulldogs have moved Jason Johannisen back into defence to accommodate Hayes, with the latter spending 87% of game time on the wing — the second-highest percentage of any Bulldog behind Lachie Hunter.

Elsewhere, this could also be the week we finally offload Noah Balta — even though such a move will cost us $10,200 — with Mitch Lewis the target. Lewis ranks No.1 at the Hawks for inside 50 targets across the past two rounds, with only Paul Puopolo winning more disposals inside 50. It’s definitely one move to ponder.

Western Bulldogs young gun Will Hayes is the top rookie on the bubble this week. Picture: Michael KleinPLAYERS TO WATCHCOLLINGWOOD VS PORT ADELAIDE

In the past three rounds, Brodie Grundy averages 132 points — ranked No.1 in the competition. Travis Boak has led the Port Adelaide charge over this period with 119 points per game — ranked eighth.

MELBOURNE VS HAWTHORN

Max Gawn posted scores of 112 and 125 points in his two games against Melbourne last season. Ben McEvoy had mixed results, scoring 49 and 109 points in these games.

GREATER WESTERN SYDNEY VS ST KILDA

Tim Taranto won a career-high 17 contested possessions last round on his way to a season-high 136 points. Sebastian Ross had his first price rise of the season after scoring 118 against Adelaide.

BRISBANE LIONS VS SYDNEY SWANS

Lachie Neale averages 146 points in Brisbane wins this season — ranked No.1 in the AFL. Isaac Heeney scored a season-high 137 points in Sydney’s only win of 2019 against Carlton.

WESTERN BULLDOGS VS RICHMOND

Tom Liberatore suffered his first price drop of the season after scoring a season-low 71 points in the loss to Fremantle. Dustin Martin’s value plummeted for the third time in 2019 — dropping by $10,300 after scoring 89 points.

RELATED CONTENT

Star signs monster, ‘revolutionary’ deal

Star signs monster, ‘revolutionary’ deal

Lynch: Talent will only get you so far

Lynch: Talent will only get you so far

Can Dusty turn his SuperCoach season around? Picture: Alex CoppelWEST COAST EAGLES VS GOLD COAST SUNS

Andrew Gaff had 32 disposals, two score assists and 103 points when these sides last met in Round 4 last season. David Swallow had a blinder for the Suns, finishing with 29 disposals and 129 points — his highest score against the Eagles.

CARLTON VS NORTH MELBOURNE

Sam Walsh’s price has boomed by $236,300 this season — the biggest of any player in the competition. Ben Brown’s value has gone the other way (-$78,300) after averaging just 61 points.

GEELONG CATS VS ESSENDON

Tim Kelly has racked up 106 and 129 points from his two matches at the MCG this season. Zach Merrett averages 30 disposals and 121 points at the venue this season which is a career-high tally.

ADELAIDE CROWS VS FREMANTLE

Brodie Smith has reached three figures in each of his past three games, rising in price by $35,400 last round with a score of 103 points. David Mundy celebrated his 300th AFL match in style — scoring 122 points.
 
Joined
9 Aug 2012
Messages
40,127
Likes
151,432
AFL Club
Carlton
Coaches reveal top tactics to save their SuperCoach seasons

May 1, 2019 9:01pm

Tim MichellHerald Sun

You can spend hours planning the perfect SuperCoach team, poring over JLT Series statistics and pre-season injury news, only for disaster to strike weeks later.

If, like me, you find yourself outside the top 25,000 coaches, it’s easy to despair.

However, a quick check of the rankings shows how swiftly our seasons could be salvaged.

The gap between the top 1000 and 5000th is just 171 points, while 5000 to 10,000th are only separated by 101 points.

That’s the equivalent of getting a captain’s pick right when others don’t or turning a rookie into a premium a few weeks before the coaches ahead of you in the pack do.

If you’re desperate to turn your season around and stay in the race for league or rankings glory, there are several ways to start climbing.

SUPERCOACH ROUND 7 TRADE GUIDE: WHY YOU MUST GET NAT FYFE

SURVIVAL GUIDE: HOW TO NAVIGATE THE BYES IN SUPERCOACH

AFL 2019: WHY JOSH KELLY KNOCKED BACK VICTORIAN MEGA OFFERS

You can aggressively trade, bringing in premium options quickly but risking disaster late in the year if injuries strike.

