Rucks Discussion
- Thread starter Impromptu
- Start date
I was wondering about this, can't think of too many that might move, was some discussion that Mumford and Swans were having difficulty sorting out a contract, would move Pyke to 1st Ruck but not sure if I could bring myself to pick him.
Bellchambers to GWS could be good for him and good for Ryder but would be tough to pick either unless they are significantly cheaper than other options.
Bellchambers to GWS could be good for him and good for Ryder but would be tough to pick either unless they are significantly cheaper than other options.
Port supporter and I have no love for Lobbe in Supercoach.
We have Renouf and Redden also on the list.
When Lobbe gets to play as the only ruckmen he can score big but I can't see him playing 18 plus games as the only ruckmen which I think he needs before you can pick him in Supercoach.
I don't think they can ask Westhoff to play a whole year as the back up ruckmen, his year has really slowed down since they stopped playing two recognised ruckmen. Problem is none of our ruckmen can play forward at all.
We have Renouf and Redden also on the list.
When Lobbe gets to play as the only ruckmen he can score big but I can't see him playing 18 plus games as the only ruckmen which I think he needs before you can pick him in Supercoach.
I don't think they can ask Westhoff to play a whole year as the back up ruckmen, his year has really slowed down since they stopped playing two recognised ruckmen. Problem is none of our ruckmen can play forward at all.
- Joined
- 21 Mar 2012
- Messages
- 4,277
- Likes
- 6,648
- AFL Club
- Carlton
This is also my hope and was this year but this comment has made me look at my rucks this year and they have been actively traded, 7 trades is definitely not set & forget.
R3 Kommer to Leuey (301k) (via Blicavs DPP)
R6 Jacobs to B Hill (again via Blicavs link)
R10 Leuey (449k) to Krooze (for 380k)
R13 Macaffer to Roughy (ok not really a ruck trade but he has swung through there)
R16 Blicavs to Mcbean
R17 Buddy to Big Willy (via Rowe DPP)
R20 Krooze (566k) to Pav
so much for set & forget, 7 trades to fill two onfield positions just seems silly and yet due to DPP's, cash generation and donuts I am not upset with this.
R3 Kommer to Leuey (301k) (via Blicavs DPP)
R6 Jacobs to B Hill (again via Blicavs link)
R10 Leuey (449k) to Krooze (for 380k)
R13 Macaffer to Roughy (ok not really a ruck trade but he has swung through there)
R16 Blicavs to Mcbean
R17 Buddy to Big Willy (via Rowe DPP)
R20 Krooze (566k) to Pav
so much for set & forget, 7 trades to fill two onfield positions just seems silly and yet due to DPP's, cash generation and donuts I am not upset with this.
Last edited:
I'm expecting his Price to be around $310-$330k.
At that Price you can take him and nearly sit him in your R3 spot, and truly make your Rucks set and forget. Particularly if you can find a Grundy type as a cheap R2.
I say it every year, but I still can't believe people are considering HMac. I guess Sandi is nearly as bad.
Maybe just go the Whole shooting match - Goldstein, Grundy, Sandi, HMac and hope you never have to make a trade in your Rucks for the whole year!
At that Price you can take him and nearly sit him in your R3 spot, and truly make your Rucks set and forget. Particularly if you can find a Grundy type as a cheap R2.
I say it every year, but I still can't believe people are considering HMac. I guess Sandi is nearly as bad.
Maybe just go the Whole shooting match - Goldstein, Grundy, Sandi, HMac and hope you never have to make a trade in your Rucks for the whole year!