Discussion Round 1: Teams & In Game Discussion

NT.Thunder · 20 Mar 2020

NN and Hickey - Yuck

Meltingpot38 · 20 Mar 2020

Damn that has really screwed things. No more handcu***

jobeywatto · 20 Mar 2020

I really don't know what I'm gonna do now. Williams also not being named ruins things even further because I can't have Brander up forward anymore, so two gunk fwd rookies (Taylor + Cavarra/Davis/King/Sturt) will need to be on the field... YUCK.

I might honestly just keep Nic Nat. Soldo scored 100 from limited game time last night. Hopefully this is just a 1 week tag team effort against Gawn this week and then Hickey gets dropped for Williams in R2.

Meltingpot38 · 20 Mar 2020

Might revert back to the R2 i had in Jan - Sauce Jacobs

Leroy · 20 Mar 2020

Brander and Starcevic warming the bench down back. Finally sorted.

Grundogging · 20 Mar 2020

Presto said:

M2 for me but that may change tonight once I consider which elite ball users I'm going to bring in across the three lines.

Rickwood · 20 Mar 2020

Anyone else having trouble with the SC site? I can't add any players re a trade - all the "plus" signs are greyed out

bomberboy · 20 Mar 2020

I'm sticking with NN - if it's really that dire I'll flick him to Naismith soon and get some cash in the bank.

Herbie66 · 20 Mar 2020

NicNat out , McAsey out

Brander back to D , Naismith to R2 , Williams to R3 for a week

and welcome Heeney to the side

just need to leave enough in the bank for Pittonet or TDK

Seymour Skinner · 20 Mar 2020

Any validity in running 2 floating donuts now we have very limited rookies?

Thinking I take Williams out.

Swing Starcevich back.

Budarick to the mids.

And bring in B O'Connor, allowing me to swing Brander Fwd.

Leaves me with 50k. But basically 2 dead spots.

Don't rate Sturt, Davis, Bedford etc.

The Experiment · 20 Mar 2020

Seymour Skinner said:

You rate these guys less than a player who isnt going to play?

Meltingpot38 · 20 Mar 2020

Is 5 players from a team too many? Have 5 from GWS....

FirstTimer · 20 Mar 2020

Any suggestions for a Williams replacement
Has Robertson been named yet any suggestions for that spot

jobeywatto · 20 Mar 2020

I can really see Williams getting a debut next week. Maybe with his recent hamstring they're just being a bit more cautious with him. WCE probably also want to see how playing 2 main ruckmen will affect them before reassessing. I'm keeping him.

Seymour Skinner · 20 Mar 2020

The Experiment said:

Reckon I'll go O'Connor, and change Comben to Xerri, pray that he gets a gig eventually so I don't have 2 totally dead spots.

I can always use a trade to correct it next week if it becomes obvious I've made a mistake.

BigRuss · 20 Mar 2020

jobeywatto said:

No brain R3 IMO, 100% comes into the side when NN is rested. Hickey takes the #1 role and Williams slides into his spot.

Rickwood · 20 Mar 2020

Rickwood said:

took 25 mins of panic, but they started coming back

Herbie66 · 20 Mar 2020

FirstTimer said:

BZT , McAsey , Starcevich , Brander
Green , Pickett , Brown , McInerney
Williams
Bedford , Budarick , Cavarra , Davis , Georgiades , King , Sturt , Taylor

should give you enough bench options

Mahony F/M if you need a ? to take Pickett's score

The Experiment · 20 Mar 2020

BigRuss said:

How man times do we expect NN to realistically be rested over a 17 round season? 2, maybe 3 times?

AngryAnt · 20 Mar 2020

Anyone going with Mitch Hibberd on the bench rather than taking a punt on Tyler Brown who might be out of the Pies side in a week?