Alternatively, you can back in those you started with to discover their best form, banking trades to making a surge during the byes or when others run out.

Here’s three tactics I plan to use, and the strategies of 12 other coaches who have battled through the first six rounds.

MY TEAM

Name: Stocker Exchange

Current rank: 50,844

Best overall season rank: Top 2000-3000

Three tactics to climb rankings:

— Prioritise consistency: I can’t afford to be up and down every two weeks if I’m going to rise from outside the top 50,000. It’s why I’m targeting Caleb Daniel, who hasn’t scored below 93, this week.

— Get forward rookies off field: This year’s crop of forward rookies have been too inconsistent — bar Willem Drew and Gryan Miers — to be on our fields much longer.

— POD vice-captains: The captain loophole gives you two cracks at the perfect double score and you can gain an edge if you pick right with a player most other coaches don’t have.

Matt Parker is one of the top upgrade options in the forward line for most coaches. Picture: Michael Klein.

YOUR STRATEGIES

First name: Josh

Team Name: Ham & Cheese Rioli

Current Rank: 37,267

Best season rank: inside the top 1000 (years ago)

Three tactics to climb rankings:

— Ship out underperforming forwards such as Matt Parker and Jack Petrucelle.

— Get Jake Lloyd in before the bye rounds.

— Bring Tim Kelly in this week.

First name: Dan

Team name: Batten Above Avg

Current rank: 33,760

Three tactics to climb rankings:

— Trade in rolled-gold premiums

— My mistakes from the outset were trading in pseudo-premium players like James Worpel and Tom Liberatore and starting Jack Steele. From now, I’ll be asking myself, “will this player be a top eight in their position at the end of the year?” before I make my move. Value options in this category — Lachie Whitfield and Tim Kelly — will come.

— Nailing vice-captain and captain choices. I didn’t place as much importance on this in the early rounds, getting sucked into players that had their games early in the round. Over the past three weeks choosing Grundy (160, and Gawn (126 and 145) has seen me rise up the rankings.

First name: Sam

Team name: ScottishKings

Current rank: 42,889

Best season rank: 8,898 (2015)

Three tactics to climb rankings:

— Analyse the top-10 in each position and identify who is a must have! My ‘must-haves’ are players ranked first and second. Four or five of the top-ranked teams have Max Gawn, Brodie Grundy, Lachie Neale, Patrick Cripps and Travis Boak. Every week that players I don’t have score 120+ is another week I’m leaving points on the table and falling behind. Outside of hopefully attaining as many of those names quickly, I’ll look at lower ownership players to improve my ranking.

— Focus on my team structure for the bye rounds, by having 18 (possibly 20) scoring players each round.

— Identify AFL teams with a good draw coming up, such as GWS until Round 12.

Tim Kelly is a top upgrade target up forward after falling to his base price. Picture: Alison Wynd.

First name: James

Team name: JimmyD

Current rank: 34,974

Three tactics to climb rankings:

— Using the VC/C and non-playing loophole.

— Trading rookies in before their price rises to generate maximum money for upgrades.

— Fielding rookies with a higher-scoring average. (For example if the last playing position is between two rookies, field the rookie with a higher avg. Not chase previous weeks score. An example was last weekend when I weighed up Michael Gibbons v Charlie Constable. Gibbons scored 100+ in previous round where as Constable was returning from a rest. I trusted Constable due to his superior average.

First name: Tim

Team name: Wooly’s Winners

Current rank: 46,704

Best season rank: 1,485

Three tactics to climb rankings:

— Aggressive trade from here until the byes, potentially using most of my trades and saving only a couple for injuries. Try to complete my team quicker than normal.

— Hold trades. No sideways trades for current underperforming premiums (such as Jack Darling).

— Alternatively, you could keep upgrading as normal and hope team comes good. However, it is risky and could leave a lot of work to do late.

First name: Lekdog

Team name: Lekdog’s Puppies

Current rank: 41,617

Best season rank: 2656

1. POD’s got me into this mess and PODs will get me out of it! I’ll target players who are performing well but are in less than 10% of teams!

