Strategy Round 13: Trades

[bloke]

Genuinely considering holding Hore over Brodie Smith.

Chances are I won't be able to upgrade both, and Hore is definitely the better prospect at the moment

 

[BomberSam]

Supercoach is OPEN!

 

[quite ironic]

Out: Clark, Answerth, Balta
In: Naish, Clarke, Daniel

 

[Connoisseur]

N Answerth to R Gray locked in.
T Atkins assured to be traded but decision will be whether to grab
Bewley this week and D Clarke next week (replacing Setterfield) allowing L Baker to J Dunkley this week
or
D Clarke this week and P Naish/J Hately next week replacing Setterfield and B Smith to L Ryan this week.

In regards to R Gray excluding his injury affected score against Fremantle last year he has averaged 120.5 from his prior 8 matches against Fremantle since 2011 with 5/8 120+.

 

[Lynchmond]

Any love for Naish? Looks like a decent downgrade option if he keeps his spot. Job security looks sceptical, though I was impressed with his debut. Think he plays this week, though whether he plays enough to make cash is up for debate.

 

[Eagling]

With Darling, Clark and Answerth out and Naish in I have 890k to spend over two players.


Very uncertain on if I should grab a couple of budget options or spend the money on a $500k+ premium and save $$$ for another upgrade next week.

Considering players like Robbie Gray, Connor Blakely, Caleb Daniel, Travis Boak, Rowan Marshall, James Sicily and Lachie Weller, though the preference is definitely towards a round 12 premium. Any suggestions who is the pick of the bunch from the Round 12 bye premiums - including those unlisted.

 

[Tamuhawk]

Out: Smith, Stack & Larkey
In: Fyfe, Boak & Bewley

11k leftover.

Gives me 19 players but that's only assuming Rocky comes back and Young isn't dropped.

 

[BomberSam]

So big Chazzy Dixon bagged 5 in the SANFL over the weekend (and Wines got 32 touches).

Port fans, will Chaz come straight back in? And if so, will it fix the Hoff?

 

[Bomber18]

Not sure whether to take Macrae with a 150 BE or wait a week. The alternative would be taking Blakely.

Thinking that maybe it’s better to wait a week on Blakely to see role and just hope Macrae hits a 130 against the Blues

 

[Rumbler]

ROB --> Bines
Hore --> Sicily
Balta --> Dunkley

These plans will get scrapped if ROB is named. I'd rather have a ruck on the field.

 

[<actus]

I’d made up my mind that Ziebell was not the answer for D6. Then Higgins goes down with an AC joint and I’m wondering if Ziebell might look good at D6 after all.

Also in consideration - Westhoff at 360K now that Charlie Dixon is back ...

 

[Woodsey]

Out: Atkins, Balta, Clark
In: Boak, Ryan, Bewley

With these trades look like Ill field 17 which Scott, Hately, Whitfield all likely not playing. I really wanted to get rid of Answerth and could trade him in for Boak but with a Balta BE of 106, Im not sure which way to lean and two game average of 38 it looks like he is back to his old ways.

 

[pizza safety]

Either

Hore -> Luke Ryan
Liam Baker -> Caleb Daniel
Stocker -> Dylan Clarke

Leaves Brodie Smith, Duursma and Walsh to upgrade

or

Jordan Clark -> Naish
Brodie Smith -> Luke Ryan
Stocker -> Dylan Clarke

Leaves Duursma and Walsh to upgrade with the possibility of keeping Hore at D6. I'm not convinced Hore is good enough to keep is the issue.

 

[Herbie66]

Don't think I will trade (at this stage)

Have 19 available but that includes :-

Gardner , Setterfield , Scott , Hayden , Burgess & Young

Hopefully Rocky is right to go.

Mummy is becoming my biggest issue , may need to just use Westhoff as my R2 instead

 

[Nathan]

I have no idea how I’m going to finish my team..still Hore, Duursma, Walsh, M8, L.Baker on field rookies.

Only 11 trades and not much cash..Heeney and Mrouch are perfect butt not ideal this week.

 

[BlueNwhiteHoops]

No doubt

Logue plays out the year in the Freo 22 assuming he remains fit...like you say, that's the big question mark though

The other question mark is his scoring, I read preseason that he was a terrible scorer in the 2nd's averaging like 40-60.
I remember thinking, gee, if that's all he can average in the 2nd's he mustn't play a very friendly SC role and he is 160k!

 

[Courtesans]

Atkins, Baker /Clarke, Boak.

 

[whiteTiga2k]

At the moment

Answerth to Sicily
Balta to Boak

How would you rank these though. Boak VS Walters+25k VS Heeney+70k

Att hat price I'm considering bringing Heeney in next week anyway... And playing Kelly or danger midfield. Thoughts?

 

[IDIG]

At this stage
Out: Hore, Answerth, Baker
In: Sicily, Gardner, Blakely/Hurley

Not especially excited about either Blakely or Hurley but grabbing them allows me to bring Telly in for the run home.

 

[PlaymakerX]

I must have no idea about SuperCoach despite being top 9k lol but I am nowhere near fielding 20 as some of you are suggesting, just wasn’t enough options I liked based round this bye round.