2. Maximise rookie profit! I’ve actually traded well in terms of rookie management (although no Sam Walsh killed me) so I’ll continue to get the most out of these guys and only jump off them when the perfect fallen premo or juicy rook is ready to be pounced on.

3. Do a better job with my VC! I need to do some creative VC work to catch up with the pack but not be greedy in the process. Most people go Grundy VC/Gawn C but I need to be better! Does my POD VC average 110 against Geelong? Does my POD VC dominate in the wet? Is my POD VC untouchable in Perth? These are the questions I need to consider!

First name: Darrell

Team name: Picken From Behind

Current rank: 25,291

Best season rank: About1900

Three tactics to climb rankings:

— Maximise the rookies and wait for the fallen premiums to reduce the cash I need.

— Picking that point of differences will be the key to the rise. I’m looking at you Daniel Rich.

— Not wasting trades will be a huge factor come later in the year, when coaches start choosing to rest their stars.

Name: Josh

Team name: Oraziooooooo

Current rank: 52,365

Best rank this year: 31,133

Three tactics to climb rankings:

— Make a call on rookies who are starting to hit their ceiling. Use the cash to upgrade some of my midfield to get high-performing premiums.

— Start using the bench loophole more effectively. Too many times I’ve had a good score from a player that I can’t get on the ground.

— Avoid sideways trades. Back your players (unless they sustain a long-term injury) to prevent burning too many trades unnecessarily.

Caleb Daniel is a point of difference option who has scored consistently. Picture: Michael Klein.

Name: Lochie

Team Name: SharpShooting

Current Rank: 35,268

Best Season Rank: 6,409 (2017)

Three tactics to climb rankings:

— Prepare for the bye rounds, because it’s a great time to jump unprepared players.

— Take risks by adding one or two points of difference.

— Maximise points through loopholes as much as possible, such as emergency and vice-captain, to avoid losing easy points.

Name: Damien

Team name: Soul Star

Current rank: 32,661

Best tactic to climb rankings:

— Log the top 10 players in each position, looking at the point of difference players and upgrade my mid pricers to get them in at their bottom price. Fyfe comes in this week and Tim Kelly soon, taking byes into account. I’m also considering points of difference Tom Stewart, Zak Jones and Caleb Daniel.

First name: Liam

Team name: The Tough Bretts

Current rank: 36,656

Best season rank: About 8000

Three tactics to climb rankings:

— Trading aggressively to get players like Jack Petruccelle off field, even if they still have money to make.

— Upgrading to points of difference where sensible to try to make ground up on the competition when popular players have a down week.

— Not overpaying for top premiums such as Travis Boak, Lachie Whitfield and Jake Lloyd, so I can stretch my upgrade budget further. I’ll be going Jack Scrimshaw to Daniel Rich this week so it leaves enough cash to move Tom Atkins to James Sicily.

First name: Sam

Team name: Bragsy’s Dons

Current rank: 46,918

Best overall rank: 2609 (2016)

Three tactics to climb rankings:

— Use the bye rounds to your advantage. A fair amount of people start to drop off then and that’s when you can climb the rankings by planning ahead.

— Never trade your premos. You have put them in your team for a reason so stick by them!

— Hold your cash cows as long as you can to generate every cent you can get your hands on, which can then be used to upgrade to premium players.
 
Joined
9 Aug 2012
Messages
40,127
Likes
151,432
AFL Club
Carlton
Nice work Blues - HS Live Feed

The stat which proves Blues improvement

Tim Michell

Tim Michell

It is often said that percentage is the greatest indicator of a side's improvement.

While Carlton fans have been left to lament close losses to Hawthorn and Gold Coast in the past three weeks, the Blues' percentage of 93.6 is the fifth-best of any 1-5 side in AFL history.

Essendon (2006, 96.3) and Melbourne (1984, 97.1) are the only clubs since 1927 to boast a better percentage with a 1-5 record after six rounds.

The Bombers' 1927 team was 97.8 per cent at Round 6 despite losing five games, dropping five successive matches by a combined 54 points after a 47-point Round 1 win.

Geelong (1908, 94.2 per cent) rounds out the top five.

"Like all Bluebaggers, we don't like any loss," coach Brendon Bolton said after the club's five-point defeat against Hawthorn in Tasmania.

"All the players are dirty, we're dirty. You have got to learn these lessons.

"There's lots to like, but we have got to be able to adjust in games and we failed to do so in the third (quarter)."

Carlton has not finished with a percentage above 80 since 2014, logging 64.8 per cent, 79.3, 78.2 and 59.3 in the past four seasons.

Brisbane Lions went from 18th and a percentage of 74.3 in 2017 to 89.1 and 15th last year, the start of their emergence as a finals contender.

Similarly, Melbourne finished with a percentage of 77 in 2015, 97.6 in 2016 and 105.2 in 2017 before rising to a preliminary final last year.

Champion Data stats reveal the extent of Carlton's improvement, adding an average of 14.5 points per game to its score (61.5 to 76) this year and climbing from 18th for points from stoppages (20.4) to second (35.7).

Jack Silvagni (3.9 to 13.5), Ed Curnow (3.6 to 12.3) and David Cuningham (2.4 to 9.0) have recorded the greatest increase in their scoreboard output.

Harry McKay, Cam Polson and Sam Petrevski-Seton are others who have had greater impact in the attacking half.
 
Joined
9 Aug 2012
Messages
40,127
Likes
151,432
AFL Club
Carlton
AFL SuperCoach Round 7 trade ratings: Western Bulldogs bubble boy Will Hayes in demand, Zak Butters on chopping block

Tim Michell and Al Paton, Herald Sun

5 minutes ago

Subscriber only

Zak Butters, Will Hayes, Tom Liberatore and Nat Fyfe are names which feature prominently in this week’s top-10 trades.

It is the stage of the season where coaches are looking at punting underperforming rookies for fallen premiums and Fyfe tops the list of options this week after dropping below $600,000.

Western Bulldogs mature-age recruit Will Hayes is the best of the bubble boys, but which rookie should you be sacrificing to bring him in?

AL PATON AND TIM MICHELL RATE THE TOP 10 TRADES OF ROUND 7

Zak Butters to Will Hayes (2031 trades)

Al: Hayes is the clear standout of this week’s bubble boys and while Butters should make his break even of 27 this week, he’s close to his peak price. Tick.

Tim: Butters still has more money to make with a break even of 27, but you shouldn’t lose out on much value by punting him. He’s scored 23 and 46 in the past three weeks and isn’t the on-field option we planned for. Bench him if you can until he reaches top dollar, although Hayes is a decent replacement.

Tom Atkins to Will Hayes (1980 trades)

Al: Similar equation to above with Atkins projected to increase in value by $12,000 this week then hit the wall in terms of value.

Tim: After two scores above 60 and some solid cash generation, Atkins dropped back to 47 against West Coast. His break even is only 25 so you can hold him for another week, but much like Butters you won’t miss out on much money by moving him on. You’d be happy to trade him before the byes as he misses in Round 13.

Western Bulldog Will Hayes is the most popular trade target this week. Picture: Quinn Rooney/Getty Images.

Bailey Scott to Will Hayes (982 trades)

Al: If Scott isn’t recalled this week it makes sense to have a rookie in that spot who is scoring points and gaining value instead. But you won’t make much money on the deal ($55k).

Tim: Wait and see on this week’s teams. I’m of the opinion we should hold Bailey Scott if he isn’t named, as playing Sunday presents the perfect chance to use him as a midfield loophole. You could make a Port Adelaide rookie emergency on Friday, then put Scott on field if they score more than 60. If he’s named, I’m not certain he holds the same value and trading him to Hayes makes sense.

BATTLING: HOW 12 COACHES PLAN TO SAVE THEIR SUPERCOACH SEASON

GOSSIP: TEAM WHISPERS YOU NEED FOR SUPERCOACH

SHOCK CONTENDER: THE POWER STAR RATED A BROWNLOW CHANCE

EXCLUSIVE: DOGS UNVEIL GRAND PLAN TO BRING AFL BACK TO WEST

Sam Collins to Tim Kelly (796 trades)

Al: This looks like a quirk of the SuperCoach site and the trade is Collins to a rookie and a forward rookie to Kelly. Regardless it’s the trade of the week for me. At $476k he’s a huge bargain.

Tim: Another trade which makes complete sense. Kelly has shown all the trademarks of a top-four forward, bar his one blemish when he carried an ankle injury and was tagged by Matt De Boer. His inclusion takes one of the inconsistent forward rookies off field which is another bonus.

Sam Collins to Tim Kelly or Nat Fyfe will be the best trade of Round 7. Picture: Quinn Rooney/Getty Images.

Sam Collins to Nat Fyfe (770 trades)

Al: Sam Collins has crossed the threshold where his break even is higher than his average, so it’s time to go. If he can get you to Fyfe, go for it.

Tim: A thousand times yes. Collins has reached his maximum price and Fyfe has fallen to his base price. This trade has huge upside.

Jordan Clark to Noah Answerth (763 trades)

Al: Red flag! Answerth looked good on debut but trading in a rookie after one game is fraught with danger. Doesn’t make much money anyway.

Tim: The expectation is Clark will return for the Cats this week and I’m inclined to hold. Answerth was impressive on debut, but I’d prefer to bring him into midfield to have the ability to swing Xavier Duursma via their Def-Mid eligibility. Unless it means missing out on a fallen premium such as Nat Fyfe, hold off a week on Answerth. One quiet game and you could have a rookie sitting on your bench at his starting price who plays NEAFL for the rest of the year.

Zak Butters to Noah Answerth (674 trades)

Al: See my reservations about Answerth above. Get Bulldog Lachie Young ($120k) instead.

Tim: As above, I don’t mind trading Answerth in as a midfielder. Butters has just about run his race and bringing in Answerth could enable you to field Xavier Duursma as a midfielder. Make sure you check your bye structure though, as Brisbane Lions have the week off at the same time as the popular premiums from Collingwood, Melbourne, Sydney and Geelong.

Thousands of coaches are happy to take the punt on Noah Answerth after one game. Picture: AAP Image/Richard Waugh.

Jack Scrimshaw to Noah Answerth (641 trades)

RELATED CONTENT

Carnage as NBA superstars injured

Carnage as NBA superstars injured

Insanely ripped star’s crazy body change

Insanely ripped star’s crazy body change

Al: Why no love for Young? His scores haven’t been amazing (42, 52) but if he’s your last bench defender the only thing that really matters is he’s getting a game. Should rise $32k next week.

Tim: Scrimshaw has a tendency to run hot and cold, as we saw against Carlton when he had 50 points at halftime and finished with 62. He’s averaging 70 and should meet his break even of 58, but if he’s the difference between a top premium and a risky prospect, cash him in now. The only issue is Answerth (one game) and possibly West Coast’s Josh Rotham (pending selection) will be the only defensive downgrades in Round 7.

Tom Liberatore to Will Hayes (571 trades)

Al: Reverse! This would be a one-down, one-up trade where getting Hayes gives you enough cash to go from Libba to a top-liner like Nat Fyfe. But despite Libba’s low score last week the points gain just isn’t worth it. If you don’t think Libba is a keeper trade him around the byes when he’ll be valued at well over $500k.

Tim: Don’t trade Libba yet. He might have scored below 100 in the past two weeks, but he’s still doing enough to justify being in your midfield. Most coaches get spooked when a player starts to lose value, but it will only take one game where he replicates his efforts from Round 2 (128) or Round 3 (150) to send his price north of $500,000. You should plan to at least hold him until the byes.

Dockers captain Nat Fyfe is the top premium target of Round 7 after falling to under $600,000. Picture: Mark Stewart.

Tom Liberatore to Nat Fyfe (569 trades)

Al: See answer above. If it’s the only way to get Fyfe look at Laird or Tim Kelly instead where you’re trading out your lowest scoring players not a borderline premium.

Tim: I don’t mind this. If you have to trade Tom Liberatore, it should be as an upgrade, and Fyfe is the pick of the options this week due to his break even of 90. The preferable option should be holding onto Libba though.
 
Top